KotOR Mafia - game thread

[DaveShack]

Vote: spaceman98 I don't see The Black Knigh claiming anything.

 

[Mergle]

Vote: spaceman98 I don't see The Black Knigh claiming anything.

That's a bit trigger happy there. I agree with you that I'm not sure what spaceman's saying, but his logic is no worse that the Black Knigh's was. And why would the Sith be looking to construct a case against the Black Knigh? What's he done for it to be worth the Sith trying to get him lynched, especially using poor logic to do so when there's plenty of genuinely suspicious behaviour from Black Knigh.

 

[Xenoneb]

Mergle, can you explain how you did that. Vote:Mergle

 

[topsecret]

Vote: The Black Knigh. For much of the early game he was lurking. After Pizza issued an order for lurkers to wake up, he began overenthusiastically trying to roleclaim. Perhaps he wants to claim a pro republic darkside role so that when one of the numerous scanners scans him as sith, no one will care? Why would a townie want to roleclaim so badly? If he is buletproof, why not say it? Not dieing next night would be proof enough. If he is a power role, claiming and letting the scum finish you is unwise. If he is vanilla, claiming rules one person out of the scums kill list. Thus his overenthusiasm to claim is scummy. His latest post is even more suspicious.

This is not to say we shouldn't kill Earthling, but I think he can wait.

I didn't see a single claim. vote: spaceman98
Perhaps you would show it to us?

 

[mechaerik]

I think he confused Black Knigh with Gone 3 the Celt on that part.

 

[Dreadnought]

He must be. Strange that he wouldn't double check his sources.

Vote: spaceman98

 

[choxorn]

FoS: The Black Knigh for scummy reasoning and an incredibly annoying name. Why can't you just have a t? What did it ever do to you? Monster.

Because CFC doesn't allow usernames to be more than 15 characters in length.

Anyway, Vote: The Black Knigh, because he is still very very scummy.

 

[BSmith1068]

vote: Buddhafish. At least until he responds to my PM from this morning. I know you are online (and have been most of the day). It shouldn’t take that long to craft a response to my question.

 

[Takhisis]

15 characters. At least usertitles will allow me to get 'the Dragon Queen'.

 

[dcmort93]

I agree that Spaceman is a bit too trigger happy for my likes

 

[Verarde]

After re-reading the past page and a half...

wow.

There's a lot of finger pointing, but nothing really solid.

spaceman98 might have just confused TBK with someone else. But still...
Mergle is not worth going for, he could still be a townie cop. We just haven't had the ability to check out his story.
Earthling, not worth another attempt at lynching. Best bet would be for a town aligned vigilante or bounty hunter to take a potshot or two at him.
On Buddhafish, he's an interesting character.
With TBK, he's just been inactive. But it seems like he's coming back around, so I'm willing to back off of him for now.
NinjaCow's evident crusade against Buddhafish is a little worrying...

I'm going to FoS: NinjaCow and Buddhafish, while vote: spaceman98.

 

[SouthernKing]

Vote: NinjaCow64
I feel that he seems to be a bit overzealous in hunting. I may be wrong, but that's generally not a good sign in my eyes.

I have doubts over the strength of the spaceman case, if someone can point out otherwise I may reconsider.

 

[BSmith1068]

unvote. Response received.

vote: The Black Knigh. Both spaceman and TBK are suspicious in my opinion, but TBK is more so.

Now might be the time for both of you to start claiming some things, either in public, or in private.

 

[choxorn]

Being trigger-happy is not a scumtell. Mafia are more careful than that, they don't want to attract attention to themselves. They make cases that are safe and that they are completely sure are safe, if they even make cases at all.

He might be scum, but it looked more like an honest mistake.

 

[classical_hero]

Sometimes it is when you need to kill lots of people and even on the lynches.

 

[mechaerik]

After re-reading the past page and a half...

wow.

There's a lot of finger pointing, but nothing really solid.

spaceman98 might have just confused TBK with someone else. But still...
Mergle is not worth going for, he could still be a townie cop. We just haven't had the ability to check out his story.
Earthling, not worth another attempt at lynching. Best bet would be for a town aligned vigilante or bounty hunter to take a potshot or two at him.
On Buddhafish, he's an interesting character.
With TBK, he's just been inactive. But it seems like he's coming back around, so I'm willing to back off of him for now.
NinjaCow's evident crusade against Buddhafish is a little worrying...

I'm going to FoS: NinjaCow and Buddhafish, while vote: spaceman98.

I'm not really picking up a scumvibe from spaceman though, It seems like an honest mistake; he confused two lurkers who afaik are pretty new to this section of the site.

I'm going to vote: Ninjacow for now, and FoS TBK.

 

[mechaerik]

Of course, my scumdar is far from a precision instrument, so there's that.

 

[Gone 3 the Celt]

Guys, I'm pretty sure he means me, not the Black Knigh. Thaat shouldn;t be a reason to vote for him because he made a mistake in his post. I will, however, vote:TheBlackKnigh, seeing as he has not posted anything of use except for poor quality lynch excuses.

 

[topsecret]

Guys, I'm pretty sure he means me, not the Black Knigh. Thaat shouldn;t be a reason to vote for him because he made a mistake in his post.

Could spaceman please confirm/deny this?

 

[Gone 3 the Celt]

Because I didn't want to get killed by a bounty hunter. Until that post, I had only posted in lynch votes, qualifying me to be a lurker.

His latest post is even more suspicious.

Explain to me how this is suspicious.