To be fair to imp I didn't even know that no exit to desktop was a thing. I skimmed the posts it was in, and only now have clocked it. I probably would have done it and messed the game up without realising if this hadn't happened in the next 5-10 turns. But he isn't a bad chap, and is a reliable player in the pbem games. It would be sporting of you to give him a second chance I feel... that's just me though.