Wu Sangui - Villified Traitor, Opportunist, or Victim of Circumstances?

Knight-Dragon

Unhidden Dragon
Retired Moderator
Joined
Jun 25, 2001
Messages
19,961
Location
Singapore
Wu Sangui was born into a military family in the Ming province of Liaodong, in what was today's Liaoning province in southern Manchuria. His father, Wu Xiang, had been an army general. Following in his footsteps, Wu Sangui took the junshi exams and got enrolled as an officer in the Ming frontier army. Rose thru the ranks, and was considered one of the more talented generals in the late Ming army, perhaps the most brilliant.

Wu Sangui participated in the Ming attempt to raise the seige of Jinzhou, the first fortress guarding the route into China from Manchuria, in 1643. He was one of subordinated generals to Hong Chengchou, who was leading a 130000-strong Ming army to relieve Jinzhou, which was being beseiged by the Manchus. The Ming army was crushed in a series of ambushes; Wu Sangui managed to escape back to China, being of the rearguard. Manchuria was abandoned.

He was now given command of Ningyuan, the next fortress on the route in fr Manchuria, and its 40000-strong garrison. The Manchus would need to seize this fortress, as well as Shanhaiguan - the next one in line, to control a direct route to Beijing and the heart of the Chinese Empire. Otherwise they would need to make a long detour thru the Mongol steppes and attack fr the other side, going thru tough lands unsuitable for sustained campaigning. The fortresses and passes were formidable obstacles - it had taken the Manchus decades to take Jinzhou and Nurhaci, the founder of the Manchus as an organized entity had died in the attempt years ago.

But the Manchus got lucky. The Ming Empire had been beset by internal rebellions. The most significant of which was led by Li Zicheng, who had defeated several large Ming armies sent to attack him. In 1644, Li led his army and attacked Beijing, the capital. The reigning Chongzhen emperor hanged himself on a tree. The Ming Empire had just collapsed around its center. After looting the capital, Li Zicheng set off to deal with Wu Sangui and his garrison.

At the same time, a Manchu force approached fr the other direction, under the command of the Prince Regent Dorgon. Wu Sangui was entrenched at Shanhaiguan, having marched to attempt to save the capital but stopped upon hearing news of the death of the emperor. He and the Ming army was trapped between the two enemy forces...

Wu Sangui had three choices. He could join Li Zicheng, but would be villified by generations of Chinese, for allying with the killer of the last emperor of the Ming. He could join the Manchus, and together destroy Li and his rebels. Or he could just sit tight, and await destruction if the two coorperated...

The hour of decision was at hand...

Wu Sangui made his choice and allowed the Manchus to enter into China and joined forces with them to deal with Li and his rebel army. Li Zicheng was estimated to have anything between 60000 and 100000 harderned troops but morale was low as the soldiers were far from their home in the western parts of China, and Li had taken harsh disciplinary actions against his troops for military indiscipline. On the other hand, Wu Sangui had his 40000 Ming army, plus anything between 20000 and 50000 local militiamen hastily raised. The Manchus supplied another estimated 60000 men.

The Manchus joined up with the ranks of the Ming troops, and dealed a devastating defeat on the rebel forces. Wu was ordered to pursue the fleeing Li into China. And so, the Manchu invasion of China had begun, led by ex-Ming armies...

Aftermath
After the Manchus had conquered China with Wu Sangui and the other Chinese generals doing most of the fighting in S and SW China, including pursuing the last legitimate Ming claimant all the way into Burma and executing him there, they rewarded Wu and the Chinese generals with near total control of the region. Wu Sangui received Yunnan as his personal fief, and settled there with his followers and army of 50000 battle-hardened troops.

Wu had been ennobled as a Prince and was granted the title of Pingxi Wang (Pacifier of the West) soon after the Battle of Shanhaiguan. He settled down to develop Yunnan into a prosperous province and led the way for further assimilation of it into the Chinese fold.

In 1662, the Kangxi emperor came to the throne. After spending years doing away with his regents and settling his own house in order, he resolved to remove the dangerous anomaly of the Three Feudatories, as Wu and the other two Chinese generals rewarded with near-total control of the southernmost provinces were known as. In Dec 1673, Wu Sangui finally rebelled, fearing the loss of his powerbase as the Kangxi emperor had been attempting to remove the Feudatories fr their domains.

Geng Jimao joined him in the rebellion, but Shang Kexi refused to and was imprisoned by his own son, who rebelled on his behalf. These were the other two Feudatories. Wu declared it his mission to drive the Manchus out of China, and was very successful for awhile, at one time controlling all of S China. He had even declared himself as Emperor of a new Later Zhou dynasty. Many Chinese joined him.

But the Qing persevered, and the tide turned. The Three Feudatories never really got their act together and the Qing forces were able to deal with them one by one. Then in 1678, Wu Sangui passed away. His son fought on for another 3 years before being captured eventually. In the aftermath, the Manchus executed most of Wu's followers and the rebellion was finally and fully crushed...
 
A Chinese map of the Shanhaiguan pass...

shanhaiguan.gif
 
Qing matchlock firearms and a Ming cannon captured and used by the Manchus... All the armies were well-equipped with firearms and cannons - Li Zicheng had used them to great effect against the Ming armies sent to deal with him, Wu's army was part of the Ming Grand Army and was perhaps the best-equipped in China and the Manchus had drawn the most valuable resource out of captured Liaodong province in the form of Chinese artillerymen...

This was the reason why Chinese infantrymen had forsaken armor fr the late Ming times onwards, as compared with the Early Ming and earlier - the use of firearms to which the Chinese were no strangers, and of which Westerners were introducing newer and better designs. ;)

Qing1.jpg

Qing2.gif


A Mongol horsemen, like many who served in the Manchu Mongol Banners...

Qing3.jpg
 
Originally posted by XIII

{snip}

... Wu Sangui finally rebelled, fearing the loss of his powerbase as the Kangxi emperor had been attempting to remove the Feudatories fr their domains.

Geng Jimao joined him in the rebellion, but Shang Kexi refused to and was imprisoned by his own son, who rebelled on his behalf. These were the other two Feudatories. Wu declared it his mission to drive the Manchus out of China, and was very successful for awhile, at one time controlling all of S China. He had even declared himself as Emperor of a new Later Zhou dynasty. Many Chinese joined him.

But the Qing persevered, and the tide turned. The Three Feudatories never really got their act together and the Qing forces were able to deal with them one by one. Then in 1678, Wu Sangui passed away. His son fought on for another 3 years before being captured eventually. In the aftermath, the Manchus executed most of Wu's followers and the rebellion was finally and fully crushed...

This sounds rather like the story of the Tu-Sing(?) rebellion
(1850s). IIRC if those rebels had got their act together, they
probably would have defeated the Qing, and the history of
China would have been much different as (IIRC) they wanted to
modernize the country much as the Japanese did after the Meji
Restoration.
 
That was the Taiping rebellion I think; more of a pseudo-religious peasant uprising.

The rebellion of the Three Feudatories was much more serious, being of a large portion of the regular army under their control. ;)
 
Having never heard of this story before, and reading this, my opinion is that he was a patriotic man, yet an opportunist one. He knew he could play his cards later if he rebelled against the collapsed Ming empire. He was a victim of circumstance, but it certainly takes a man of wisdom to make the descision that he did.
 
To the modern Chinese, Wu Sangui was the epitome of the word 'traitor', specifically for letting the Manchus entered China in 1644. IMO, this was unnecessarily harsh, for the Ming emperor was dead and he was acting out of the necessity of survival. However his later actions in actively leading the Qing forces to conquer China was definitely overboard.

Particularly when Ming claimants (third-rate ones but legitimate nonetheless) were raising forces to combat the Manchus esp in the Yangzi valley. And then, there was Koxinga who was leading another Ming loyalist force, fr his base on an island off Fujian province (later moved to Taiwan).

He could have joined forces with any of them, and helped restore the Ming, at least in the South. But instead, Wu led the very forces who captured and executed the last Ming claimant, in Burma.

Definitely an opportunist.
 
the ming was done, so his choice was the " new legitiment" rulers or a bunch of rebels, as a warrior he most likely had more respect for the manchus than "rebel scum " and this influenced his decestion. i know the ming lasted in the south a bit longer but for all purpuses it was done. he helped the manchus finish off the ming's, but don't the chinese believe--how to word this---when a dynasty dies the new one picks a name that is stronger or tells how it beat the old one as its name? if the manchus had killed and defeated the ming was it not a " divine " sign that they were done and the manchus the legal replacements.
 
But the Manchus were foreign barbarians, the dazi, you see. If Wu had attempted to grab power for himself, he'd probably be more forgiven since he's Chinese.

Still many Chinese were loyal to the Ming; there were large volunteer forces raised in the Yangzi and elsewhere to attempt to save the dynasty.
 
Perhaps Wu was a long-term stratigist, who wanted control of China for himself. Allieing with the Manchu's who he had seen treeted thier prisoners very well, with many captured Ming Officers serving as High ranking officals, Wu perhaps thought that by allieing with them he could achieve a position of power, and then when he had a chance, throw out the Manchu's apointing im as the new Emperor. He did not support the Ming forces since the Ming were the Legitimate emperors at the time, and if they beat back the Manchu invasion, they would be restored to power, and Wu would hae lost his chance to become emperor. So he destroyed the Ming Forces, and gained a good proportion of the army behind him to take out the Manchu's, but failed. This is all but speculation, as we cannot see into the mind of this long dead General, but it was abbition that drove him to betray first the Ming, and then the Manchu's, or at least in my opinion.
 
Yes, but the point is the Ming emperor, his overlord, was dead, when he allied with the Manchus at Shanhaiguan. ;) Technically, he didn't 'betray' the Ming. He hadn't exhibited any anti-Ming behaviour earlier either; having served as an able Ming frontier general.

I guess just fr Shanhaiguan onwards, there was no turning back...
 
I was just wondering - Was there really someone called the "Duke of mt. Deer?" From the chinese movies/ series I watched - he seemed to be someone instrumental in the taking down of SangGui
 
That's a fictional character, from the Louis Cha's jingyong series. HK seems to release a new TV series drama for it every other year. :lol:

The Kangxi emperor himself was very capable and had little need of capable assistants.
 
Originally posted by XIII
That's a fictional character, from the Louis Cha's jingyong series. HK seems to release a new TV series drama for it every other year. :lol:

The Kangxi emperor himself was very capable and had little need of capable assistants.

Thanks for the info. Great article too. I always wanted to know more about Sanggui ever since I saw him in the chinese series.
 
Back
Top Bottom