Dreadnought
Deity
Um, abilities don't necessarily have to be used at night.
KotOR Mafia - game thread
- Thread starter Takhisis
- Start date
Um, abilities don't necessarily have to be used at night.
Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
Whoa.
Unvote; Vote: Dreadnought
Blatant lying? Tsk tsk.
Unvote; Vote: Dreadnought
Blatant lying? Tsk tsk.
Dreadnought
Deity
How am I lying?
Dreadnaught, if you're not sith, you're making this unnecessarily difficult. It seems probable there's only one villain out there, so unless you have some super anti-sith role (and from what you've claimed this doesn't seem so) that would necessitate your immediate killing if they knew who you were, I don't understand why you don't lay all your cards on the table given your lynch is looking likely.
For yours and others information, you have been scanned as darkside.
For yours and others information, you have been scanned as darkside.
Dreadnought
Deity
Fair enough. I'm an HK-47 that can overturn a lynch once during the game. I can win with either Sith or Town, but obviously I can't side with the Sith now. My PG is to overturn the lynch in favor of the winning side, but I honestly don't care about that so I'm going to save it for myself.
Backwards Logic
Emperor Palpatine
But, there's only one HK-47 (The one Revan built), and we lynched him ages ago.
Dreadnought
Deity
I don`t have my role PM anymore, so I can't double check, but I'm fairly certain I am a HK-47 robot. Either way I'm a droid that can overturn a lynch.
mechaerik
Tuturuu!
He may be an HK-50.
OK, that's pretty comprehensive from Dreadnaught. Most other characters have been unique, which makes this strange, assuming mechaerik's right on the HK-50 thing (and if he's not, then dreadnaught's outright lying). But on the other hand, the sith have all had cover roles which have been pretty comprehensive (except the last 3 revanchists, and classical stated they had had them, but lost them somehow). So that actually increases Dreadnaught's credibility.
And Dreadnaught is almost certainly telling the truth about lynch protection, even if he's sith. It explains to an extent why he prevaricated earlier.
Further, bhuddafish says he was attacked. Now, he's an odd choice for the sith to go after, so this may be a bounty hunter, but it may mean the dreadnaught roleblock didn't necessarily stop the sith.
So. I'm convinced it's either dreadnaught or backwards logic.
If we go for dreadnaught, he'll survive today and we'll have both at large overnight.
If we go for backwards logic, he dies. If he's sith, we win. If he's not, we roleblock dreadnaught tonight, lynch him tomorrow, roleblock him again, and lynch him again and win, without loss of life.
So, unvote; vote: Backwards Logic
And Dreadnaught is almost certainly telling the truth about lynch protection, even if he's sith. It explains to an extent why he prevaricated earlier.
Further, bhuddafish says he was attacked. Now, he's an odd choice for the sith to go after, so this may be a bounty hunter, but it may mean the dreadnaught roleblock didn't necessarily stop the sith.
So. I'm convinced it's either dreadnaught or backwards logic.
If we go for dreadnaught, he'll survive today and we'll have both at large overnight.
If we go for backwards logic, he dies. If he's sith, we win. If he's not, we roleblock dreadnaught tonight, lynch him tomorrow, roleblock him again, and lynch him again and win, without loss of life.
So, unvote; vote: Backwards Logic
Backwards Logic
Emperor Palpatine
So, how is it I'm the other option when I've:
1) roleclaimed to a few players here already.
2) proven to have access to the bounty noticeboard, thus proving my neutral alignment.
3) Been scanned as grey and as a droid.
The above can be verified by a few players here already.
To complete everything about me for everyone, I'm G0-T0, pro-Republic, and at night I scan people to see how much money they have in their possession. Considering there haven't been any kills of late at all, it's fairly safe to leave me around again today (consider where the roleblocks have been targeted - I've never been roleblocked), burn up Dreadnought's anti-lynch ability (which is odd, considering he said the Sith would target him if he revealed it - they wouldn't since it doesn't exactly threaten them), and put everyone one step closer to winning now. You'd all be wasting a day with my lynch.
1) roleclaimed to a few players here already.
2) proven to have access to the bounty noticeboard, thus proving my neutral alignment.
3) Been scanned as grey and as a droid.
The above can be verified by a few players here already.
To complete everything about me for everyone, I'm G0-T0, pro-Republic, and at night I scan people to see how much money they have in their possession. Considering there haven't been any kills of late at all, it's fairly safe to leave me around again today (consider where the roleblocks have been targeted - I've never been roleblocked), burn up Dreadnought's anti-lynch ability (which is odd, considering he said the Sith would target him if he revealed it - they wouldn't since it doesn't exactly threaten them), and put everyone one step closer to winning now. You'd all be wasting a day with my lynch.
johnhughthom
Emperor
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2009
- Messages
- 1,450
Ooh, that would be fun. A hugely underrated game.
I think we need to stay on the Dreadnought lynch.
The ability to stop the lynch sounds to me like a secondary, one-use ability. I know this because I had the same ability, and used it to stop the Earthling lynch. It seems strange to me that the town would have the ability to stop the lynch twice.
Furthermore, Dreadnoughts claim to not remember his character is somewhat troublesome. I tend to keep my role PMs for games that I am still playing, even if I have to delete some other PMs to make space in my inbox. You never know when you may need the details to save yourself from a lynch.
This, taken with the poor initial defense of not wanting to reveal because he didnt want to become a target- something that doesnt seem likely with this ability and the fact that he has done little all game to seriously hunt the Sith among us leads me to believe that he is our man.
topsecret: Did you attack Buddhfish last night?
BL: Scan me tonight and tell me how many credits I have.
The ability to stop the lynch sounds to me like a secondary, one-use ability. I know this because I had the same ability, and used it to stop the Earthling lynch. It seems strange to me that the town would have the ability to stop the lynch twice.
Furthermore, Dreadnoughts claim to not remember his character is somewhat troublesome. I tend to keep my role PMs for games that I am still playing, even if I have to delete some other PMs to make space in my inbox. You never know when you may need the details to save yourself from a lynch.
This, taken with the poor initial defense of not wanting to reveal because he didnt want to become a target- something that doesnt seem likely with this ability and the fact that he has done little all game to seriously hunt the Sith among us leads me to believe that he is our man.
topsecret: Did you attack Buddhfish last night?
BL: Scan me tonight and tell me how many credits I have.
mechaerik
Tuturuu!
BSmith has a point. Vote: Dreadnought
The attack on Buddhafish is also accounted for.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
Ok, text wall forthcoming.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
Ok, here is a list of alive players:
mechaerik
Buddhafish
Backwards Logic
Dreadnought
Bsmith1068
Verarde
topsecret
Jarrema
Mergle
The Black Knigh
Gone 3 the Celt
Vote analysis isn't my thing, but here's some claim analysis:
mechaerik:
No claims about abilities or role at all, ever. If I missed it, just say something and this assessment can change.
Buddhafish:
I have claimed neutral. I have access to the Bounty Board, and I can place bounties and protections. This claim has been accepted as real, I believe.
Backwards Logic:
He has claimed to be G0-T0, one of the leaders of the Exchange, IIRC. He also has access to the Bounty Board, and has answered very truthfully to all inquiries. Pro-Republic? That's sketchy at best, but Sith? Unlikely. Plus, he was roleblocked last night, meaning that he couldn't have attacked me. That is, unless topsecret attacked me, which I will explain later.
Dreadnought:
A lynch-stopping ability claim. With an HK-47 role claim. After HK-47 has been dead for 10+ days. mechaerik pointed out that he could be HK-50, but I agree with Bsmith. I tend to keep my role PMs.
Bsmith1068:
Almost certainly a Jedi. If not, definitely Republic. I'm not sure if he's claimed anything in-thread, but he's part of the town network, and seems to be a leader of it.
Verarde:
Claimed Zaalbar, the wookie. With Mission Vao not being a cover role, and since no one has stepped up and contradicted his claim, I think it's safe to say that he's telling the truth. Is Zaalbar a main character in KotOR? If so, this further confirms Verarde as Republic.
topsecret:
Last Bounty Hunter. I don't know which one, he's never said, but he is a bounty hunter with access to the Bounty Board. And it is very well possible that he attacked me last night, as I am the only person with a valid bounty out right now. I'd be pissed if he did, since it's such a small amount of credits, but it is possible.
Jarrema:
Mical, the Disciple. He died, we saw his role, that's pretty much all I need to see.
Mergle:
Same deal as Bsmith. Most likely a Jedi. If not, definitely Republic. A member of the town network, and one of the leaders of it along with Bsmith and Earthling.
The Black Knigh:
I don't have much to say here. He claimed Republic a long time ago, and we really haven't checked back with him since. If he's claimed a specific role, I've missed it. But why would a Sith have a resurrection ability? They would most certainly want to resurrect Sith, not Republic, and if a Sith died and was reborn, the town would just lynch them again. Doesn't seem likely that he's Sith.
Winston Hughes/Gone 3 the Celt:
Winston/G3tC is a Hutt. THrough Wookiepedia, maybe Zax the Hutt? I think he was in KotOR. Anyway you slice it, he's neutral, he's a Hutt, that's about it.
With all that, mechaerik, Dreadnought, and The Black Knigh don't have role claims or actions out there that confirm them as one thing or another.
Until all step forward and provide more info, Vote: Dreadnought, as he seems most likey to be scum out of the three.
mechaerik
Buddhafish
Backwards Logic
Dreadnought
Bsmith1068
Verarde
topsecret
Jarrema
Mergle
The Black Knigh
Gone 3 the Celt
Vote analysis isn't my thing, but here's some claim analysis:
mechaerik:
No claims about abilities or role at all, ever. If I missed it, just say something and this assessment can change.
Buddhafish:
I have claimed neutral. I have access to the Bounty Board, and I can place bounties and protections. This claim has been accepted as real, I believe.
Backwards Logic:
He has claimed to be G0-T0, one of the leaders of the Exchange, IIRC. He also has access to the Bounty Board, and has answered very truthfully to all inquiries. Pro-Republic? That's sketchy at best, but Sith? Unlikely. Plus, he was roleblocked last night, meaning that he couldn't have attacked me. That is, unless topsecret attacked me, which I will explain later.
Dreadnought:
A lynch-stopping ability claim. With an HK-47 role claim. After HK-47 has been dead for 10+ days. mechaerik pointed out that he could be HK-50, but I agree with Bsmith. I tend to keep my role PMs.
Bsmith1068:
Almost certainly a Jedi. If not, definitely Republic. I'm not sure if he's claimed anything in-thread, but he's part of the town network, and seems to be a leader of it.
Verarde:
Claimed Zaalbar, the wookie. With Mission Vao not being a cover role, and since no one has stepped up and contradicted his claim, I think it's safe to say that he's telling the truth. Is Zaalbar a main character in KotOR? If so, this further confirms Verarde as Republic.
topsecret:
Last Bounty Hunter. I don't know which one, he's never said, but he is a bounty hunter with access to the Bounty Board. And it is very well possible that he attacked me last night, as I am the only person with a valid bounty out right now. I'd be pissed if he did, since it's such a small amount of credits, but it is possible.
Jarrema:
Mical, the Disciple. He died, we saw his role, that's pretty much all I need to see.
Mergle:
Same deal as Bsmith. Most likely a Jedi. If not, definitely Republic. A member of the town network, and one of the leaders of it along with Bsmith and Earthling.
The Black Knigh:
I don't have much to say here. He claimed Republic a long time ago, and we really haven't checked back with him since. If he's claimed a specific role, I've missed it. But why would a Sith have a resurrection ability? They would most certainly want to resurrect Sith, not Republic, and if a Sith died and was reborn, the town would just lynch them again. Doesn't seem likely that he's Sith.
Winston Hughes/Gone 3 the Celt:
Winston/G3tC is a Hutt. THrough Wookiepedia, maybe Zax the Hutt? I think he was in KotOR. Anyway you slice it, he's neutral, he's a Hutt, that's about it.
With all that, mechaerik, Dreadnought, and The Black Knigh don't have role claims or actions out there that confirm them as one thing or another.
Until all step forward and provide more info, Vote: Dreadnought, as he seems most likey to be scum out of the three.
Dreadnought
Deity
You think I'm Sith because I accidentally deleted my role PM? Seriously?
You've never used the "check this box to select all PMs" to delete before? Accidents happen.
I'm overturning my lynch by the way. If you want to drag on this game further, feel free to lynch me. I'm sticking to my voting and posting patterns to show that I am not Sith.
You've never used the "check this box to select all PMs" to delete before? Accidents happen.
I'm overturning my lynch by the way. If you want to drag on this game further, feel free to lynch me. I'm sticking to my voting and posting patterns to show that I am not Sith.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
I didn't say the case was conclusive, I just said that you were most likely to be Sith.
So mech, could we all have a roleclaim?
So mech, could we all have a roleclaim?
