Rate Conquest!

[Yoda Power]

you get the point..

 

[Civrules]

Man, we've had so many threads like this and I will always give it the highest score. Is it perfect? No, no game is perfect. But is it the most fun from all the Civ series? Yes, yes it is. That's why I give it a 10/10.

 

[Padma]

9/10. Only because it is not perfect. I love this game.

 

[zurichuk]

9/10 excellent game (but won't give it 10 because they can do even better)

 

[tigerden27]

8/10, it will be 9 when the patch comes out and fixes the few bugs I've experienced.

 

[Oddible]

9/10 same here - could it be perfect? Well, no, its software alas.

But seriously - these Conquests scenarios are so excellent - providing balanced games out of the box - fun from many angles (playing the underdog or the historical winner). Lots of variety - different units and concepts in each conquest. Not only that, but lots of great balancing changes made to the random games too.

Did they fix some of the diplomacy issues that arose in vanilla Civ3 that got nixed in the first patch (like the fact that you could never get a civ to give one of your cities back after they help you liberate it from an enemy while in an MPP)? Haven't tried yet.

 

[Colonel Kraken]

9/10 This is simply an outstanding expansion pack with so much content and a core game that has come so far. Yet, I cannot give the 10 out of 10. Firaxis simply cannot give up their pig-headed ways and provide some basic, Basic, BASIC items to the game that are sorely needed and have been begged for for far too long.

But alas, I have grown used to its inadequecies such as they are. Nobody can have every feautre they would like, but certainly there are a core few that have nearly unanimous support that are not included in Civ.

Oh well.

Here's to hopin'.

--CK

 

[Master Ray]

8/10. Once a patch is out probably a 9. I am surprised so many bugs got through the public beta testing.

 

[SuperBeaverInc.]

9/10, but that could be biased towards the best game in the world

 

[vbraun]

9/10 If there is new software there will tehn be new bugs.

 

[Hunter]

8 for sure

Amazing game and the best Civ I have ever played but I felt a few small things were missed so for now only 8.

PS:
it must be said that I almost never give 10 so they only lost one point in my mind.

 

[Plug]

While Civ Conquests is a good addition to Civilization 3 I am surprised you are all willing to give Firaxis such high marks.

The Forbidden Palace redistributes corruption, rather than relieving it, bug is enough to drop Civ Conquests below 5 points for me.

Also, the pack seems a little rushed and I think some of the new artwork (such as the new bonus resources, terrain tiles and the craters) looks a little substandard.

When we get a patched Conquests I will consider raising my mark up to 8 or 9 but due to the many problems I will only give it 4. The Forbidden Palace bug has really spoiled it for me since it will seriously affect my high scores (that is, current high scores will not fit neatly with post patch high scores).

 

[General Porkins]

Absolutely love the game...9/10 bc of a few of the bugs but overall it is awesome

 

[Mano3]

9 - Almost perfect!

I must say that I like the Conquests, as they are shorter than the full-blown games. I also like the history focus in each Conquest.

 

[Mongoloid Cow]

I voted dunno/dont have the game/etc.

 

[Quentin]

8. But only because i always try so hard (and fail miserably) to get myself away from the game. Its taking over my life. LOL

 

[Yoda Power]

Originally posted by Mongoloid Cow
I voted dunno/dont have the game/etc.

Then you should properly state which of the options are correct

 

[Hygro]

I voted 9 as I feel while it's really really awsome, there are still features I want that aren't there, such as setting up specific diplomacy for a scenario.

 

[Doc Tsiolkovski]

Let's see...

10 for the Conquests
9 for the epic game (love the traits, but don't like the new bombard, no plagues)

Averages to 9.5

-1 for the distribution - I absolutely understand and accept any delay until it went 'Gold', but I fail to understand why it was available 2 or 3 weeks later in many countries
-2 until the FP/GPT/SGL name bug is patched

 

[baktakor]

Because of the Multiplayer. The game itself is somewhat divine! Or should I say SIDious!

But the missing info-menues in MP suck.