SunTzu's Top 10 Scenarios of All Time!

[SunTzu]

SunTzu's Top 10 Scenarios of All Time!

1. Second Front by Captain Nemo
2. The Struggle for Europe(TSFE) by Marko
3. Red Front by Captain Nemo
4. Imperium Romanum by BeBro
5. Third Reich by Michael Jeszenka
6. Age of War by Exile
7. The Thirty Years War by Jesús Muñoz Fernández
8. 2194 Days of War by Captain Nemo and Alex the Magnificent
9. Ansteig by John Petroski
10. Up the Deadly Boot by John Petroski


Honorable Mention


Birth of America(BOA) by John Valdez
Afrika Korps by John Petroski
The Cruel Sea by Case
The Battle of Austrailia by Case
Antartica by John Valdez
Raging Dragon by Case
Second Reich by Michael Jeszenka
WW2 by Harlan Thompson
WW2-Pacific by Harlan Thompson
WW2-China by Harlan Thompson
Crisis in the New World Order by Andrew Livings

These are listed in no particular order

Here's SunTzu's top 10. And Honorable Mentions
I do believe FMK's The Battle of Stalingrad scenario will make #1 spot, so when it is released i'll update this.
I urge everyone to play these scenarios. You can find them here at www.civfanatics.com
Sorry i had to promote

EDIT. I just revamped the list

 

[Case]

Here's my top ten:

1. WW2 in Europe - Harlan Thompson
2. Red Front - Captain Nemo
3. Second Front - Captain Nemo
4. Colonies III - John Ellis
5. Imperium Romanum - BeBro
6. Mongols V 3.0 - Harlan Thompson
7. Crises of the New World Order - Andrew Livings
8. Russian Civil War - Techumseh
9. The River War - Allard H.S.
10. The Cruel Sea - Case (I'm allowed to like my own scenarios )

 

[SunTzu]

WW2 in Europe by =H.T!? I'm sorry that scenario does not stand up against any other WW2 scenario. The graphics are nearly original. And its too easy to win.

 

[Field Marshal Klesh]

I do believe FMK's The Battle of Stalingrad scenario will make #1 spot, so when it is released i'll update this.

Geez man, thats some pretty stiff competition you know. And besides, my whole reason for doing this from the start was A) to have a scenario about Stalingrad to play B) I figured that I might as well do it so I could give alittle back to all the cats who's scenarios I love to play. I actually think its no where near as cool as RedFront is. Consider it a cheap Nemo-style rip off. But thanks for the kind words.


-FMK.

 

[Henrik]

(in no particular order)

• Collonies II/III - John Ellis
• Imperium Romanum - Bernd Brosing
• Red Front - Captain Nemo
• 30 Years War (version 2!) - Jesús Muñoz Fernandez
• Age of War (for PBEMs only) - Exile
• Hellas - John Ellis
• Brown Mans Burden (for MP) - Carl Fritz
• Modern Age - Exile

Scenarios i'm playtesting (and thus cannot add to the list yet) :
Stalingrad - Field Marshal Klesh
Bonaparte II - John Ellis
Armada - Jesús Muñoz Fernandez

 

[Case]

Originally posted by Henrik
Scenarios i'm playtesting (and thus cannot add to the list yet) :
Bonaparte II - John Ellis

*Drools*
Do you know when that's coming out? IMHO John Ellis's Bonaparte is the best scenario on the Napolionic Wars

 

[Alcibiaties of Athenae]

Originally posted by Case


*Drools*
Do you know when that's coming out? IMHO John Ellis's Bonaparte is the best scenario on the Napolionic Wars

John and I started playtesting a new version (revamped events file) this week.
The progress of this will be posted in MP forum, but I can give you a glimpse of the game:

France masses an army for the invasion of Britain

 

[Case]

*drools even more*

 

[TrailblazingScot]

I see people's top 10 are missing Harlan Thompson's "Lord of the Rings" scenario and no-one seems to have played my "improvement" on it called "thering" by ChrisHutch (since my computer was stolen I haven't got the file...and Mr Temba's old site doesn't seem to tranfer it properly )

Has anyone seen my scenario

 

[TrailblazingScot]

SunTzu you crit H.T's ww2 in Europe for being too easy, yet you have Ansteig in your top 10! I took America in like the 3-4th Turn...too easy

AND 2194 Days of War by Captain Nemo and Alex the Magnificent is too easy...as germany russia is gone in three turns max (and that is only because it takes time to get to the far-east of Russia!)

TSFE too difficult and unrealistic! (I'll play as allies...before I get a chance to move I always lose Ullapool and all my money...and the invasion of France is flawed too...(hardest difficulty level...yet the daft sealion happens on easier levels too)