Agree with these settings. As for the format i like my own suggestion giving everyone the chance to play on once from their own save instead of having to choose the winning save. Btw i like ABigCivFan's suggestion too but that's because i like the the open game format. In practice i think many players would play on from their own save making the winning save and with it the voting process relatively unimportant. SG'd be fun too but i think we could do something like that after we 've played a deity cookbook game. About reporting, CellKu provides some very good guidelines for reporting. In open games it's not really worth it to go into so much detail. here i think it's indeed important to do it this way to promote discussion about strategy.