Where's your deity guide? Or would you rather just complain about how ShadowSong's isn't good enough?
I'll write one when I can beat deity under what I consider to be reasonable settings.
What is wrong with early war?
My objection is more that the guide contains very little else. Early war is a tiny fragment of Civ 4, not the be all and end all of it.
I don't think he was all that restrictive. There is a reason that certain settings are allowed in the HoF. It's because a win with those settings represents an accomplishment. Why do we have to tear down the guide writers so much? So what if shadow turned off barbarians? I think they're a stupid part of the game, and I doubt that I will ever play a game with barbarians again.
There are many things in the HoF rules I do not agree on, which is one reason I don't take part in it. You may not like barbs, but the game is made easier when you turn them off. Hence you aren't playing a genuine deity game (though barbs are fairly minor. I have relatively little objection to them compared to for instance, permanent alliances or biased map settings).
Other than that, his settings are prety vanilla. I don't feel the need to have random maps and civs selected every time I play. In fact, I hate some of the map types, namely the high water ones, because I don't like building ships.
Please don't claim they're vanilla settings, because they're nothing like them. They're tiny maps, with at most one or two opponents, which even for the non conquest victories you're relying on all but destroying in the very early game. They all rely on having a single landmass, and hence you have a very limited selection of maps, and the navy and exploration is basically irrelevant. Several of them require a future start, throwing the tech tree and research out of the game as well.
Now I don't wish to offend Shadowsong, and if you like this kind of thing and the HoF, then good luck to you. The guide is however of little use to me as I don't consider the settings valid for a genuine win. For me to consider a win to be genuine, the following must be true:
Random map type.
Random AIs
Standard Map size or larger
Ancient age start
All victory conditions enabled
Barbarians: ON
Permanent Alliances: OFF
Did not have to restart hundreds of times to get the map.
When I can beat Civ 4 at deity under those conditions, and not by relying on ancient war, I'll be more than happy to write a strategy guide. However at the moment I can't, since I'm still working on Immortal level. Sure, I could run through the guide and get a entry in the hall of fame claiming a deity win, but it won't feel to me I've achieved anything.