Is this a miracle?

MobBoss

Off-Topic Overlord
Joined
Oct 28, 2005
Messages
46,853
Location
In Perpetual Motion
http://www.breitbart.com/news/2006/07/03/D8IKQCEO0.html

Doctors have their first proof that a man who was barely conscious for nearly 20 years regained speech and movement because his brain spontaneously rewired itself by growing tiny new nerve connections to replace the ones sheared apart in a car crash.

How exactly do nerves regrow? I didn think they could. So, would this unexplainable medical phenomena qualify as a "miracle"?
 
Usually, a miracle of that nature would require a full recovery, not a partial one.
 
warpus said:
No, it wasn't a miracle - there was no supernatural intervention here.

*cough*...errr...how do you know?...I mean really. If the reason is undefined, then you dont know thats the case now do you?
 
well, why would god rebuild his nerves but not fully.

god is kind, and would fully heal him if he wanted to.
 
No-nerves can partially regenerate if given therwapy, or even if just left alone-look at Christopher Reeve.
 
MobBoss said:
*cough*...errr...how do you know?...I mean really. If the reason is undefined, then you dont know thats the case now do you?

Miracles today become logical explanations tomorrow. Example: Greek mythology.
 
MOR DTAYLS PLZ

"The nerve fibers from the cells were severed, but the cells themselves remained intact," unlike Schiavo, whose brain cells had died, said Dr. James Bernat, a neurologist at Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center in New Hampshire, who is familiar with the research.

Nerve cells that have not died can form new connections; for example, nerves in the arms and legs can grow about an inch a month after they are severed or damaged. However, this happens far less often in the brain.

The new research suggests that instead of the sudden recovery Wallis seemed to make when he began speaking and moving three years ago, he actually may have been slowly recovering all along, as nerves in his brain formed new connections at a glacial pace until enough were present to make a network.

Oh, and insert obligatory reference to earlier threads where I have talked about the brain growing new I/O connections. El_Machinae will remember it.

I'm not going to comment for a while.
 
Yeah, I remember.

While it's not technically a miracle, it's still pretty amazing. During MobBoss's biology education, it was a dogmatic mantra that nerves could not regenerate. We know this is not entirely true, but the dendrites growing around scar tissue to access old sources is still quite amazing. Only in the last few years has this dogma been shattered (with the finding of neural stem cells and all)

And it's a good reason to realise that you're never too old to learn new tricks.
 
What is a miracle?
 
Any recovery is a miracle, IMO, even if only partial and explainable.
 
*CivGeneral awaits word from the bishop's and the cardnial's investigation on this.
 
What is a miracle?

Something we haven't explained yet? :mischief:

Yes nerves can regenerate. Still this is pretty frickin amazing. And therefore I would like to class it as a miracle. Under my definition of the word, anyway :D
 
Depends on your definition of miracle...

...I'd say yes...considering the circumstance... (whether or not supernatural forces were involved).
 
Is this a miracle?

Scientifically and medically, no. There's a perfectly sensible explanation.

For the long-suffering patient and his family who had been caring for him for all these years, yes.
 
I don't think the information provided shows if it was a miracle or not. From my definition of a miracle anyways which does involve divine intervention. I would say only the person in request for the miracle and God know for sure. It's pretty amazing but even as a Christian I don't generally try looking for miracles except an occasional rhetorical prayer for one maybe.

Depends on the definition of miracle too. I believe God works through science. If science can explain it, is it a miracle? If not, all of God's miracles can be explained and thus aren't miracles. It's a miracle God puts up with us. There is the miracle.
 
Back
Top Bottom