Mafia Game: Those Darn States (Game Thread)

[pevergreen]

I don't use 100% lightly.

:shrug: I dont care either way, but he will die.

 

[Verarde]

Yes, choxorn can have the hat. I don't see why not, he is usually on the good side.

Now for the lynch, hmmm. I will follow the lead of ATPG, so SS-18 ICBM.

 

[Love]

Ok. I'm going to let you know that last night I scanned Takhisis as Tokugawa of the Japanese Axis Faction.

You know the guys that killed civplayah.

 

[Verarde]

I thought the Prussians killed Methos...

 

[Love]

My bad. Civplayah.

 

[Nictel]

I don't use 100% lightly.

:shrug: I dont care either way, but he will die.

If you are talking a vigilante kill, that would be a serious mistake.

Ok. I'm going to let you know that last night I scanned Takhisis as Tokugawa of the Japanese Axis Faction.

You know the guys that killed civplayah.

Ah proof. Takhisis.

 

[Renata]

Takhisis

 

[RRRaskolnikov]

Pevergreen, would u mind telling me more (PM maybe?)... Love knows he shouldn't lie about Takhisis , so I will trust him for now.

 

[pevergreen]

You have done nothing to deserve extra infomation.

Nictel is not town aligned.

 

[TheLastOne36]

Wait wait wait... Hold on a second?

Tokugawa? In WWII?

Something is obviously wrong here Love or the GM made some very very random roles for this game.

 

[Love]

Well nor is captain america. Don't be stupid.

 

[TheLastOne36]

That's right. =\

Takhisis than.

 

[Arakhor]

Well, wasn't Captain America created during WWII?

Pevergreen, telling people you have extra information and then not sharing it simply makes you look like an arsehole, whether you are Mafia or not.

Based on Love's information (assuming that he even survives tonight), I'll also vote for Takhisis.

 

[pevergreen]

Pevergreen, telling people you have extra information and then not sharing it simply makes you look like an arsehole, whether you are Mafia or not.

Difference in playstyle.

Naming people incorrectly is always fun though aint it Arakhore?


Simple logic guys. Roles are revealed on death here (I normally don't get that luxury).

I have become a conduit for infomation. I'll place myself on the line here, if I die, its not like the town loses anything important.

Either the info is good, you lynch Nictel and it proves it, or you don't and its ambigious. If you lynch him and the info is wrong, I'll die for it.

 

[Kennigit]

It's not WWII only. John C. Calhoun is not WWII.

I'll go with the Takhisis bandwagon, changing my Perfection vote

 

[pevergreen]

Hi Pevergreen!

You have done nothing to deserve extra infomation.

True... same as you. Still I am not claiming illogical stuff in the game thread, asking people to blindly trust me.

Nictel is not town aligned.

You are doing it again... How do you know what kind of alignments there are? Even with a scan, you can't have scan enough people to know the big picture...
Maybe if you tell me from where come the info, I will be more trusty and talk more as well (I can exchange info about Renata and me). I hope we can work together.

Raskolnikov

First point: Lets say someone reveals to you that they can investigate people. Theres no ironclad way to rule yes or no, so you have to test the info out. On the possibility that the person is pro-town, wouldn't it be a good idea to, ya know, shield their identity from the mafia? A basic townie role acts as a conduit, providing the face. Shields the power role and allows the info to get out.

Second point: How do I know what alignments there are? Well, in the basic sense, there are: Town, anti-town and neutral. Inside of that, sure you get individual objectives, cults, multiple mafia family situations and everything else. But neutral is not pro town. I've seen (and created a few) neutral roles that can go either way. Simple fact is, he is not town aligned, therefore he is not good. In the absence of any actual evidence, the random voting gives way to the idea that instead of randomly lynching quite probably a townie, we could lynch someone not aligned with the town.

 

[RRRaskolnikov]

OK since you act as a conduit for everyone (including mafia), I won't tell anything to you Pevergreen...

maybe by telling everyone what was in a PRIVATE message you think you are achieving something... I myself think you discourage people from telling you anything. Good luck to you

Ras

 

[Autolycus]

Lead on, Love. Takhisis/Tokugawa must go.

 

[pevergreen]

OK since you act as a conduit for everyone (including mafia), I won't tell anything to you Pevergreen...

maybe by telling everyone what was in a PRIVATE message you think you are achieving something... I myself think you discourage people from telling you anything. Good luck to you

Ras

you said you asked in thread, in post 188, I see no real question there.

I don't see the point of potentially having the same discussion multiple times in private, I simply don't care enough to do that.

Think of it like this. Say you like playing basketball. You've played with a group of friends for 3 years. Apart from 2 or so months, you've been playing every single day. Some of your newer friends say, "Hey pever, come over to this new place, its fun" so you go over and start playing, but its new people, new rules, new things expected and new ways of doing stuff. Sure, its still basketball, but its not as fun. Shooting the 3 pointer may have been cool at your old court but here its a no no.

Also, seriously. There is no capital 'p' in my name.

 

[SS-18 ICBM]

Surely Japan has reason to reduce US presence in the Pacific. While there's nothing inherently wrong with games of state, current methods leave something to be desired. Takhisis.