by The Person:
Isn't it so that a city theoretically can reach size 42 without the use of food caravans if placed on the correct terrain?
You can celebrate to size 41 (WLTP/WLTC days). Then filling the food box is the only way to grow after that.
To grow through celebration, you must:
1. Have no unhappy/double unhappy citizens (red/black).
2. Have 50% or more happy (light blue) citizens.
3. Have food surplus of at least +1 food.
To reach 41 through WLTP days:
1. City must have 20 citizens working on terrain (e.g., zero overlap, no off-map in city radius).
2. Be at city size 40.
3. Have 20 or more happy citizens & no red/black showing (e.g., normal celebration for one day or more).
4. Have food surplus of at least +1 food.
Then you will get to size 41.
But now you will loose your celebration, because you can only have 20 happy citizens! You will now have (for instance) 16 taxemen and 5 "Elvis" (the Elviii are not really contributors of luxuries however!!!).
by Specialist290:
Largest city I've ever gotten through legitimate means (i.e. not cheating to see how high it would go w/ Cheat Mode) is 33, on my France Game.
43 for me. It required careful timing, since I didn't use a food caravan either in filling the box. It had all grassland (via transformations, except 4 wheat). It would have grown more, of course, but the game ran out.
Normally, I don't worry about anything beyond size 36, since citizen #37 and higher in a size 37+ city contibutes zero resources to your empire (you can hire only 16 taxment/scientists, and Elvii beyond 16 specialists give no luxuries).
