Redefine the titles?

Joined
Jan 25, 2002
Messages
3,005
Location
Northern Ireland
I think that it is time to change the boundaries for the titles. You know Cheifetan ---> Deity. Because i see a lot of people with Emperor :mischief: and Deity titles when the real senior members should be people like Dell and AoA with 4k+
Thise spammers in the RPG don't deserve to be at the same level as them......and me :p

Just a thought?
 
Mine says "Moderator". :p

:yeah:
 
Originally posted by anarchywrksbest


I hope that wasnt a one line post with several smilies? Where is my spam checklist?! :mischief:

:eek:
Cor, you are really pushing it. What with this and your joining CFC thread in OT....AoA is going to get you...:mischief:
 
I have no need for fancy sounding titles :mischief:

I dn't really see the point hough, it's not like anyone uses the default titles anyway.
 
Originally posted by mordhiem
I dn't really see the point hough, it's not like anyone uses the default titles anyway.
I do :p


Originally posted by anarchywrksbest
I think that it is time to change the boundaries for the titles. You know Cheifetan ---> Deity. Because i see a lot of people with Emperor and Deity titles when the real senior members should be people like Dell and AoA with 4k+
Thise spammers in the RPG don't deserve to be at the same level as them......and me

Just a thought?

I think you'll find that with the way the RPG is going, those "spammers" will have much higher post counts than AoA and Dell in a very short time anyway :rolleyes:
 
most of the biggest post counts come not from soamming but the democracy and RPG games which involve many posts per turn.
 
Those Demo Games and RPG are really just an excuse for spam, IMO... Shaitan and several others have in excess of 5000 posts, even though they haven't been here that long. I don't think the posts in that RPG should count. It's crazy.
 
Who cares what someones post count is anyway? I think thats one thing TF should have not brought back.

Mine is higher than Lefty's (who has been here MUCH longer than I have). Does it mean anything? No. :p

Personaly, I like the custom titles (see above left). :D
 
Originally posted by Ohwell
Those Demo Games and RPG are really just an excuse for spam, IMO... Shaitan and several others have in excess of 5000 posts, even though they haven't been here that long. I don't think the posts in that RPG should count. It's crazy.

The demo game is certainly not spam. Have a read through it, and even the Civ II one.


@Lefty: The RPG section is not an integral part of of the demo game. It is a forum where people can (loosely) pretend to be living in the Civ III world, where they can run shops, banks, set up sports teams etc etc.

The "problem" is that this forum has only been in existance since late august, yet has attracted over 10,000 posts. The majority of these posts are very short - one or two lines. Eg "I'd like to by an assault rifle. I believe this costs 100 gold", or "I'm starting a football team. Who wants to play?"

It is the short nature of the posts that make them seem spammy, even though they are pretty much all "on topic". It is however a pretty effective vehicle for generating a high post count in a short time (check out the top 50 all-time posters, see which ones have joined this year, and see where they post most frequently :rolleyes: ). A few exceptions to this though....

It obviously appears to be annoying some people, and even those from the demo game proper IIRC. I personally have mixed feelings on postcount - its not that important to me, although I get annoyed reading the spam that appears to function solely to increase PC (Humour and jokes is a bit like this nowadays). The most effective solution is simply to avoid the RPG forum (at least its nicely self-contained). :)
 
Postcount is interesting but nothing to be worried about. Important things about postcount: 300 for custom avatar and 30 for custom title, which brings me back ON TOPIC. Maybe the default titles should be added to? I believe you used to have a lot more like Archer or something, maybe some of these should be re-instated but have higher postcount needs for high levels like Emperor etc? Possibly 2000 for Emperor and 3000 for Deity?
 
Even the MP will become "spammy" in a good spam sense with the PBEM games. I've noticed joespaniel's post count catching up to mine! :eek: ;)

BTW, at the rate the Civ3 demogame is going (about 5,000 posts per month!), it's gonna have 100,000 posts in a year an a half! I say "at the rate it's going", simply because of the many short, and cancelled turn chats... :)
 
Originally posted by Alcibiaties of Athenae
Mine says "Moderator". :p

:yeah:

Mine does too. :yeah:
:D
 
show off ;)

i dont get why everyone is so bothered about postount sure its nice to have a higher number but it doesnt really make that much of a difference most of the longer term posters know who the better quality posters are and arnt to bothered about the people with higher postcounts than them
 
well, in fact whether something is spam or not depends on the standpoint.
i believe the rpg-members do not think their posts are spam.
rpgs naturally need more posts.

but wouldnt it be good to just dont count those posts in the postcount?

or well, maybe a better idea: hide the postcount! or delete the titles! or both!

are you so number-centric? well, you should learn to judge people from what they say and do instead of from their titles.


Disorganizer
Knight of Lancre
Baron of Ankh
Demogame Chat Operator
Owner of the "Rebel Pub, Distillery and Brewery"
Former UN Representative of Fanatika
Former Mayor of Bavaria
 
The demo game is certainly not spam. Have a read through it, and even the Civ II one.

Well actually I meant the RPG only, the Demogame is not spam. I didn't meant to put that in.

But the RPG, please, it's insensible. Those posts should not count. "I'd like to buy an assault rifle" ??? CMON!! That may be ON TOPIC but it is absurd.
 
Originally posted by Chieftess
Even the MP will become "spammy" in a good spam sense with the PBEM games. I've noticed joespaniel's post count catching up to mine! :eek: ;)
:mutant: oops...
It gets a little boring in between turns, sorry. :o I will keep the non-game related chit-chat down from here on out.

However, the "got it" posts do add up...

Maybe we could use the chat room instead of the board. I will suggest it to the other players. :)
 
I busted my arse making Emporer in the days when you had to do serious stuff like argue with Greadius and add jokes to the thousand clues list. In the past two months I went from around 200 posts to 1000. Sure, PBEM forums add spammy inflation but there is no way you can take my title!

What if we simply added ranks beyond Deity? I know it would break with Civ titles, but I mean, I can't wait to be a Deity...
 
so why is the title so important for you guys?
ok. the first few posts to get custom avatar and things, but the rest?
just dont show the postcount and title on the name. that would solve many problems, because it would also solve the problems of newbies not being taken serious in some threads ;-)
 
To me, reputation counts first. PC and date joined only give some ideas of what to expect but ultimately I'll go by reputation. For e.g., I always eagerly read Vrylakas' posts. Always very interesting. :goodjob:
 
Back
Top Bottom