Native American or Hindi/Southeast Asian culture group?

Which culture group should I use?

  • Native American Culture Group

    Votes: 2 14.3%
  • Hindi/Southeast Asian culture group

    Votes: 12 85.7%

  • Total voters
    14
  • Poll closed .
I say go with the Native American. Native American will look bad with the Mesoamerican cities.
 
I voted for South/SE Asian culture group (a predictable vote to those who have read my other posts), but this is a real conundrum. South/Se Asia has a lot of different groups with an overlay of the brahmanic culture (castes, temple styles, shared mythology, etc.). On the other hand, the Americas have a wide diversity of cultures. In a former incarnation I studied for about 10 years with an Apache and also with a Tewa shaman, and subsequently was a research associate at Children's TV Workshop, helping design a Native American curriculum for Sesame Street. Between all that I have had in depth on going conversations with cultural leaders for Haida, Pueblo, Navajo, Crow, Choctaw, as well as doing a lot of library research. When asked, they all said that they wanted to be identified by their individual tribe, not "Indian", not "Native American". An Inuit, an Iriquois, and an Incan are really, really different from each other; yet lumping them into some other culture group that has nothing to do with the Americas doesn't make sense either.
 
I would give all the Native American tribes their own groups(grouped by relation, such as Pueblo/Anasasi/Navaho or Mississipian or Pacific Coast for example, if it were possible BlueMonkey. Thankyou for your well-thought out response.

Shiro Kobbure and I have a Mod planned called Battlefield Asia, could I interest you in joining us in developing it?
 
Sword_Of_Geddon said:
Shiro Kobbure and I have a Mod planned called Battlefield Asia, could I interest you in joining us in developing it?

Yes! Thank you for the invitation. As I think I've mentioned in a couple of posts, I am sketching out a mod/scenario involving the Mahabharata. Anything I can do to help you also helps me in the long run.

At the moment I can offer you my research skills (texts, images, maps, etc.) and brainstorming + anything I can do on a Mac. I'm pretty much of a Mac man; my work life has revolved around that platform since 1983.:D so that's my platform for Civ (just installed C3C tonight). For work reasons I'll be getting a PC within the next couple months, which is the only reason I can even seriously consider developing a mod. All the software I use and know well on the Mac; The PC will strictly be for honing my Cisco networking skills, and Civ3 modding.:lol:
 
Sword_Of_Geddon said:
Shiro Kobbure and I have a Mod planned called Battlefield Asia, could I interest you in joining us in developing it?

further down the road I also want to try a land-locked "Silk Road" scenario, so I've tried to learn a bit about central Asia. Just let me know what I can do to help out.:coffee: (venti latte with 2 extra shots waiting for direction and purpose)
 
Back
Top Bottom