did hitler really said this?

[firas_new1]

I heard that he said something like “I did not kill all jews , I left some alive so people can know why I was killing them”

is it true?

 

[firas_new1]

another thing
if it's true it should be mentioned in his book Mein Kampf (My Struggle)

 

[7ronin]

I can not find any evidence that Hitler said anything remotely like this. Mein Kampf was published in 1926/1926, long before Hitler was in a position to bring about anyone's destruction. In any case, Hitler insulated himself from the details of such actions. Neither he nor Goering nor Himmler were present in December, 1941, at the Wannsee Conference at which Heydrich discussed with relevant members of the German government how to implement the "Final Solution" to the Jewish problem.

 

[Agent327]

I heard that he said something like “I did not kill all jews , I left some alive so people can know why I was killing them”

is it true?

Your quote (if that's what it is) proves its own falsehood (unless it's a partial quote): it's a quote after the fact. (He might have said something like: "I don't want people to say that..." etc, as Hitler was very concerned with his rôle in history.) Though it was certainly Hitler's intention to kill all Jews, he already might have known at the time this would be an impossibility - if for military reasons alone; the Final Solution (Endlösung) envisioned by the Nazis would always be limited to the Jews under their control.

Apart from that, the "quote" isn't Hitler's style of speaking or argueing. (It would be helpful, though, if you had an actual source - but, to be true, I doubt anyone exists.)

I can not find any evidence that Hitler said anything remotely like this. Mein Kampf was published in 1926/1926, long before Hitler was in a position to bring about anyone's destruction. In any case, Hitler insulated himself from the details of such actions. Neither he nor Goering nor Himmler were present in December, 1941, at the Wannsee Conference at which Heydrich discussed with relevant members of the German government how to implement the "Final Solution" to the Jewish problem.

The Wannsee conference was, as you say, about the implementation - i.e. the decision itself had already been taken (by Hitler, who made sure no records of this decision were on paper, as he was fully aware how this action would be viewed by the public, both in Greater Germany and abroad.)

 

[firas_new1]

ok before I say anything remember that English is not my native language and know that I’m using a dictionary now to translate some words in the reply’s

I can not find any evidence that Hitler said anything remotely like this

me too, thats why I asked

Mein Kampf was published in 1926/1926, long before Hitler was in a position to bring about anyone's destruction

thanks for the good point

Your quote (if that's what it is) proves its own falsehood (unless it's a partial quote): it's a quote after the fact. (He might have said something like: "I don't want people to say that..." etc, as Hitler was very concerned with his rôle in history.) Though it was certainly Hitler's intention to kill all Jews, he already might have known at the time this would be an impossibility - if for military reasons alone; the Final Solution (Endlösung) envisioned by the Nazis would always be limited to the Jews under their control.

Apart from that, the "quote" isn't Hitler's style of speaking or argueing. (It would be helpful, though, if you had an actual source - but, to be true, I doubt anyone exists.)

I’ll be frank with you, I’m from the middle east and Arabic is my native language, I just translated the Arabic sentence which I recently discovered that it’s a little bit popular around some Arabic webpage’s

but as far as I noticed it’s not mentioned in serious historical sites, I generally found it in the signature of some members in gamez forums

 

[philippe]

could you tell us more on the Jewish image and history as seen in the local media of over yonder?

 

[Godwynn]

another thing
if it's true it should be mentioned in his book Mein Kampf (My Struggle)

Might be in his Zweites Buch?