None Shall Pass 2 [Game Thread - Concluded]

[BSmith1068]

Grumble. Grumble.

 

[SamSniped]

Well, time to defend myself, I guess. I am Gimli, and whenever anyone targets me with a night action (that isn't a kill), they are blocked but also protected for the night. I'll try to do some analysis and present some potential candidates later today.

 

[Arakhor]

So why did Christos finger you as someone worthy of being lynched?

 

[Legato Endless]

Hey, best of both worlds!

Vote: SamSniped

Woot! Vote: SamSniped

I just realized that the entire Morgoth faction died to night kills. Not a single one was lynched.

Sigh.

 

[Riedquat]

Well, time to defend myself, I guess. I am Gimli, and whenever anyone targets me with a night action (that isn't a kill), they are blocked but also protected for the night. I'll try to do some analysis and present some potential candidates later today.

But something failed there right? BSmith was carrying an action on you but there is no sign he was protected at all...

Am I wrong guessing more actions were carried on Sam tonight? Somebody else had to be auto-blocked...

Vote: SamSniped

 

[edse]

And how could Christos scan him? Vote: SanSniped

 

[Buddhafish]

He said he scanned him the night before. Not this previous night.

 

[SamSniped]

But something failed there right? BSmith was carrying an action on you but there is no sign he was protected at all...

Am I wrong guessing more actions were carried on Sam tonight? Somebody else had to be auto-blocked...

Vote: SamSniped

I didn't know that BSmith was carrying out an action on me...? I can't clarify either way, sorry. Possibly a kill through shields?

And how could Christos scan him? Vote: SanSniped

So why did Christos finger you as someone worthy of being lynched?

My guess is that the scan came up blank (since he would have been roleblocked) and therefore he thought I was scum.

 

[JohannaK]

I can confirm I was blocked tonight upon trying to scan Sam.

 

[Riedquat]

He said he scanned him the night before. Not this previous night.

O.o Really? Well that I didn't know...

I didn't know that BSmith was carrying out an action on me...? I can't clarify either way, sorry. Possibly a kill through shields?

Visor got killed that way but shown in the writeup...

My guess is that the scan came up blank (since he would have been roleblocked) and therefore he thought I was scum.

I would expect a blocked result on himself rather than a blank scan

 

[Buddhafish]

@Riedquat, at least I'm assuming that. I'm assuming he scanned SamSniped the night Sam joined the game, because he made his claim the next morning.

The original post from edse I was responding to from him made it sound like christos scanned Sam the night he was killed, in which case he wouldn't be able to share results. I hope that makes sense.

 

[Arakhor]

None of which proves whether or not Gimli is Town, of course.

 

[Buddhafish]

This is also true ^^^

 

[SamSniped]

I would expect a blocked result on himself rather than a blank scan

That's what I had meant, sort of. If the result reads as "SamSniped blocked your scan!" (which Joan could possibly confirm?), then it could seem suspicious. Also, I am not alerted to whether or not anyone targets me, unless Joan is lying (which I doubt).

 

[SamSniped]

None of which proves whether or not Gimli is Town, of course.

With Joan's confirmation, at least, it proves that I'm not insane.

 

[Arakhor]

Even if we accept that Joan wasn't blocked by someone else the same night, it doesn't prove that you protect them as well, given that BSmith died and he was apparently targeting you as well.

 

[edse]

@Riedquat, at least I'm assuming that. I'm assuming he scanned SamSniped the night Sam joined the game, because he made his claim the next morning.

The original post from edse I was responding to from him made it sound like christos scanned Sam the night he was killed, in which case he wouldn't be able to share results. I hope that makes sense.

I meant, how could Christos scan Samsniped two nights ago when people targeting him gets blocked?

This is what Christos said:

My ability is to see if one is town/non-town and his universe. There is a chance I am wrong (it does not say in the description how % chances I have to be wrong, it just says that there is a chance my scanning is wrong and I may identify a townie as a non townie). My scanning of SamSniped may be wrong, but if I am right, this is a chance to eliminate another non townie.

If you do not trust me, I call you to lynch me. At the end of the day, I will be proved correct and so I can laugh in the afterlife. I have nothing to be afraid, really. Just do not regret your action later.

It sounds like he really got a result.

 

[JohannaK]

I simply got a message saying "You were blocked!".

I assumed at first that I had been actively blocked, but if it is Sam's ability, it figures.

 

[Arakhor]

Which leaves an interesting question as to why Christos apparently got a result.

 

[Tanar Aerdoth]

I don't think Christos would have taken a message saying, "You were blocked!" to mean that Sam is non-town.