Attached is my dxdiag.
Here are my e-mail correspondences with a Firaxis techie. I think it shows pretty well what the problems I'm having are, the steps I've taken to fix it so far, and the utter uselessness (thus far) of said Firaxis techie.
ME:
I am so disappointed. You have published a lemon. I and hundreds of others
(
http://forums.civfanatics.com/forumdisplay.php?f=159) are having video problems that affect our ability to play the game. I haven't even been able to play one turn, and my laptop meets the minimum requirements (and most of the recommended requirements) and has all of the most up-to-date drivers. I want my money back. Down with Civ! Down with Sid Meier! Your legions are quickly falling into anarchy and rebellion. And it serves you right for releasing a lemon.
TECHIE:
Could you please send us your dxdiag file?
Thanks
ME:
Attached is my dxdiag file.
The bug I'm having is this: the game starts up fine, I can see and hear the opening video, I get the main menu, etc. I can start a new game and the world loads. But then, within a minute, the game freezes. The music eventually stops. I have to do a hard reboot of my machine to be able to do anything else, though. Ctrl-alt-del, alt-tab, ctrl-Q, nothing works - just a press and hold of the power button to shut down. In the game itself, sometimes I get to the first window where it says "your people have placed
their faith in you" or whatever, and I get to hit the Continue button before it freezes. Sometimes I don't even get that far. I've yet to see the world map (mini map in the lower corner shows up fine) - the main section of the screen just appears black, with some sort of picture icon (I presume for one of my starting workers/soldiers/settlers?).
I'm pretty sure the issue is with the game being compatible with my ATI Mobility Radeon 9200 hardware or driver, given that whenever I sent a trouble report to Microsoft, it told me that the problem was with the driver. Microsoft would then show me one of two different errors/solutions. One of the errors was a generic "go see ATI's site and make sure you have the updated driver" (which I did, and it turned out I already have the most up-to-date driver), and the other was this one:
http://oca.microsoft.com/en/response.aspx?SGD=67e2d500-14a9-49ab-8c87-97f1fdf914c1&SID=11. I followed the link on that page for this error: Error Message: STOP 0x000000EA THREAD_STUCK_IN_DEVICE_DRIVER (Q293078), and then I followed the directions to fix it. Unfortunately, Civ4 won't even run on zero acceleration, so that solution was a dud. I did try upping the acceleration one pip at a time, and finally got it to run when the acceleration slider was about halfway to full, but it ran poorly (flickering images, e.g.) and it still froze within a minute of starting a world.
Then, I sought help by searching the Web to see if others had similar problems and found solutions. Well, as you know, I found many folks with similar problems, and many more folks with different problems, but precious few solutions.
I eventually found this link, which I believe is the only official fix out there with regards to ATI video problems:
http://www.2kgames.com/civ4/support_ati.htm. I wasn't convinced it was the right solution for my problem, but I gamely gave it a go. The uninstalling/reinstalling of the game and the driver (in the order suggested) did not fix the problem. Not only that, but I was experiencing more pronounced stuttering of the sound and video (whereas before, I had hardly any), and the game took a lot longer to load. Adding the Art Pack did not fix the freezeing problem, either (but the world did load quickly again, and the sound and video stuttering had ceased). If anything, the freezing was occuring more quickly.
I have now uninstalled the game, and I would very much like to know either how I can get it working properly, or how I can get my money back. I have now spent some seven or eight hours just trying to get this darn thing to work (such is the love and devotion Civ fans have for their games), and I am ready to start asking Firaxis to pay me for my time.
I would also like to recommend that Firaxis games not supply its testers with top-of-the-line computers having only one set of hardware among them, because the teeming masses of Civ-lovers out here have vastly diverse computer hardware and generally don't have the most up-to-date hardware, either.
Thank you,
JMM
TECHIE (turnaround time for this response was 12 minutes):
It looks like your video driver (for MOBILITY RADEON 9200) has a date of 3/25/2004. I would definitely recommend updating the video driver.
Also, your audio driver (for SoundMAX Digital Audio) has a date of 3/17/2003. Check for an available update if possible.
Let me know if either of these updates helps.
Thanks
ME:
Regarding the video driver:
When I access the drivers site for my particular Vaio, it tells me that there are no updates to the original ATI driver that I have (
http://esupport.sony.com/perl/swu-list.pl?mdl=VGNS170&UpdateType=Updates). When I was following Microsoft's instructions, however, I checked for the original drivers (
http://esupport.sony.com/perl/swu-list.pl?mdl=VGNS170&UpdateType=Original) and noted that although mine was dated 3/25/04, the one listed as the original on the aforementioned url was dated 7/8/04. Not terribly new, either, and the version number was identical to the one I had, with the exception of a "d" at the end (
http://esupport.sony.com/perl/swu-download.pl?mdl=VGNS170&upd_id=1572&os_id=7). I downloaded it, anyway, and installed it (even though the Update Driver tool indicated that it had the best driver). For whatever reason, my computer still said the version number without the "d" along with the 3/25/04 date. Then, when I performed the instruction set from your support site (
http://www.2kgames.com/civ4/support_ati.htm), I deleted my ATI driver. When I reinstalled, I used the same file that I had previously downloaded from my Vaio support site (
http://esupport.sony.com/perl/swu-download.pl?mdl=VGNS170&upd_id=1572&os_id=7). That is the current version that I have on my machine, and I have no idea why it still has the date 3/25/04 instead of 7/8/04.
To be brief, I have the most updated video driver for my hardware currently installed.
Regarding the audio driver:
Now, even though I haven't really had any audio problems, I took a look at the Vaio support site for my audio driver, as well. According to their Updates section (
http://esupport.sony.com/perl/swu-list.pl?mdl=VGNS170&UpdateType=Updates), there are no new audio drivers for my system. When I looked at the original equipment page (
http://esupport.sony.com/perl/swu-list.pl?mdl=VGNS170&UpdateType=Original) and then clicked on the ADI SoundMax Audio Driver link (
http://esupport.sony.com/perl/swu-download.pl?mdl=VGNS170&upd_id=1571&os_id=7), I found that the version number is the same as the on I have, just with a few more digits tacked on at the end. Oddly, the date for this driver is also 7/8/04 (same as for the video driver). I downloaded the driver and clicked Update Driver in the device manage for this device, and it claimed it had the most up-to-date driver already (this also happened when I did it earlier for the video driver, and it turned out that reinstalling the video driver didn't change the date or any of the other stats of the video driver).
To be brief, I think it's fair to say that I have the most current audio driver installed, as well.
(Why do I feel like I'm doing a lot of the work that the Firaxis testers should have done before shipping this product?)
Anyway, what's next?
If you can't solve this, then please tell me how to get my money back. Most stores won't let you return software once it's been opened, you know. I bought this from Amazon. I'm not sure what their specific policy is. What will Firaxis do for me if Amazon won't accept a return?
(There has since been no response.)