Elemental gets more leeway from me cause its actually a brand new series.. Civ V has had 20 years of history to build on.. just because the designers decided to toss the majority of that doesn't mean i give them more rope. I would give them more leeway if they would have started a brand new series but "rebooting the series" doesn't count to me.This is the Gamespot headline and it seems to be echoed by most of the bigger sites (i.e. those who have more to lose by giving a false review than they have to gain by buttering up a producer). I'm therefore unsure why there is any love for this game, given the response to Civ V. Could the lovers enlighten me?
Elemental on the otherhand is a brand new game on a brand new engine.. It takes alot of elements from MOM but it doesnt claim to be a sequel. Also stardock doesn't make me download steam. Civ V is just an amalgam of little annoyances that have made me fed up with it. If it were just bugs or just steam or just removed features or just balance issues i could deal.. but all of the above.
Not to mention they are giving away the first DLC to everyone.. and the first 2 DLCs for those users who had to deal with the terrible launch.and the CEO takes part on the discussion of issues etc.. actually shows people he cares (even if he does get pissy sometimes)