@PH 1,2,3... i know there is really nothing you or anyone can do about it...
4. Archaon and the other everchosen unite chaos for a little while... and the rest of the time they fight amongst themselves...
5. I agree chaos should be a horde... a horde who has 90% weak units and only 10% strong units... (to attack cities with... etc) since cities look to be the weakest part of how Chaos works... Chaos has never taken Kislev city.. its only taken Praag twice... and who cares about Praag, everyone knows its a speedbump
6. By massive im not talking about slaves im talking about the number of freemen/women etc that chaos must have to field such a large army (i would hesitate to say but there population would have to be larger than the empire to justify such large amounts of men... let alone feed them when there not united, or equip or replace casulties...
7,8 To support such a large population there must be enough land to feed all those people i talked about in point 6. Now people may say they raid for there food... i say no... they cant raid any areas that are truely fertile... Kislev can sustain its population but i would imagine it couldnt do alot more... And Naggaroth.. well lets not even bother... Cathay... im not so sure about... but it would corrospond to China.. and the north of China is not the most fertile land ever.. (all the lands they can raid are not that fertile...)
So that begs the question where do they get there food from.. the wastes are grassland/plains some of the more southerly tribes have taken to Farming... most of the Northen tribes havent there still herders...
With such a large population even if it spread over a massive area (which the lands of the Tribes of Chaos are..) they must be to some extent fertile... enough to grow grass and basic crops..
For an example of why crops are important... look at Horses most western mounts cannot just live on grass they need oats etc.. looking at the minatures of Mauraders there mounts dont look like ponies (however in some canon/black libary publications they are described as that...) horses are not easy critters to keep they need to be shod, feed, watered, kept out of the rain, kept warm, have there coats checked etc.. (they also represent an expensive piece of kit)
There must be fertile land to feed the people or there herds and by proxy the people (life may be hard... but i would imagine constant tribal warfare etc makes it alot harder) the Chaos wastes are big, and the ranges that the tribes work over therefore must be big (look in the Chaos army book for those ranges) the wastes are warm (Chaos related warmth btw) there are areas where its Chaosy...
Really to field such a large army, have such a large population, maintain large amounts of horses/live stock and farm the land the Wastes must be fertile...
(i dont know... but i would think the wastes are wastes because there not to hospitable to people from the Old World.. with all the chaos worshippers running around, the land might not be fertile by our standards.. but it would be in its own twisted way...)
9,10 I agree with that.. easier that way
12. Slaves... hmmm i need to do some reading up on that... i know they have them... i just want to be able to draw some rough conclusions about exactly what percentage there might be inside the wastes... a fairly large one in the south i would imagine...
4. Archaon and the other everchosen unite chaos for a little while... and the rest of the time they fight amongst themselves...
5. I agree chaos should be a horde... a horde who has 90% weak units and only 10% strong units... (to attack cities with... etc) since cities look to be the weakest part of how Chaos works... Chaos has never taken Kislev city.. its only taken Praag twice... and who cares about Praag, everyone knows its a speedbump

6. By massive im not talking about slaves im talking about the number of freemen/women etc that chaos must have to field such a large army (i would hesitate to say but there population would have to be larger than the empire to justify such large amounts of men... let alone feed them when there not united, or equip or replace casulties...
7,8 To support such a large population there must be enough land to feed all those people i talked about in point 6. Now people may say they raid for there food... i say no... they cant raid any areas that are truely fertile... Kislev can sustain its population but i would imagine it couldnt do alot more... And Naggaroth.. well lets not even bother... Cathay... im not so sure about... but it would corrospond to China.. and the north of China is not the most fertile land ever.. (all the lands they can raid are not that fertile...)
So that begs the question where do they get there food from.. the wastes are grassland/plains some of the more southerly tribes have taken to Farming... most of the Northen tribes havent there still herders...
With such a large population even if it spread over a massive area (which the lands of the Tribes of Chaos are..) they must be to some extent fertile... enough to grow grass and basic crops..
For an example of why crops are important... look at Horses most western mounts cannot just live on grass they need oats etc.. looking at the minatures of Mauraders there mounts dont look like ponies (however in some canon/black libary publications they are described as that...) horses are not easy critters to keep they need to be shod, feed, watered, kept out of the rain, kept warm, have there coats checked etc.. (they also represent an expensive piece of kit)
There must be fertile land to feed the people or there herds and by proxy the people (life may be hard... but i would imagine constant tribal warfare etc makes it alot harder) the Chaos wastes are big, and the ranges that the tribes work over therefore must be big (look in the Chaos army book for those ranges) the wastes are warm (Chaos related warmth btw) there are areas where its Chaosy...
Really to field such a large army, have such a large population, maintain large amounts of horses/live stock and farm the land the Wastes must be fertile...
(i dont know... but i would think the wastes are wastes because there not to hospitable to people from the Old World.. with all the chaos worshippers running around, the land might not be fertile by our standards.. but it would be in its own twisted way...)
9,10 I agree with that.. easier that way

12. Slaves... hmmm i need to do some reading up on that... i know they have them... i just want to be able to draw some rough conclusions about exactly what percentage there might be inside the wastes... a fairly large one in the south i would imagine...