The Set Game

[Perfection]

Nope! The answer is very straightforward, and can be expressed in three words, and it's not based on some subjective criterion.

 

[carmen510]

Aha! Even amount of vowels possibly?

Member: Lace

Non-member: Dogs

 

[Perfection]

NOPE! Right mindset though!

Member: Perfection, Love, Death, Failure, Sugar, Aliens, War, PRC, Weapons, Mr. Belgian, Oxygen, Cool, . .. .. .. ., Lace, Dogs
Nonmember: Fifty, Thunderfall, Catharsis, Hrochland, Happiness, Fertility, Internet, Pinko Perfs, Fifty-one, Daffodils, Delicious Goldfish Colors, Your Mom, A member of Perfection's set, Not a member of Perfection's set, Grass, mr. rogers in a blood stained sweater, The Set Game, My mother, Mr. French, Cocaine, Making insanely hard and stupid sets, Moderators, Dude, poop

 

[choxorn]

An even number of consonants?

Member: Member

Non-Member: Pie

 

[Perfection]

NOPE!

Member: Perfection, Love, Death, Failure, Sugar, Aliens, War, PRC, Weapons, Mr. Belgian, Oxygen, Cool, . .. .. .. ., Lace, Dogs, Pie
Nonmember: Fifty, Thunderfall, Catharsis, Hrochland, Happiness, Fertility, Internet, Pinko Perfs, Fifty-one, Daffodils, Delicious Goldfish Colors, Your Mom, A member of Perfection's set, Not a member of Perfection's set, Grass, mr. rogers in a blood stained sweater, The Set Game, My mother, Mr. French, Cocaine, Making insanely hard and stupid sets, Moderators, Dude, poop, Member

 

[dude_lewis1]

no idea of the rule......trying to get more words to see any patterns

member-Mr. Smith
nonmem-mr. addams

and if it has to do with the rule, are spaces and punctuation considered a letter/character?

 

[sepamu92]

Even number of consonant phoneme types

Member: Members

Nonmember: Cats

 

[Perfection]

Pronunciations are irrelevant!

Member: Perfection, Love, Death, Failure, Sugar, Aliens, War, PRC, Weapons, Mr. Belgian, Oxygen, Cool, . .. .. .. ., Lace, Dogs, Pie, Cats
Nonmember: Fifty, Thunderfall, Catharsis, Hrochland, Happiness, Fertility, Internet, Pinko Perfs, Fifty-one, Daffodils, Delicious Goldfish Colors, Your Mom, A member of Perfection's set, Not a member of Perfection's set, Grass, mr. rogers in a blood stained sweater, The Set Game, My mother, Mr. French, Cocaine, Making insanely hard and stupid sets, Moderators, Dude, poop, Member, Mr. Smith, mr. addams, Members

 

[dude_lewis1]

Cereally, its been 3 pages.....

Nobody's posted here in 3 days 'cuz no1 can guess it.... another hint pretty please with sugar and a cherry on top?

nouns?
Member: Pluto
Non: Sleep

 

[Izipo]

How long has this been going on ?

Is 19 days enough for you ?

Don't you think it's time already ?
You've had your fun, I won't be speaking for everyone, but clearly I'm not having mine here.

Quoting oneself maybe lame, but the point still stands.

 

[flyingchicken]

I conceded a hint when I was taking too much time with mine!

Uh... *moment of enlightenment*

No repeated consonants! NO REPEATED CONSONANTS! NO REPEATED CONSONANTS!
Member: Zaibatsu
Nonmember: Toyota

 

[Perfection]

YES!

 

[flyingchicken]

Hurrah!

Here's something rather--no, very--contrived:
Member: Toyota
Nonmember: Zaibatsu

Hint #1: αβ

 

[choxorn]

Has repeated consonants?

Member: Your Mom

Non-Member: Your Face

 

[flyingchicken]

Nay!
Member: Toyota,
Nonmember: Zaibatsu, Your Mom, Your Face

Hint #1: αβ

 

[Perfection]

sounds like two words put together

Member: Polygon
Nonmember: Poop

 

[flyingchicken]

Neigh!
Member: Toyota,
Nonmember: Zaibatsu, Your Mom, Your Face, Polygon, Poop

Hint #1: αβ

 

[Perfection]

Words that begin with T

Member: Turds
Nonmember: Feces

 

[flyingchicken]

Whinny!
Member: Toyota,
Nonmember: Zaibatsu, Your Mom, Your Face, Polygon, Poop, Turds, Feces

Hint #1: αβ
Hint #2: ←, →, ←, →, ←, → ...

 

[choxorn]

Alternates between Vowels and Consonants and ends in a vowel?

Member: One

Non-Member: Seventy-Six