Nightfang Mafia (Game Concluded)

[AvatarKhepri]

Are you also forgetting that I claimed to have redirected DoubleA onto murska?

Or that the possibility that scum got lucky with their first kill, taking out a seer?

Your hypotheticals ignore several occam's razors, so I'm curious why you are positing that scum knew a power role down to the player.

I was saying "the first part here seems to imply you think wolves have a significant information advantage, but the second part seems to imply you think that's why a vig and a seer are the first two to die, but that doesn't make sense if the reason the seer is dead is because you redirected the kill there". I'm not positing that scum knew power roles, I'm saying that my reading of your post gave me the impression that you were positing that, and I think that's a silly idea.

EDIT: Going back and reading the post in question, it looks like I saw a connection between the ideas in the two paragraphs that wasn't intended.

 

[Yakostovian]

I was saying "the first part here seems to imply you think wolves have a significant information advantage, but the second part seems to imply you think that's why a vig and a seer are the first two to die, but that doesn't make sense if the reason the seer is dead is because you redirected the kill there". I'm not positing that scum knew power roles, I'm saying that my reading of your post gave me the impression that you were positing that, and I think that's a silly idea.

EDIT: Going back and reading the post in question, it looks like I saw a connection between the ideas in the two paragraphs that wasn't intended.

Of my quoted post that started us down this rabbit hole, the first and second paragraphs are related. "Composition" would be players within a house, no roles within.

The third paragraph was merely repeating known information and speculating on what it could mean.

 

[Arakhor]

One hour left until dusk. Last call for daylight discussion!

 

[Arakhor]

Day Two

Discussion trickled on throughout the day, though everyone had already made up their minds long before lunch was served. The predominant call was for the death of the quietest delegate, who hadn't even bothered to turn up that day, so at dusk a party went down to his rooms and dragged him back to face his summary execution.

Choxorn has died!

Spoiler for identity :

He was the Sorcerer and a member of Great House Telvanni.

He was a vampire from Clan Aundae!

Final Vote Tally
Choxorn (6): Yakostovian, AvatarKhepri, Pzelda, Rakkoon, Topsecret
DoubleA (3): JohannaK, Beroli, Takhisis
Beroli (1): DoubleA

Not voting (1): Choxorn

 

[Arakhor]

Day results have been sent out and night time has begun. Send me your orders for Night Two within the next 22 hours!

 

[Arakhor]

No talking at night-time, please.

 

[Arakhor]

Dawn will come two hours earlier than scheduled, in six hours' time.

 

[Arakhor]

Night Two

Last night was not a quiet one. The hallways echoed with the passage of various people and then suddenly a horrific scream rang out. Wary of further vampiric assault, no one left their chambers until dawn, whereupon Rakkoon's battered and broken corpse was found, casually discarded in his rooms.

Rakkoon has died!

Spoiler for identity :

He was the Spy and a member of Great House Hlaalu.

He was not a vampire!

 

[Arakhor]

Day Three has begun! Midday will be in 23.5 hours (9 pm BST on Weds 12th) and dusk will be in 47.5 hours (9 pm BST on Thurs 13th).

 

[Takhisis]

Same as yesterday.
vote: DoubleA

 

[Beroli]

My reasoning for this is already laid out and unchanged: Vote: Double-A, the mute redirected killer of Murska.

 

[Yakostovian]

I attempted to redirect doubleA onto a target other than rakkoon.

It apparently succeeded to no effect I can tell.

 

[Takhisis]

Maybe AA's a strongman?

 

[Yakostovian]

If it weren't for the fact that AA has been strangely quiet, I would say we might have jumped to conclusions concerning his possible undead status, and it was merely a coincidence that murska died when I redirected him.

But his silence speaks volumes.
Vote: doubleA

 

[AvatarKhepri]

That quiet isn't any better in private. Vote: Double A.

 

[Yakostovian]

That quiet isn't any better in private. Vote: Double A.

since I'm the only one that doesnt know for certain who belongs to what house, are you claiming to be the same house as doubleA?

 

[Yakostovian]

Correction: since I'm the only one that doesn't know who is aligned with who, are you claiming that doubleA is part of your house?

 

[Takhisis]

Neither of them is in my house, if that's any help.

 

[Double A]

AA is a vig. AA didn't say anything in the hopes of getting another kill in before getting ganked by mafia but got redirected onto Joan. AA can't kill someone without spending a day action to prepare a kill. Hilariously, AA prepared to kill Murska on D1, so it actually went through.

 

[Takhisis]

AA (…) got redirected onto Joan

But JoanK is alive…

btw why does AA speak of itself in the third person?