Deosn't seem so origionaly though, on this other forum I am on, it;s still just what they are guessing but they are already bashing EA. The following are completely biased and opinionated:
"MAKING A WHOLE NEW GAME....off the BF2 engine. So basically, a mod?""
"This is going to ruin the entire series. The whole point of the Battlefield games was to delve into historical events and historically accurate battles, guns, vehicles, etc. It's also completely stupid how they're making this right now, since BF2 came out less than a year ago, and they're still working on more stupid patches and expansions for BF2."
"Terrible plot + Attempt to be like Star Wars + Nothing new or exciting = Failure."
"The plot sucks indeed, such a cliché. It's always some kind of natural disaster, 2-4 superpowers trying to take what's left of the resources/available land,"
"M16's into a hunk of crud that is supposed to look VAGUELY like a pulse rifle"
"just some new vehicles, maps and weapons, nothing new or revolutionary about it so far."
Of course, the game could turn out to not be bad.