[142.3] Bug or intended? Brandenburg gates gives +20 exp when upgrading a unit

[Pep]

It seems Brandenburg gates gives +20 experience to upgraded units. So, if you upgrade a chariot archer to cavalry you get +40 experience (2 promotions). It's an intended effect of Brandenburg gate or a bug?

 

[Thalassicus]

This appears to be a vanilla bug, and I'll see if I can work around it. Thanks for bringing it to my attention!

I use the vanilla "GlobalExperience" field. I suspect Firaxis forgot to check if the new unit is actually new or is the result of an upgrade. I'll replace this field with one that works properly.

 

[Pep]

This appears to be a vanilla bug, and I'll see if I can work around it. Thanks for bringing it to my attention!

I use the vanilla "GlobalExperience" field. I suspect Firaxis forgot to check if the new unit is actually new or is the result of an upgrade. I'll replace this field with one that works properly.

I've made a test on version 147.4 and the bug also affects Militarism policy.
In the first image you can see a Ship of the Line before the upgrade. In the second you can see it upgraded to an Ironclad and with 50 more experience points (20 Brandenburg + 30 Militarism).

 

[Thalassicus]

Thanks, I think I fixed these for v148.5.

 

[Pep]

Thanks, I think I fixed these for v148.5.

The bug is still in v148.6. I've attached a savegame if you want to test it (just pick a horseman near Seoul and upgrade it). Maybe it's not fixable without the source code.

In this savegame you can also see the oil on ice is present in v148.6: http://forums.civfanatics.com/showpost.php?p=11431866&postcount=5.

EDIT: Removed the savegame because I'm near the quota limit.

 

[Pep]

I've tested this bug again in v154 and it's now fixed (both Brandenburg and Nationalism finisher) .