[R&F] Do you think to intimidate us with force?

[MarkJohnson]

I forgot to denounce Catherine De Medici before declaring war. I have plenty of time, so I decided to camp on her border for the 5 turns, then DoW with less penalty.

Next turn after denounce, she says Do You think to intimidate us with force? etc.

One of the options is, You were right to worry (Declare War)!

Is this an option to declare war with less penalty, or no penalty? Or do I still get an insane war penalty to declare war right now?

 

[Trav'ling Canuck]

It'll be a surprise war if you declare from that screen.

Ignore her and declare using a Formal War when it becomes available.

 

[MarkJohnson]

It'll be a surprise war if you declare from that screen.

Ignore her and declare using a Formal War when it becomes available.

That figures. I ignored it. Then I seen a roaming barb builder, so I captured it. Then there was a French settler next to it and I couldn't resist it, so I DoW her the following turn. lol Then another settler, but a barb one this time and another barb worker.

But they should change that options in that DoW. It makes it sound like there will be no penalty as it wouldn't be a surprise war any more, since she was asking for the war.

 

[Chefofrats]

She is not asking FOR the war, she is asking you what your troops are doing on her borders. "You were right to worry" is YOUR answer, it has nothing to do with her wanting a war. It would be ridiculous if you could create a legitimate casus belli lowering warmonger penalties by brazenly amassing troops at somebody's borders. If anything, it should increase penalties.

 

[MarkJohnson]

If I select you were right to worry, it declares war. Then I get egregious war penalties. If I wait then I just get severe surprise war penalty.

But it's not really a surprise if she's asking me is it? She is well aware of the possibility. It should be the same as denouncing first.

The correct answer is to lie and say my troops are passing by, or select ignore her.

I just selected ignore and she pulled her troops back to the city ASAP.

 

[Trav'ling Canuck]

The correct answer is to lie and say my troops are passing by, or select ignore her.

If you say your troops are just passing by and then declare war (or don't move your troops away) you get the relationship penalty for breaking a promise.

If you ignore her, you get the relationship penalty for refusing to make a promise, but that penalty is less severe and goes away quicker.

Mind you, if you're going to go to war and eliminate her anyway, it doesn't really matter which you choose, as both only involve your relationship with her, not other civs, unlike the warmongering penalties.