Well, to me it was horrible. On so many levels, first and most important of which being that it felt like a death sentence to Civ franchise. I draw many parallels with Sim City (I actually mentioned simcity 2000, my error, I meant sim city 4), as I had exactly the same feeling with Rev that I once had with Societies in 2007. I grew bored with it after the first city and never used it again.
Societies was an attempt to bring a complex game into a "fun realm" as you like to call it, but in essence it was an exercise to dumb down the game so that casual gamers would like it (and buy it) which ended up being a total fiasco, just as Revolutions was. Who played Revolutions? You did, but you are a Civ fan, how many people from the large majority of console owners do you know that replaced NHL/NBA/Fifa/NFS gaming habbit with Revolutions? I know of none (though there might be some, but not enough to call it a success), because their focus is not on strategies, their focus is on quick-fix fun which Civ will never offer unless you convert it to some franken-FPS. So how many simcities were there after Societies? Glowing ZERO (I am not counting even dumber handheld versions). Let face it, had Rev been a blockbuster success we would not be looking at PC Civ5, but instead would be looking at Rev2.
If you want me to tell you that Revolutions was not fun to the more casual of us here, I wont do that, simply because its not true; I am absolutely 100% confident that you and many others who think Civ5 is not dumbed down had tons of fun with Rev. Good for you. But I am not a casual gamer, I like to flex my brain muscle more than I crave for instant-gratification (which, btw, when I do need surely wont look for in Civ).
That all being said, I still must emphasize that I am not against Civ5 in any way, shape or form. I am ecstatic it is coming out. All the MAJOR things that are needed will be there, the hex, the 1upt, the combat mechanics, the policies engine, etc. All those things would be hard or impossible to retrofit into a game, everything else is fixable.
So what I am trying to tell you all is to lighten up a bit, who cares if its not the über Civ out-of-the-box, if there is enough interest, and there is, it will be made great for everyone. The CIV lives on, that is the most important thing we get out of Civ5. It wont DIE like SimCity!
CIV5 FTW!