Inconsistent Effect of Capturing Wonders

[floydmcw]

I am fairly sure that if I capture Stonehenge, I immediately get a monument in each city.

In a recent game I captured the Spiral Minaret and did not get the bonus for my religious buildings until the city with Minaret came out of revolt.

What's the difference? Is it wonder specific, or is there some general rule?

(Of course I'm aware that wonders with a one-time benefit like the Oracle or Taj Mahal are never replicated when captured.)

 

[6K Man]

If I had to guess, because a city does not produce when in revolt, buildings in those cities that create have no effect when in revolt.

Maybe worth testing the effects of Stonehenge and Eiffel vs. Hanging Gardens, Parthenon, and Colossus vs. religious wonders, Pentagon, and shrines? And what about 3GD or Versailles or UN?

 

[sampsa]

In a recent game I captured the Spiral Minaret and did not get the bonus for my religious buildings until the city with Minaret came out of revolt.

Surprising, from what I've noticed they always affect instantly, no matter if the city is in revolt or not.

 

[lymond]

Minaret, or any global effect wonder(except one time wonder's like HG, Taj, etc), should go into effect immediately regardless of revolt, except in the captured city. Also, you have to be in a religion, and cities will only be affected by said religion.