I think this guy is just a bored troll.
He asks obvious, noob-ish questions, then lambastes everyone who gives him advice, telling them that they don't know what they're talking about, while staunchly defending the most asinine strategic blunders as "solid".
In
this post, he brags about being an Immortal player who has considered writing Deity walkthroughs, yet in this current thread, he can't seem to beat Noble, after 60-some tries. So, he's obviously a lying, rude braggart (a wonderful combination) or a troll (not that there's all that much difference, really).
I can't believe I wasted five minutes of my life being trolled by this guy and contributing to this stupid thread, but there it is.
And this is the first time in many years of reading CFC that I've ever seen Dave McW post anything but the most helpful, concise tip in any thread he's contributed to. I actually had to do a double take. That was my first sign that this guy is a huge troll. Seriously, just go through his posting archive. It's quite obvious that he's here to insult, belittle, and ridicule, not to talk about Civilization.
And to PreLynMax: I'm no saint. I've trolled internet forums and caused massive flamewars, going all the way back to the early 90s in UseNet. I've been banned from numerous high-profile sites. But I've never once trolled CFC, because I respect this forum and site. It bugs me that you don't. This is the one community that I've ever really respected, and it's because everyone here is friendly, helpful, polite, and almost endlessly patient. You're the exception. Don't ruin the one site that I legitimately enjoy. I urge you to live up to your first post and delete your account today. I'm amazed that CFC is so lenient as to allow you to troll these forums for so long (over a year??), but I doubt that you're going to be welcome here for very much longer if you continue this abusive, rude attitude. Just leave. You hate it here, and you're not liked.