BOTM 64 (Napoleon, Deity) Final Spoiler

DynamicSpirit

Fear him of the pink tie
Moderator
GOTM Staff
Joined
Dec 23, 2005
Messages
6,849
Location
London, UK

BOTM 64 Final Spoiler



Tell us what happened in your game. Did you win? If you did, feel free to boast and make everyone else feel miserable!

Reading Requirements

Stop! If you are participating in BOTM 64 (Napoleon), then you MUST NOT read this thread unless
  • you have submitted your entry OR
  • you will not submit your game

Posting Restrictions
  • Do not post any savegame file from the game. Discussions and screenshots are fine but not actual games.
 
Yippee I get to be first to announce a loss... :lol: Don't think I'll be the first though would expect some victories as well.

Lots of mistakes and a few positives and learnt quite a bit so not all in vain.. :)

Plus points. Managed a few firsts.. First to Music for the GA.. First to Lib for Mil Trad.. First to Economics for GM. Later on used a Esp economy to gain a lot of techs.. Mmm think thats about it.. :lol:

Negatives.. Too many to mention.. ;) Not enough workers early.. Not realising Oracle hadn't been built!! To late when I started it but went very late. Not getting the barb cities which sprang up in the desert area. Missed out on an important one with bad rng but should have had enough troops anyway. Forgetting how deity AI can spam units..

Wars!!! I had to decide earlyish whether to go for a cultural win or to be more aggressive. Would have stood a good chance with the former but think all of my deity victories have been peaceful space/diplo/culture so decided war was the way to go.

First war was with Sury. I was forced to close borders by the AP which sent him into red fist mode. I'd settled a city hoping to get the horses by culture so packed that with LBs etc.. Mmm underestimated his siege.. So that didn't work out very well.. Killed a few of his cats but lost all of my units especially my woody 3 units which hurt. I was able to hold him off just losing the one city and once I got Roo back to pleased he would supply me with horses at a price tho.. Also bribed Shaka into the war but once his SOD got into Sury's lands I had to bribe him to peace. Waste of effort/techs there and then he went into red fist mode and I had no doubts where his SOD was coming.

Sure enough within a few turns once he was back in his lands the declaration came.. Plus side I was able to bribe Bismarck into the war and only lost an initial city before his SOD went elsewhere. Managed to eventually capitulate Sury and start on Shaka. Took back the city he had taken plus a couple of others before taking a ceasefire. Should have carried on and capped him as well as he promptly vassalled to Bismarck. Or at least taken a few more cities. Well that was about the highpoint of my game Should have gone straight after Roo at this point but didn't.. ;)

Couldn't see a way to win from the position I was in. Hoping Roo would build the UN and me somehow become more populous than Bismarck was about my main hope. Had a couple of late wars with Roo that didn't work out either. Killed alot of his units though :). So ended up with approx 24 cities and voting for Biz in the UN election to put me out of my misery. :)
 
(At 1AD, I have one city and S2 is attacking it.)

I thought it would end quickly so I took extensive notes. But it lasted a bit longer than I expected.
If I had feodalism... it would have lasted even longer.
Spoiler :
50AD actually, S2 didn't pillage the cottages and the fur; whipped a wall; a stack of 8 attackers dies, no casualties
125AD Wang Kon gifts polytheism; trade cow for fur
150AD construction researched; whip a catapult; research monarchy and feodalism; a barb city appeared near the gems (to the S)
175AD the catapult showers the enemy stack and retreats
200AD a stack of 9 attackers dies, still no casualties; S2 doesn't want peace (I don't want either); the worker goes out and builds some improvements
225AD a stack of 6 appears to the SW
250AD 6 more attackers
275AD 3 more attackers; I convert to Buddhism; only Monty won't be happy
325AD a stack of 8 attackers dies, no casualties; 4 other units go away
540AD a stack of 9 attackers dies, still no casualties; a great general appears, build a super healer

580AD Bismarck declares war on me; hope he will be more successful than S2; strange: S2 is now a vassal of Bismarck; did he ask him for help? is this usual? S2 has no other war
680AD yet another barb city to the W; no sign of Bismarck yet, the vassalage took him by surprise, but I'm confident that a nice stack should come soon
700AD a stack of 5 attackers from CS2 dies, no casualty
720AD revolt to hereditary rule
760AD S2 sends a horse archer, a chariot (he didn't repair the horse pasture though) and a maceman, things are changing
800AD Bismarck's stack appears: 3 macemen, 2 horse archers, 2 crossbow men, 1 chariot; Apostolic Palace elections, I vote for Bismarck, only cautious now

820AD Shaka declares war on me; it might help; Bismarck has sent a trebuchet and a war elephant too
860AD Shaka's scout appears to the E, this one won't help
920AD 2 stacks from S2 and Bismarck are ready; I shower the 2 stacks once each; the 2 cats die; many other attackers are coming; longbowmen are appearing
940AD 5 attackers died, 2 defenders died; wish I had feodalism
960AD 8 attackers died; 1 defender died; Shaka's stack appears: elephants, cats, chariots, impis, a total of 15
1000AD 8 attackers died; 1 defender died; still building/whipping archers; the AIs are optimistic so maybe that's why they don't touch the cottages and other improvements; apostolic vote to stop the war against me; I vote yes
1010AD the vote failed; Bismarck voted yes but doesn't want to stop
1030AD 2 attackers died, no defender died; Shaka's stack is ready, with S2's and Bismarck's; I don't have a catapult to greet Shaka with the traditional shower; I'm getting superstitious; make sure I save this turn
1040AD? conquest loss; I think Shaka's stack ended the job; should have greeted him with the traditional cat (manners > skill, once again)

So, conquest loss at 1040AD.
 
What an intense game. 30 hours of nerve wrecking fight to the end.

I got a pretty good start. Through classical, medieval and renaissance I was tech leader. I manage to lib steel and pick up economy GM. After that I went for factories, railroads and mining inc. This allowed Bismark to get physics and Montezuma to get communism.

I kept Suryyama II at friendly the whole game after I converted to his religion, which was very useful.

After libing steel I decided to attack the Americans. Soon the Aztec joined the war as well. This was the first time I was smelling victory. I was walking over them and noone liked them.

Suddenly Shaka declared war on me and the Aztecs. The Americans had peacevassaled to them. The Aztecs capitulated to the Zulu. I bribed Suryyama to join the war. I managed to capture two cities and loose one. I gave back one of the cities for peace. Soon Suryyama also made peace. The city I lost was garrisoned by 120 units during the peace. I have never seen such stack. My ambition to annex America and have enough land/pop for a win was crushed.

The German had now gotten to be a economic powerhouse. But for some reason all nations suddenly declared war on them. In a couple of turns I also joined the war. The war went well. I was smelling victory again. I had noticed that I was without oil and oil units had started to appear. I was just about to capture oil from the Germans when they capitulated to the Zulu. My victory was stolen by Shaka again. He will have to pay for this.

Soon afterwards I was attacked by the Zulu. I had a defensive pact with the Khmer so they joined the war. In this was Germany recaptured all cities he lost to me and the Khmer. As for the Zulu I captured the city he captured last war and he captured the city I captured last war. I gave back the city for peace.

After researching radio and realizing "useful, I have no oil" I decided it was time to bring out the nukes. I built some nukes and then declared war on Zulu, Aztec, Germany and America. It went well. I killed massive amounts of Zulu infantry. so much that the Khmer no longer was afraid of their military might. I only captured three cities from the Zulu. Then bribed Suryyama into the war. Germany broke free of the Zulu as they now had 50+% of zulu pop. They had been hanging at 46% for a while.

Since I feared the germans would go for a space victory still being the tech leader I gave a city back to Zulu for peace. I was thinking I could send my army to the german front. Which was not true. As soon as I was moving my army the cities started to revolt so I had to park my army there. My biggest problem in the war was fighters. If I was able to supress the fighters on air patrol I was able to nuke and paradrop to take cities without having to fight tanks and helicopters in the open. I droped many nukes.

The war against Germany went well. But a new danger was growing on the horizon. The Aztecs were going for a culture victory. and I have to fight my way through the advanced and big German empire to get to them. I had to use a lot of spies to keep my enemies from having uranium and oil. It was really exhausting to see the counter for culture victory go down every turn.

Once I had gotten past the Germans and captured a border city to the Aztecs I made peace and got an other border city. Since the Aztecs did not have ability to remove fallout I nuked their source of oil. I only had 10 turns to get to their capital. Nuking their oil worked wonders. They only had 1 fighter out of reach from my tactical nukes. I razed their capital with only 4 turns to go. I made peace soon after as I noticed that Zulu and Suryyama was starting to get very advanced.

I probably made a misstake not to build teh internet. I could have gotten it as I was first to computers. (I was teching towards mech inf as I did not have oil) Now Suryyama built it and became tech leader. Shaka was closest behind. I was lost as to what I should do. I considered a domination victory but the fight against Montezuma was to slow. (I continued a couple of turns after I razed their capital) My economy was not great. Perhaps I should have gotten ecology before robotics. Constant radioactive winds was destroying everything. But with Mining inc and Cereal mills I was having some economy. (at one time spies destroyed the bank in my corp HQ city, I was immediately bankrupted) Fighting both Suryyama and Shaka to prevent them from achieving the space race did not seem doable. I decided to got for a peaceful approach. Get a lot of workers to clean fallout and then build wealth and research in my cities. This did cause me to tech faster then them, but Suryyama had a huge advantage with the internet. But since Suryyama and Shaka was still fighting I thought I had a chance of teching up and optimizing my building of components better.

Now I noticed since Suryyama voted for me in the UN and I was pretty close. I was smelling victory again. I was very happy Montezuma build the UN and still had it. With me and Suryyama having most pop i was in a pretty good position if I could expand my pops a little. I decided to attack the americans. They had SDI but not oil, robotics or uranium. I nuked them good and they surrendered after three turns. I told my workers to build farms and all my governors to prio food.

In 1967 the world united behind Napoleon well know for nuking everyone that has ambitions to go into space. the world recognized his efforts to save us from space aliens and the horrible Aztec arts.

I built 91 tactical nukes and 15 ICBMs.
 
For the first time I played contender instead of challenger. No food was just not an acceptable handicap.

I knew Khmer would love me for OrgRel, so I went religious. I build 1 settler. Sent out missionaries (w/escorts--thanks for the copper!) Peaceful game. I was going to use a shared war if I had to, but Bismarck also voted for me and I didn't even need his votes.

Victory in 350 AD.
 
When fighting the Aztecs I nuked two cities. All that was left in them was a worker and an executive. I droped my nukes but it seems they are immortal when in a city. I almost rage quit when my wellplaned assault with paratroopers and nukes were stopped by an executive.

My first game on Deity and I'm very pleased. I do not know if I will play it again. It was exhausting.

DynamicSpirit, will you tell us now what had been edited on the map?
 
I haven't used nukes or paratroopers in years, so maybe I'm thinking of CivIII, but can't you just airdrop them next to the city and attack the executive on the same turn? Either way, thx for the info on the topic.
 
You can't attack after air dropping.

Also one of the reasons I made peace with Aztecs was that the Germans had a fleet in the only city in tactical nuke range, so I was not allowed to bomb it.
 
DynamicSpirit, will you tell us now what had been edited on the map?

The map was mostly unchanged from what the script generated. I modified a couple of things:
1. The original map gave neither you nor Suryavarnam any resources to defend yourself with. I rectified that by giving both you and him copper, and placing horses between the two starting positions.
2. I can't remember the details, but I improved the food supply near the starting area.
 
I am seriously impressed Folket, that is an epic win in the most difficult of circumstances. This wasn't a standard Deity game, I think it was harder due to the poor start area (where was the 2 gold/gems DS ;)). So if this is your first Deity win, wow!!!

On Oasis Deity, I decided I couldn't win unless I went Religious. So I targeted Oracling Theocracy, which worked great.

I didn't open borders with the 'enemies' (monty & shaka) until I had too. I was struggling though, until Sury demanded I switch to Judaism. I accepted as he already had about 1/3 of the AP votes. Ironically this meant I now shared a religion with Shaka, who I had avoided OB's with.

Sury loved me so I kept spreading Christianity to him and in the end it was just his votes and mine (I revolted to Christianity after the vote, but before the results to double my vote)

In the end I won by only 1 vote. Even though I won by Religious in 250ad with only 3 cities, I will count this as my one of my best BtS victories. It wasn't botm 52 (my best ever), but it is up there.
 
It was a very close game. I do not think I have had a game that was this close to the very end.

I could have lost very early when Suryavarman planed to attack me. Luckily he demanded mathematics from me.

I'm still kind of delirious from the victory. Before the SGOTMs I managed monarch with difficulty. I then played that one emperor BOTM which was my first emperor win. One SGOTM later I'm able to win on deity. I had no idea I would improve this fast. I would recommend playing SGOTM for everyone that wants to improve.

This was not only my first win on deity. It was also my first try.
 
I decided against building wonders. I might be wrong but the only wonder I remember building was the three gorges dam. The internet would have been great for me in this game. Eiffel tower as well since the lack of luxury resources was very painful. But if I had not spent all my resources stopping others from winning I might not have won.

I had gems, incence, fur and dye most of the game. Late game the fur obsolete. I found this to be the main challenge on the map.

My plan was to hang in there until the modern era and then win. But I noticed I did not have oil to late. If I had managed to capture the oil field from Bismark in our first war I could probably have won a domination.

How come you decided to get no more then three cities?

I tried to keep good relations with Shaka, Suryavarman and Montezuma since they all like eachother. I avoided trades with Americans since they were so hated. I avoided OB with Montezuma while still trying to keep him happy just to avoid being disliked by Bismark.

Did other also find the Korean to be crushed between Khmer and Zulu?
 
I deliberately targeted religious, and you generally don't need many cities to win that way.

In my game there were a few blocks, mostly defined by religion. Sury & Shaka, Bismark & Monty. Everyone hated Roosy, which is a little strange in itself, so I dowed him late in the game to try and get the extra support from Monty & Shaka.
 
What I was thinking is. It is easier to win religious in some way when having very few cities?
 
If you want to win religious fast, normally there isn't time to build settlers, you are building wonders (Oracle or AP) and missionaries
 
It sound very much like a hit or miss. What do you do if Suryavarman starts to plot a war against you?
 
Contender Save, 1908 Cultural loss to the ???? AZTECS???

Settled SW on the PH, built TGW to keep out the Barbs and allow me to expand without fear.
It was a surprise to see Khmer so close I kept good relations with everyone throughout.

The big mistake was breaking off trade with America when demanded by someone. I think it took him almost 200 turns to forgive me.

Due to stealing techs via espionage and skillful tech trading I was able to stay even with and sometimes ahead of the AI. I see a military victory doesn't seem likely so I go for the UN.

There were lots of wars but not for me.
Major wars/turning points:
Khmer attack Korea and vassal them.
Shaka attacks Aztec and vassal them.
Khmer attack America and they vassal to Shaka.

It becomes Shaka, Monty, and Roosevelt in one block. Sury and Wang Kon in another. Bismarck and I are independent. Shaka is a little bigger than Sury but has a little less power.
Shaka DOWs Sury three times. The first time Sury holds him off but loses a city. For the first time ever in a game (Deity no less) I pay off Shaka to make peace. I am afraid that he will get too big.
I need two blocks to hopefully get the UN win. The UN vote never goes my way but I keep hoping. Shaka is my opponent and he has grown so large that his block is the same size as Me, Bis, Sury, and WK combined.

I keep trying the UN but switch to go space. Again Shaka DOWs Sury and again he holds for a while but then starts to lose cities so I bribe Shaka to make peace. I had hoped that either America or Aztecs would regain enough cities to break free from Shaka but it doesn't happen.

It is about 1850 AD or so when I realize that the Aztecs are going culture and are within 30 turns or so. I build lots of spies but even destroying buildings and causing revolts can't slow down their culture enough. The end is just a foregone conclusion. I keep trying for space but they get their culture victory. By my estimation I probably would have come close to beating Shaka to space.

Some options I probably should have explored in retrospect were;
- going for a culture win from early on. I couldn't catch up to the Aztecs at the end but I never put any effort into building culture and always tried for GS, GE, or GSpy from my farming.

- after leaving UN I could have went for nukes and used them much as FOLKET did to weaken Shaka, then Sury.

Research for Deity was the best I've ever done, though I'm kind of amazed. I ran 100% research from approx 600AD to just about the end of the game. I lost the race to Liberalism by 3 turns to Bismark.

Finally the complaints.
As far as I can tell I was the first to Physics. I took a screen shot to document. No one else had SciMethod, though I can't be sure if perhaps the Aztecs got it at the same time. The autolog isn't much help here. But I didn't get the GS. Perhaps somehow I missed it. Not a game killer but a disappointment.

I could not build The Internet. This was part of the strategy to beat the AI to space, instead of researching, I'd be building. I checked several cities where I could build it and it wasn't shown as an option, even a grayed out option. I went to the list of wonders built and it had not been built. I checked auto log and it doesn't show it being complete.

And Lastly.... why didn't Shaka prevent Monty from getting the cultural win? Usually the AI at this level is very good about adjusting strategies and preventing the human from winning. I'm not sure I remember correctly, but if one of the human's vassals was to get a cultural win, it doesn't count as a win for the human. Am I wrong? (Please, no reason for everyone to tell me how wrong I am!)

Things I'd change in the replay:
even though I noticed the Copper pop up under Paris, I never gave much thought to an early Axe rush. Intimidated by Deity probably.

another UN strategy that I though of when reviewing this is; I wonder if I had given away all my cities but Paris to one of the AI's would it have made enough difference to win a UN vote?

@Dynamic Spirit - You must be getting soft by giving us the copper, though you tempered this kindness by also giving it to the Khmer. The Horses were a surprise to say the least as they don't normally appear on the southern half of this map. This became yet another reason to play nice with Sury when I saw he had Horse Archers.
Thanks for trying to help us out :confused:

Here's an idea, go into worldbuilder and change the playable Civ to Sury and let us try him out.
 
greatbeyond, I'm sorry fro your loss. As for UN. You do not have to avoid nukes to win UN. When you nuke someone people who are annoyed at that will not get upset. So in your game you could nuke Monty and Shaka while Khmer and Korea would still like you.

Who built the UN in your game? If it was Shaka going nukes and conquer as many other cities as possible should be a path to victory.

In my game Germany turned into an economic powerhouse that had to be destroyed twice. did they have peace your whole game while not dominating research? I wonder what the big difference was.

Personally I think you do not want to have open border with America in this game. He is to hated. If you had not had OB or resource trade he would never get unhappy for you breaking them.

Internet is a project. Perhaps you can open the save again and look under projects. It is an other "tab" in the wonders window (the small icons over where you see the list).

The AI will not try to prevent someone from winning. They will continue to play as if nothing is changing.
 
I'm still looking for that first GOTM Deity Contender win. That's why it hurts to come so close. Shaka was first and I was third just behind Sury.

I built the UN in 1775. The only way I could see me getting in the vote. I was two techs ahead at that point.

Perhaps I'm getting my Civs mixed up. I thought the use of Nukes got you a negative modifier to your rep from all civs except those you have an alliance with or are your vassals.

You are right about the Top 5 Cities/Wonders screen. I forgot all about the icons at the top to switch the view. Wayyy too much vanilla Civ I guess.

I was the only one that was never at war. There were many smaller wars that I didn't mention in my narrative. I was surprised that Bismark was able to stay independent with the two powerhouse blocks looking for easy victims.

I have seen the AI, once it has almost completed it's space ship, DOW on another Civ.
I have also seen the AI attack when the human gets close to a spaceship or cultural victory. Perhaps it's just a fluke. I wonder what's in the code?
 
Back
Top Bottom