300

I remember I did see 1 guy in the formation who did not have a sixpack. :p

Actually they had eightpacks. That was impressive of how beefed up they were to play these Roles.

BTW, I have seen it while it is due in the theatres tomorrow. I will see at the big screen, but saw it on my brother's computer. I really do not see why so many people are so worried about the exaggerations that are made in the movie and thus the Graphic novel. Clearly it is a retelling of an event through the eyes of a certain group of people. Clearly it will have taken some liberties at what really happened and thus you should expect it to happen.
 
It is kind of disturbing how often this happens in American movies. Even Aragorn killed messengers!
About killing messengers:

That's actually in Herodotu's original. The upshot of that was otoh that it angered the Gods, and to make amends two Spartan volunteers set of to the court of the Great King to offer up their lives.

The Great King, who is always depicted as supernaturally generous (worked fine for him, as he used it agressively, to assert his superiority), was impressed with their moral stature and resolve and so pardoned them, allowing them to return home.

This kind of highlights the superiority of the ancient Greek version of events. Killing messengers was an act of hubris. Messengers are outside of the conflict. When the Spartans did this, it was a crime, and the Spartans recognised that and the need to pay for it.

Of course, these Spartans were asked by other Persians why they had offered their lives like this, of their own free will. And the Spartans replied that is was exactly because they were free men, only subject to the laws of their society. This the Persians, according to Herodotus, found entirely inexplicable, as they were all "slaves" of the Great King, whose only law was the whim of their ruler. They had no concept of being free in the Greek sense (in the Greek version of things).

That's the opposition in the ancient Greek version: Freedom and law against despotism and whim. But if the despot is a good man, his subjects are virtuous and his rule good, like Cyrus. Unfortunately that kind of godlike power tends to corrupt, and lacking the laws of the Greek to rule them, the Persians would fall prey to the same weaknesses as their ruler, like Xerxes (not to mention Cambyses, who is depicted as stark raving mad).

What's so compelling about the ancient Greek version is that the story is tragedy - both sides are noble, chivalrous and corgeous, but set on the destruction of each other. Of course the Persians have a single, but fatal, flaw, and this gives the Greek victory.

Too bad Hollywood (or at least it doesn't trusts its audience to) can't grasp the idea of tragedy anymore, and make it into drama.
 
Lord of the 300 rings was a Good film by entertainment value but it is sad when such rich history is being downgraded to this level , why must Hollywood try to dumb down these kind of films ? I Remember several old Epics ( including Gates of Fire , a more realistic look at the Battle of Thermopoiles) and they were all done masterfully . If The Epic has truly died then Directors shouldn't try these kind of films.
 
Whilst I remain within the "It's Just A Movie" Crowd, I did read a review about the film in the local newspaper here which stated that:
300 brings to life Frank Millers comic-book retelling of the story of the 300 Spartan warriors who bravely fought to the death defending democracy against an invading Persian Army of Millions. A valuable lesson in our troubled times
I'm paraphrasing from memory but the bolded part is spot on :crazyeye:
 
My review of 300.

It was awesome. They used incredible images, the slow motion was perfect, and the fighting was gloriously done. The ending was also pretty cool. I have no problem with historical inacuracy, after all it's a movie, they're allowed to be creative. However I did not like how some of it was pure science fiction; first of all, humans cannot be deformed or mutated like that. Second, elephants are not that big. Thrid, you can't train a rhino, they're way too stupid.

Overall 4 out of 5 stars.
 
I thought it was just plain awesome, my friends and I all came out of the film wishing we were spartans!
 
Back
Top Bottom