Kingdom Come: Deception (Game Thread)

[pzelda]

The order is in order of suspicion. You are where you are because I consider Csargo, Samson, and GamezRule more trustworthy than you and Tim, G1K, ts, Tak, and Jo more suspicious than you.

Thanks, the formatting is little confusing and I'm a bad reader sometimes.

 

[topsecret]

@pzeldq
I'm not buddies with MJ and switched (with agreement of a few others) to create a thunderdome... But then you switched to Argon. Right now he's ahead with a few votes.

If you want, I am fine with switching to MJ and being the one who lynches him. I am no more confident in Argon, but I'll vote for either. If I tie it up on MJ, he gets lynched. Would that convince you we aren't scumbuddies?

I honestly don't know who is mafia but I think one or the other is.

 

[topsecret]

@pzeldq
I'm not buddies with MJ and switched (with agreement of a few others) to create a thunderdome... But then you switched to Argon. Right now he's ahead with a few votes.

If you want, I am fine with switching to MJ and being the one who lynches him. I am no more confident in Argon, but I'll vote for either. If I tie it up on MJ, he gets lynched. Would that convince you we aren't scumbuddies?

I honestly don't know who is mafia but I think one or the other is.

@pzelda

 

[topsecret]

@pzeldq
I'm not buddies with MJ and switched (with agreement of a few others) to create a thunderdome... But then you switched to Argon. Right now he's ahead with a few votes.

If you want, I am fine with switching to MJ and being the one who lynches him. I am no more confident in Argon, but I'll vote for either. If I tie it up on MJ, he gets lynched. Would that convince you we aren't scumbuddies?

I honestly don't know who is mafia but I think one or the other is.

I have no idea why I said "a few votes." Argon is ahead by one vote.

 

[pzelda]

@pzeldq
I'm not buddies with MJ and switched (with agreement of a few others) to create a thunderdome... But then you switched to Argon. Right now he's ahead with a few votes.

If you want, I am fine with switching to MJ and being the one who lynches him. I am no more confident in Argon, but I'll vote for either. If I tie it up on MJ, he gets lynched. Would that convince you we aren't scumbuddies?

I honestly don't know who is mafia but I think one or the other is.

I guess. Tbh, I see you trying to prove that you're town and that there's no hidden agenda behind your decision, but sometimes it looks like you don't have no agenda. Sure, one of switching and leaving it up to Csargo isn't that bad as I'm 99% sure that Csargo's town with his attitude this game and doctor claim. That's def more of a reason to follow someone than whathever is your reason for letting me direct your actions.

 

[Takhisis]

Also, if there is a mafia roleblocker explain to me why they would block a guy who writes letters of no consequence? That's just weird.

How do we know that the letters are of no consequence?

 

[topsecret]

I guess. Tbh, I see you trying to prove that you're town and that there's no hidden agenda behind your decision, but sometimes it looks like you don't have no agenda. Sure, one of switching and leaving it up to Csargo isn't that bad as I'm 99% sure that Csargo's town with his attitude this game and doctor claim. That's def more of a reason to follow someone than whathever is your reason for letting me direct your actions.

Meh. I guess I'll let Csargo decide if he wants to vote for MJ. But I am more suspicious of MJ than Argon. I feel like we're just gonna flip a 3rd party.

 

[JohannaK]

Ok, quite a few things happened. GameZ's claim got way more interesting. It looks like he can send out multiple letters at once and more importantly it looks like he visits people too and can check, whether they're home. I think it's time for Jovian to claim. It can help us to figure out the situation.

How can you make up all this crap out of literal thin air? This post is a big question mark.

 

[pzelda]

How can you make up all this crap out of literal thin air? This post is a big question mark.

I read the whole interaction and this was my conclusion.

 

[LordArgon]

How do we know that the letters are of no consequence?

The mafia role blocking letter writer who can't even communicate with half the people vs doctor makes no sense at all.

 

[Timsup2nothin]

How can you make up all this crap out of literal thin air? This post is a big question mark.

@pzelda you really need to look at what you wrote there and go back through the reality of the letters. Gamez "visits people" to drop off his letter. Since I had his first letter I got to "visit" too. I dropped off the letter to G1K, as agreed during twilight. I didn't get any information about whether he was home. Reread, please.

But I think Jo might be trying to restore the whole letter issue to a prominence it does not deserve.

 

[Timsup2nothin]

The mafia role blocking letter writer who can't even communicate with half the people vs doctor makes no sense at all.

The mafia definitely have a doctor overcoming power killer...that's how you got Visor.

And yes, I said you intentionally.

 

[LordArgon]

Oh quit it Tim I had nothing to do with Visorslash's death. If I were a Maf I would have killed another person to throw people off the case. So quit acting like you know my role, especially when you have nothing going for you

 

[Csargo]

How do we know that the letters are of no consequence?

If we believe GR's claim at face value then I'd say they're of no consequence, since he's writing them. If he's town then he has no more information than the rest of us.

I can only think of recruitment as a possible relevant ability tied to it that's actually meaningful. Otherwise it's just a random night action for either alignment potentially.

 

[Csargo]

I think the best course of action is to just lynch MJ.

Unvote:, Vote: MJ

 

[Csargo]

If the mafia have a roleblocker it must only be a oneshot ability would be my guess, same with however they got Visor.

The simplest solution is just either GamezRule is lying about the letter or MJ wasn't at home to receive the letter imo.

 

[Timsup2nothin]

Oh quit it Tim I had nothing to do with Visorslash's death. If I were a Maf I would have killed another person to throw people off the case. So quit acting like you know my role, especially when you have nothing going for you

I'm not acting like I know your role. NO ONE knows your role. No one has ever had any way to know your role other than hanging you to see how you flip. That's the problem.

The mafia role blocking letter writer who can't even communicate with half the people vs doctor makes no sense at all.

This post is the immediate problem though. Throwing confusion about "well a letter writer isn't really a counter to a doctor" when we have already established that the maf has a power to counter the doctor. Argon, YOU are the person I would count on to have put together absolutely the most detailed examination of roles, potential roles, and how roles would interact. So how did that just slip through the cracks there?

The simplest solution is just either GamezRule is lying about the letter or MJ wasn't at home to receive the letter imo.

Having received a letter myself...I just "found it in the morning." I was home, myself, but I doubt that I had to be.

 

[Takhisis]

If the mafia have a roleblocker it must only be a oneshot ability would be my guess, same with however they got Visor.

Instead of a rôleblocker they could have a ninja or a strongman.

 

[GamezRule]

Having received a letter myself...I just "found it in the morning." I was home, myself, but I doubt that I had to be.

I actually should have asked you as well to see what type of information you received. I just reviewed the morning confirmation from the previous two letters. Yours was just that I successfully hired a local blacksmith's boy to deliver the letter to your place of residence, and the second confirmation was that the messenger dropped off the letter at MJ's place of residence and departed. The direct question of "where were you last night" was intended to evoke a response but instead we got 24 hours of silence, but I'm not changing my vote.

 

[Timsup2nothin]

Instead of a rôleblocker they could have a ninja or a strongman.

Which brings to mind a question I had about @JohannaK...the leap to "poisoner." I take it that is some official "standard mafia role" term, and when I went back and looked at Visor's grisly death I could see it clearly enough, but when I read it the first time I saw him as choked and stabbed, not poisoned. If people who are more experienced with the lingo all read that and saw "oh a poisoner" I can write myself off as a n00b and that's fine, but did that happen?