With the number of changes made in C3C I don't know just how things are going to work out. 1.00 and 1.02 games not intentionally exploiting the gpt bug (ie. paying gold for gpt, and vice versa) are going to be acceptable.
Games which are played to exploit the gpt bug may or may not be acceptable. If a game isn't comparable due to use of the gpt bug, it will be taken out of the HOF, much like games on the larger Huge maps. To make a ruling on this, I'd first have to see what is possible with and without the gpt bug in comparably played games. Your Sid game seems to point to it being a bit overpowered, but I think there may be other methods to hit the Domination limit on Sid around the same time, once the FP and corruption issues get worked out.
I would suggest everyone use 1.12 because it is a more balanced and fun game, and there won't be any concerns about whether the game is comparable or not. (if following the rules obviously) I just don't want to force anyone to use a beta patch just to qualify for the HOF though.