schwartz
King
Sounds like the typical SE vs CE debateExplain exactly how 1 spy in every city is going to beat cottages+1 spy where you can afford it. You won't get more GS compared to a CE..

Seriously though.. I think it's because it's more effective to have one SY city where you settle any GSpy that you get (Instead of making SYs all over). In the mid/late-game (Post-Democracy) the settled Spy will be worth 36

Even early on, it's worth the 12 base


Also, I think about running Specialist/Hybrid style EE (Especially with the pyramids) as a way to get the same benefits of normal tech + tech trading with less downside (WFYABTA, directly benefiting the AI by giving it a tech).
I'm open to learning here, so I'm interested in what your argument for cottages is. (EDIT2: Never mind, see your point now, even if I think both ways have their good points.)
EDIT:
lol, huge cross-post. That's what you get for leaving the computer for 10 minutes.