None Shall Pass 2 [Game Thread - Concluded]
- Thread starter Zack
- Start date
azzaman333
meh
I'm saying we've got someone who has killed multiple townies who everyone seems to want to declare as being 100% innocent and we should leave them alone.
unvote
edse
King
One is not multiple.
azzaman333
meh
My mistake, thought he'd killed a townie on night 2 as well. Still don't trust whoever it is though.
Well, that's interesting. The Jedi Order clearly aren't Town, but they may be pro-town. Morgoth appears/ed to have his own cult, given that Jar-Jar was a servant without a cover role.
If the slayer of Morgoth doesn't need the Town to win, then we can hardly rely on them to protect the town, given that they are only serving their interests in attacking Morgoth.
And given that is essentially the same argument that the Empire used (and were lynched for it), I'm wondering why the Jedi Order should now be given a pass, as we still have only their word that they're not anti-town.
Vote: Christos200. You're still being terribly vague about your ability. If you really have nothing to hide, given that you've now 'proved' yourself to be a scanner, why not reveal the actual details? It's not as if Morgoth's faction don't already know, right?
If the slayer of Morgoth doesn't need the Town to win, then we can hardly rely on them to protect the town, given that they are only serving their interests in attacking Morgoth.
And given that is essentially the same argument that the Empire used (and were lynched for it), I'm wondering why the Jedi Order should now be given a pass, as we still have only their word that they're not anti-town.
Vote: Christos200. You're still being terribly vague about your ability. If you really have nothing to hide, given that you've now 'proved' yourself to be a scanner, why not reveal the actual details? It's not as if Morgoth's faction don't already know, right?
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
vote: christos200
You're going to have to be more detailed. You said "the same as yesterday" but yesterday your scan was on someone from the Empire. The empire is now dead. So it can't be "the same". I need more clarification before I trust your scan.
You're going to have to be more detailed. You said "the same as yesterday" but yesterday your scan was on someone from the Empire. The empire is now dead. So it can't be "the same". I need more clarification before I trust your scan.
Riedquat
Prince
I agree with the rest, this time you need to explain yourself better and publicly, to start your results seems to be very detailed, so what else can you tell us about SamSniped?
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
And you scanned either a replacing player coming in or you scanned an inactive player who might've been WOGed. Why?
Legato Endless
Prince
I'm guessing, barring Serial Killers or other singular factions, we've probably got at least 4 if not 5 without counting the town. The Imperials and the affiliated Jedi make up two factions alone in Star Wars. I initially wondered if Morgoth was in a similar arrangement, but the flip last night put that to rest. Granted, Jar Jar being scum isn't particularly surprising to anyone. Morgoth being the central antagonist doesn't care about the thematic divide, which leaves a pretty big void on the LOTR side of things. If there's some kind of symmetry to all this, we'd have two factions nested there. There must be at least one, even if we assume the Warrior is a vigilante (which I'm inclined to).
Well, we haven't seen any Dwarves yet, the only (half-) Elf was a cover identity (Elrond) and no one from the Fellowship has flipped yet. Likewise, two canonical Ringbearers (Bilbo and Elrond) have turned up, so I'm struggling to think of any more potential LotR factions. (Maybe the Istari, but there'd be five at most and only three of them ever appeared in the source material.)
Snerk
Smeghead
I agree with the majority but let's hear from SamSniped too.
Internet Flea
Warlord
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2015
- Messages
- 188
He asked me whether I was a Jedi as well. They may have powers that only affect Jedi, but I wouldn't be surprised if they need all the non-Order Jedi dead.
The Cult of Tom Bombadil, of course.
And what might that be when it's at home?
Legato Endless
Prince
I was actually thinking White Council, but Istari sounds quite fitting. Admittedly kind of a mute point, since what they do matters more than whatever title they're saddled with.
SamSniped for now. Christos' timing is certainly fortuitous, but letting his claim pass doesn't seem smart either.
SamSniped
DJ Goodboye
Mind clarifying to me publicly and/or via PM?
christos200
Never tell me the odds
My ability is to see if one is town/non-town and his universe. There is a chance I am wrong (it does not say in the description how % chances I have to be wrong, it just says that there is a chance my scanning is wrong and I may identify a townie as a non townie). My scanning of SamSniped may be wrong, but if I am right, this is a chance to eliminate another non townie.
If you do not trust me, I call you to lynch me. At the end of the day, I will be proved correct and so I can laugh in the afterlife. I have nothing to be afraid, really. Just do not regret your action later.
If you do not trust me, I call you to lynch me. At the end of the day, I will be proved correct and so I can laugh in the afterlife. I have nothing to be afraid, really. Just do not regret your action later.
christos200
Never tell me the odds
Well, you can lynch me if you do not believe me. Just do not regret it later.
Similar threads
