If I'm going to be responsible for it I'd probably prefer a straight subscribed SG as that's the devil I know (but only from reading SG threads). An OSG can probably work well in a large community where there's always likely to be someone around to pick it up. In a smaller group like this Mac forum I feel we need some commitment from a team of named players to "own" it. What say you?
As I understand the format, we play 10 or 20 turns each, with up to 48 hours between players (24 hours to post "Got it", 24 hours to report and upload). At worst case speed and playing to 2050 this means the game could run for 100 or 50 days. Realistically we could be in for a month or so of elapsed time.
In order to find a format that we can commit to for this sort of period, please can everyone who is interested post preferences for the following game parameters. In a few days, when we can all see our responses, I suggest we try and agree whether there is any compromise game setup that will hold enough people's attention for this length of time.
1. SG or OSG:
2. Preferred difficulty level.
3. Preferred world set-up
size:
land mass/water:
climate:
temperature:
age:
barbarians:
4. Preferred civ:
5. Preferrred opponents:
"Random" or "don't care" are valid answers for any or all of the above.