Fellowship of the Ring - A Mini Mafia
- Thread starter topsecret
- Start date
johnhughthom
Emperor
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2009
- Messages
- 1,450
My vote for Dreadnought is based on him trying to come across as helpful, saying something is only beneficial to mafia is something mafia often say, and not wanting to put a vote on someone which will cause a lynch. Is this very suspicious behaviour? No, not really. But I haven't seen anything else which caused my often wonky scum-o-meter to ping.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
He just said what I was thinking. And as I find myself in Jarrema's position, which I esteem to be that of the whole of us, I am not voting anybody just yet.
A tie will be RNG'ed.
Votes:
Mat93 - 3 (Autolcyus, DaveShack, Dreadnought)
Dreadnought - 2 (johnhughthom, Mat93)
Daveshack - 1 (?)
Not Voting: Jarrema, JoanK, Verarde
Day ends in ~19 hours
@ 4 P.M. EST
Mat93 - 3 (Autolcyus, DaveShack, Dreadnought)
Dreadnought - 2 (johnhughthom, Mat93)
Daveshack - 1 (?)
Not Voting: Jarrema, JoanK, Verarde
Day ends in ~19 hours
@ 4 P.M. EST
Dreadnought
Deity
Going to make your announcement, JoanK?
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Oh. No, the person in question PMed mee and we've talked... seems legit to me.
Well, I certainly don't want to get taken down by tiebreak random numbers, from a mystery vote.
For now, vote: Mat93. I'm reasonably certain Dreadnought is good. JoanK is at least talking recently.
For now, vote: Mat93. I'm reasonably certain Dreadnought is good. JoanK is at least talking recently.
You know what?
you are right.
The most important "mission" of my vote on JoanK was accomplished (he is talking). Now it is time to move to other target
unvote
do someone care to explain why DaveShack get this mystery vote? I would understand that vote if someone was comvinced that Dave is mafia and wanted to lynch him, but I do not understand this vote and no case made against him
you are right.
The most important "mission" of my vote on JoanK was accomplished (he is talking). Now it is time to move to other target
unvote
do someone care to explain why DaveShack get this mystery vote? I would understand that vote if someone was comvinced that Dave is mafia and wanted to lynch him, but I do not understand this vote and no case made against him
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Of course I do! I feel compelled to, both for a singular circumstance and because I dont want to be lynched under the label "unuseful".
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
And, most possibly, it is any ability, maybe it is The Ring or something.
I suppose it is ability. I only wonder if it is pro-town one, and why the person who used it does not go further with vote for Dave.
It may be character-related ability. I could see Aragorn or someone else have ability of one additional vote.
It may be character-related ability. I could see Aragorn or someone else have ability of one additional vote.
Mat93
Emperor
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2012
- Messages
- 1,104
I personally don't trust the extra vote, as no one else is voting with it. If someone reveals the reason behind it, or anything about it, then we will have a clearer idea on it.
As I have no other leads, and purely for self preservation, Vote: Dreadnought.
As I have no other leads, and purely for self preservation, Vote: Dreadnought.
Dreadnought
Deity
I'm assuming the extra vote was chosen by the person randomly, because we don't have much to go with at the moment.
I can assure you, my previous post is only based on the Lord of the Rings itself. I was guessing based on the the characters.
Indeed. You have swayed my hand, good sir.
Vote: Mat93
I can assure you, my previous post is only based on the Lord of the Rings itself. I was guessing based on the the characters.
Indeed. You have swayed my hand, good sir.
Vote: Mat93
This is your 3 hour warning 
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Abstain. No clues, no nothing for me. I'll just watch for today. Interesting candidate to the lynch...
Mat93
Emperor
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2012
- Messages
- 1,104
What am I susposed to save myself from? Reasonless votes? I see a gut instinct vote, a vote to prevent someone from dieing to a RNG on a vote from someones night action (I would assume), someone saying the best lynch candidate (most likely yes, but there has been no reason to vote for me, so why am I the best candidate?), and Dreadnought saying I swayed his hand into voting for him. I read into Dreadnoughts reasoning that he caused the extra vote on DaveShack.
Have a missed a legitimately good reason to vote for me anywhere? I didn't think so. It appears the only reason is because I haven't posted much, which happens sometimes.
I see Jarrema as the most suspicious person to vote for me, as it looks a lot like he is trying to ensure I die, to end discussion and make sure he is safe this round. But what do I know, I'm only a dead man and soon to be confirmed Good.
Have a missed a legitimately good reason to vote for me anywhere? I didn't think so. It appears the only reason is because I haven't posted much, which happens sometimes.
I see Jarrema as the most suspicious person to vote for me, as it looks a lot like he is trying to ensure I die, to end discussion and make sure he is safe this round. But what do I know, I'm only a dead man and soon to be confirmed Good.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Dreadnought's post leads me to believe that he did in fact issue that vote. And, it is my opinion that if he was corrupted he would have pushed for it, or tricked somebody into that. Instead, that post makes him look innocent to me.
