Should I buy it or not?

Zion_Withrow

Standing Before a Giant
Joined
May 23, 2003
Messages
150
Location
Sweetwater, Texas
I acidently posted this in the creation forum, I was not thinking. Should I buy civ 4? I love Civ3, but are the grapichs, civics, and religon worth buying civ4?:confused: Please post any opinions.
 

Darth Gromit

Chieftain
Joined
Oct 28, 2005
Messages
79
Location
Carbondale, IL
I say buy it either way. If you have an ATI card, you may have to fiddle a bit to get it to work, but if you have a reasonable system with a reasonable nVidia card, it's gonna run like a champ. And I definitely agree with RIT Beast, it's the best of the bunch, even replacing SMAC as my favorite TBS game.
 

xguild

Chieftain
Joined
Sep 27, 2005
Messages
82
The game is riddle with all sorts of minor bugs that don't nescesserly destroy the experiance, but obviously need patching. Many people have experianced moderate bugs like graphical glitches, slowness and desktop drops. Many of these types of issues can be avoided if your willing to do a clean format and XP install. Some people have reported severe virus like bugs that caused severe software failures and blue screens of death after installing the game, these are a bit more rare but I found at least 15-20 people that had these types of problems.

Outside of technical issues with video cards, obvious miscalculation of minimum requirements, miss labeled CDs, at least 30-40 minor in game bugs or oversights and of course the chance that the game will completetly crash your game, it's actually a good game if you can believe. In fact, I would easily say it's the best CIV game ever made if I wasn't unlucky enough to be one of the hundreds of people experiancing technical problems. In my case I can't load saved games, which I suppose isn't nearly as bad as some of the problems people are having but it definitly takes away from the experiance.

On the bright side, strangly enough the multiplayer is actually more stable and has less bugs then the single player game, obviously the result of Q and A testing focus.

Should you buy the game? Depends on your personal deamenor, I rushed out even after being warned of the countless bugs and technical issues and have spent the last week frustrated over a stupid game. I don't regret buying it, but I'm anxiously awaiting a patch that will hopefully fix my tech problems.
 

aquavit

Chieftain
Joined
Nov 1, 2005
Messages
23
Location
West Virginia, USA
RIT Beast said:
If you can get it to run, this is definitely far and away the best civ to date.

Agreed, although I'd wait a month or two until the patches come out. Just take a look at how many people are browsing the Technical Support forum.
 

Little Raven

On Walkabout
Joined
Nov 6, 2001
Messages
4,244
Location
Cozy in an Eggshell
In my view, SMAC is the greatest TBS ever made. It has held that title for almost ten years. I cannot yet say if Civ IV will dethrone it.

But I can say this: After three days of Civ III, it was obvious to me that while Civ III was not without charm, it would never come close to matching SMAC. After three days of Civ IV, Sid's latest offering is still very much in the running.

Of course you should buy it. Just make sure you have a machine that can handle it.
 
Joined
Oct 28, 2005
Messages
397
You can buy it if you're willing to look past the few bugs until the patch comes out. The game is great, it just needs some fine tuning for it to run perfectly.
 

Zion_Withrow

Standing Before a Giant
Joined
May 23, 2003
Messages
150
Location
Sweetwater, Texas
Thanks everbody, I think I will wait to but it. I really do not want to spend 50 dollars and have a gmae I can't even play. It is my fate that if anything can go wrong with my computer will go wrong. Besides if I wait a little the game will hopefully be a little cheaper.
 

covenant

Warlord
Joined
Jun 8, 2004
Messages
162
This game rocks. Its everything I had hoped Civ 3 would have been. Buy it, a bottle of wine and suddenly realize the sun is coming up and you didnt even realize you didnt get up to go to the bathroom.
 
Top Bottom