Well, unless I'm missing something, those 5 possibilities I laid out are the only ones, so time to figure out some night action plans
Marcher is always either Paranoid or Scum, and Arakhor is always either Naive or Scum, so what they do is irrelevant
In any world where I'm not scum, I will scan Marcher and Bianca as scum, Gamez and Arakhor as town, so I should scan Argon. If I'm sane, I'll read him town, if I'm insane, I'll read him as scum.
If Gamez not scum, he always sees Argon, Bianca, and Marcher as scum, but he'll read Arakhor and me as town if he's Insane (since if he's insane we're scum) and he'll read us as scum if he's paranoid, so he should scan one of us
If Bianca not scum, she always sees Argon and Marcher as town. She sees Arakhor as scum if she's Sane and as town if she's Naive, and she'll see Gamez and me as town if she's Naive, or if she's Sane and we're town, but she'll see us as scum if she's sane and we're scum.
Argon is confirmed not scum. Argon has already seen Marcher/Bianca town. If he's insane, any one of me/Gamez/Arakhor he scans will come up scum. If he's naive, he will scan all three of us as town. If he's sane, he always sees Arakhor scum, and depending on which one of me and Gamez is scum, he'll see one of us as town and one of us as scum.
The scum likely kill Argon, though, since he's confirmed town. They never kill Arakhor, since dead Arakhor confirms the scumteam is exactly Bianca/Marcher, while one of Bianca and Marcher dying confirms Arakhor is scum. The various Arakhor teams never kill Marcher, since that confirms Arakhor scum and since Marcher is the Paranoid cop if Arakhor is scum, he gives no useful information with his scans.
Actually, wait, no, if the scumteam is Bianca/Marcher, if I scan Argon and Gamez scans either me or Arakhor, they are now forced to kill one of us; both of our results would confirm them as the scumteam, and we couldn't be the scumteam, so both of us getting to reveal our results is a guaranteed loss for them. Argon always gets a scum result in this case, but that tells him only either that he's insane or sane. In that case, it would make the most sense to scan either me or GamezRule, not tell us which one, and hope he scans the same one the mafia kills, which would confirm him as Insane and confirm Bianca/Marcher as scum.
If Arakhor/Gamez or Arakhor/Me killed Argon, that would confirm Arakhor is scum; Town Marcher/Bianca already know Arakhor is scum, and either my result (if I'm town) or Gamez' result (if he's town) would confirm the scumteam to us, so if one of these scumteams kills Argon, Arakhor is 100% the lynch tomorrow, then if Bianca got lucky and is the Sane cop and saw the other one of Gamez and Me as scum that's basically game; in any case either of these scumteams almost always kill Bianca N3, leaving F3 of Marcher/Me/Gamez, with Marcher maybe knowing which one of is scum if Bianca got a scum result on N2
If Arakhor/Gamez or Arakhor/Me killed the one of Gamez/Me that isn't town, then Argon scanning me/GamezRule would confirm the scumteam if he scans the one of us that dies (since he'd then know either he's sane or naive which results in the Arakhor/survivor scumteam, or he's insane which results in the Bianca/Marcher scumteam). If he scans the one of us that survives and gets a town result, that confirms he's the naive cop, which confirms the Arakhor/survivor scumteam; if he gets a scum result, that confirms he's either the sane cop or the insane cop but doesn't tell him which one he is.
Arakhor/Gamez or Arakhor/Me could plausibly kill Bianca, though that again confirms Arakhor is scum; the townie of me/Gamez knows the other is scum, while Marcher doesn't know much and Argon could possibly know what the scumteam is depending on his result; If he's Sane, and he scanned the one of me and Gamez that is scum, then like the world where Argon was the nightkill and Bianca got a scum result, that's basically game; in any case, Argon is always the N3 kill, again leaving a Me/Marcher/Gamez F3.
To sum up:
Marcher, Arakhor- do whatever
I scan Argon
Gamez scans either me or Arakhor, which one he chooses his irrelevant
Bianca and Argon should both scan either me or GamezRule, and critically, do not tell us which one you're choosing to scan, to stop the mafia from countering you with a nightkill (either of you, or of killing in a way that doesn't tell us much about your scan)
Depending on who dies and what results Bianca and Argon get, you hopefully should be able to tell who's lying and who's not lying.
I see little reason to lynch today because I don't know who's telling the truth or not, although I totally understand Marcher and/or Bianca voting for Arakhor, or Arakhor voting for one of them.
Vote: No Lynch
