Sorry if this has been posted before, I did a search and didn't come up with anything.
So, if you stick around to play a bit longer after winning a victory, then win another victory, both get saved to Hall of Fame. (In my case I got a culture victory then captured the last remaining capital for a domination win.) I believe in Civ4 only the first gets recorded, and that makes more sense.
I've attached a save file that should fall in between winning the culture victory and my assault on Gao, the last remaining capital, in case you need to replicate.
So, if you stick around to play a bit longer after winning a victory, then win another victory, both get saved to Hall of Fame. (In my case I got a culture victory then captured the last remaining capital for a domination win.) I believe in Civ4 only the first gets recorded, and that makes more sense.
I've attached a save file that should fall in between winning the culture victory and my assault on Gao, the last remaining capital, in case you need to replicate.