Jimmy Neutron Mafia- A Small Mafia Game

[bestrfcplayer]

UPDATE TIME

When the citizens of Retroville gathered around, they chose Mergle.

Yoshiegg 737 was innocent! He was Jet Fusion!

The town was not happy with the result, and had a tough time sleeping that night.

9/20
1.Mergle
2 GamezRule
3. choxorn
4. civplayah
5. NedimNapoleon
6. electric926
7. classical_hero
8. robbiecon
9. SouthernKing

Dead
11/20
1. mechaerik -Innocent, Brobot
2. Red_Spy-Neutral, Mr. Giggles the Clown
3. Kennigit-Libby, Innocent
4. Jarrema-Eustace Strytch-Mafia
5.CELTICEMPIRE-innocent-Sheen
6. Verarde-innocent-Nick Dean
7. landlubber-Carl Sheenster- Neutral
8. General Olaf- Carl Weezer- Innocent
9. Skwink-innocent- Cindy
10. Earthling-neutral-Brains
11. YoshiEgg737-innocent-Jet Fusion

NIGHT 7 (I think) WILL END ON MONDAY AT 8PM (It's Monday because I'm going to have a busy weekend).

 

[choxorn]

When the citizens of Retroville gathered around, they chose Mergle.

You may want to consider fixing that typo.

 

[choxorn]

You give yourself extra time because you know you're going to busy, and can't even meet the extended deadline? For shame.

 

[classical_hero]

This game is dead due to the host not being active enough.

 

[Verarde]

Well, my offer still stands. Now I'm dead. I'll wrap up this game if ya'll PM me your role PMs and other important information, like QT links.

 

[bestrfcplayer]

FINAL UPDATE.

As the town of Retroville gathered around, they discovered that classical hero has been killed! He was an innocent! He was Mrs. Fowl.

And with that, the Mafia win! Congrats to Mergle, electric926, Jarrema, choxorn and SouthernKing! Finally I get this game done. (I don't think that I'll be hosting another mafia game any time soon

 

[GamezRule]

One mafia for for every four players?

 

[landlubber]

I think that there were way too many mafia. Typically, as a rule of thumb, hosts say one mafia per 6 or 7 players. There's a game going on at the .org right now with even only 1 mafia per 10 players. 1 mafia per four players is very excessive.

 

[GamezRule]

Also, I might as well tell you. I was only invulnerable from the first mafia attack against me. I only quoted part of my role PM. I left out the last little part.

 

[choxorn]

I completely agree, we were totally overpowered.

And we had some other abilities in addition to our kill. Here's the mafia role PM:

You guys are the Retroville Mafia who are led by King King Gobot (Mergle). The other members are Professor Finbarr Calamitous (electric926), Eustace Strytch (Jarrema), Baby Edward "Eddie" Neutron (choxorn) and JunkMan (SouthernKing).

Roles:
-King Gobot: Your role is Converter-Can convert ONE person. Instant fail if used on certin people (Jimmy, Goddard, Brobot)
-Fiinbarr Calamitous: -Role: Instaint Kill- Can use this role when trying to night-kill someone. CAN ONLY USE ONCE!!!!!!! USE WISELY!!!!!!!!
-Eustace Strych: -Role: Scanner-Can scan somebody to see what faction they are (Innocent, Neutral)
-Baby Eddie: -Role: Cuteness-Can stop an innocent/neutral from using their role. Only works once.
-The JunkMan has no role.

Of course, this balances out a bit when you realize these did us almost no good at all- Mergle attempted to convert Celtic and found him non-convertible, electric used his ability on GamezRule the night he survived and we forgot to send in our normal kill (we were planning on using both kills at once to see if it would work, and it probably would have), Jarrema obviously died quickly, and I never actually used my roleblock.

Even so, that we had them while the innocents had an apparent complete lack of abilities? Completely unbalanced, in addition to the numbers advantage we already had. And then there were 3 neutrals (at least... I don't suppose you could post some role PM's for us, bestrfcplayer?). The Mafia to Town Ratio was roughly 1:2. That's utterly ridiculous.

Bestrfcplayer, don't take this personally, but you're really bad at hosting games. First, there's the aforementioned balance issues, but there's also the long unexplained gaps in time (and it should be mentioned that he only updated sometimes because one of the mafia PM'd him to do so), the failure to do anything about the inactives, and the general failure to make the game enjoyable for anyone. I know that I'm certainly not going to play in any future games you host until you get better at it, and I imagine several other mafia players agree with me. How can you get better? Well you can start by asking other people for balance help and not hosting games when you know you won't have time for them. And just host tiny vanilla games if you really have no clue how to do that.

Also, Mafia QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/UVMJEcCVn37

 

[GamezRule]

Yeah, I basically completely lost interest in the game and stopped trying to win. Not like it would have been all that hard.

I hate townie power roles, because then people actually follow my vote. XD

 

[choxorn]

Not like it would have been all that hard.

Only because at the end, we weren't even trying to act like non-mafia any more.

 

[GamezRule]

I wouldn't know, I stopped reading the thread.

 

[classical_hero]

This game was totally unbalanced.

 

[Zack]

How was this game so unbalanced?

I FREAKING TOLD YOU HOW TO SET THE GAME UP, MAN!!!! AND YOU COMPLETELY AND TOTALLY IGNORED IT!!!!





Reviewing a game for balance is tedious and time-consuming. It really irks me when you completely disregard my suggestions.

 

[Earthling]

All I had to work with. (entire Role PM below) No victory condition even after asking so I'm guessing it was really same as town. The other neutrals I'd guess were the same because landlubber was extensively interrogated and had no abilities or victory goals.

Does seem like there were a lot of mafia, they quickly controlled the lynch after killing the active players at night, but at least they saw it through, well done.

You are the Brains. You are a vanilla neutral neutral.

Still, interesting setting/list of characters at least. Not easy to guess anything about the show other than Gamez being the main character.

 

[Zack]

Oh, it's my turn to host. Yippee!

 

[Zack]

CLICKY!