Paired Mafia - game thread

[classical_hero]

Here is a list of those who are active in this thread.

askthepizzaguy 12
Jarrema 12
Verarde 10
classical_hero 7
mechaerik 7
Skwink 6
choxorn 6
BSmith1068 6
GamezRule 6
Turquoiside 5
Capt Blackadder 5
Kennigit 5
Backwards Logic 4
DaveShack 2
Zack 2
BigTin 1
Red_Spy 1
landlubber 1

I have crossed out those who not in the game any more to work out who might be the mafia. I am thinking that one of them might be a lurker. So ergo, invote:Turquoiside; vote:Red Spy

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Hey, Red Spy is going to be wogged anyway.

We can revisit that if he survives the WOG process.

The others aren't nearly as bad as Red_Spy, basically everyone alive has spoke 1/2 to 1/3 as much as I have.

 

[classical_hero]

Well with Red Sppy going to be wogged, no one will vote for him, so I will unvote:Red Spy

 

[Jarrema]

After not very loud debate (albeit longer than on other days) people decided to lynch Classical Hero,

Spoiler :

He was a townie!

A moment later, heart of Red Spy suddenly stoped and he died without a whisper.

Spoiler :

He was a townie!

Tally:
Classical Hero (3): Choxorn, Backwards Logic, Turqoiside
Mechaerik (1): Gamezrule
Turquoiside (2): Mechaerik, ATPG
Abstaining (kind of): Classical Hero
Not voting: Red Spy, Skwink

Another night begins


List of living players:
1. Backwards Logic
2. Mechaerik
3. Choxorn
4. GamezRule
5. Skwink
6. ATPG
7. Turqoiside

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Where is the rest of my team?

Seriously, that should not have happened.

 

[Jarrema]

Another night passed.
Citizens gathered... and they found that no-one was missing!
With their morale strengthen, they started to talk...

Day 6 begins! It will last for 48 hours.
Day 7 and further would last 24 hours.

List of living players:
List of living players:
1. Backwards Logic
2. Mechaerik
3. Choxorn
4. GamezRule
5. Skwink
6. ATPG
7. Turqoiside

 

[choxorn]

Hey, Backwards Logic, I used a roleblock on you last night. There were no kills last night. Care to explain that?

 

[Backwards Logic]

Wow, that's interesting choxorn, because I used a roleblock on you last night and there were zero kills!

I'm guessing after your kill attempt on me failed, you resorted to faking the scan to get me lynched and out of the way. I was hoping to find someone trustworthy to reveal for me before I broke the information, but alas, you've beaten me to it with this fake claim. Now, in the interest of not getting bandwagoned, I have to come forth and reveal myself.

 

[Skwink]

For all we know, Choxorn is lying, but he's probably the first person in the game to actually claim to use a lonely townie power, so Backwards Logic

 

[choxorn]

Wow, that's interesting choxorn, because I used a roleblock on you last night and there were zero kills!

I'm guessing after your kill attempt on me failed, you resorted to faking the scan to get me lynched and out of the way. I was hoping to find someone trustworthy to reveal for me before I broke the information, but alas, you've beaten me to it with this fake claim. Now, in the interest of not getting bandwagoned, I have to come forth and reveal myself.

Well, that's a very cool story, bro, but I have a question. How, exactly, would I know that you're the roleblocker? And if I didn't know you were the roleblocker, why would I pretend I was and blocked you, which would be easily disproven if someone else was the blocker?

I'd say a far simpler explanation is: I blocked you last night, said so, and then you, now knowing I'm the roleblocker, came up with this lame excuse to try to explain your way out of the lynch.

 

[GamezRule]

The wine is yummy.

Backwards Logic, though I suppose you could both easily be mafia.

 

[landlubber]

Dead's advice: try to tie the vote. If anyone sways it at the last minute, you have two scum (the person that broke the tie and whichever of choxorn/backwards logic turns out to be scum.)

 

[choxorn]

The fact that there are an odd number of us could complicate that a bit, and it might not even work.

 

[landlubber]

Come to think of it, why would Backwards Logic do something as ballsy as that if it wasn't true? He wasn't in much danger himself at all at that point. It just doesn't make any sense that a player as experienced as BL would put himself in so much trouble when day had just started. I mean, sure, he could be defending himself, but OMGUSing and roleclaiming immediately isn't your average defense.
But wait, why would choxorn randomly accuse BL either?
My guess is that perhaps both of them are roleblockers, and the killer was inactive. It's the only thing that makes sense.
Well, two people roleblocking each other on the same night seems pretty improbable as well...
I'm just thinking out loud here, but, the more I think about it, the more I think that neither of them can be scum. If I had to pick one out as scum, I'd say BL. It seems like he got panicky and conjured up this whole "I'm a roleblocker too" thing to try and get choxorn lynched.
So, keep doing what you guys are already doing, I guess. Lynching BL is the option that makes the most sense (although nothing is making sense anymore).

 

[Jarrema]

Dead people do not have voice here!

 

[landlubber]

Sorry. [returns to shadows]

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Choxorn, who was your dead partner?

Backwards Logic, who was your dead partner?

Whichever person is caught in a lie, dies.

 

[Backwards Logic]

Here's the thing choxorn, it doesn't matter you didn't know who the roleblocker was. The fact is because you knew you got roleblocked and you knew at some point someone was going to come forth and pin you to the wall. So, you took the initiative and accused me (probably because you tried to attack me last night, but really, you could have attacked anyone), making up the whole 'I'm a roleblocker' thing in the process. So far, it's worked - the initiative has gotten the votes in your favor despite the fact it's a lie.

My partner was Capt Blackadder fyi. Swink - the reason no one's claimed a lonely townie power to this point is it automatically marks them for death. There's no real protection in this game, so it's only a matter of time before they would die anyway. Choxorn knew he was going to die anyway if he didn't, hence the false roleclaim.

 

[choxorn]

My partner was BigTin.

So which is more likely, that I'm lying and got a lucky guess by claiming first, or that Backwards is lying and didn't have to guess by claiming second?

 

[mechaerik]

Vote: Backwards Logic

Sorry, but Choxorn's right on the odds.