[RD] Psychiatry thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tahuti

Writing Deity
Joined
Nov 17, 2005
Messages
9,492
In 2016, I experienced psychosis consciously for the first time. Back then, I was working on a video game. I recently moved back to my parental home, though the financial situation was rather precarious: I had to waste all my savings on living expenses because family finances dumped and I had no income. Worse still, my rig used for game development broke down and I had nothing to replace it. So I became depressed, and eventually psychotic. Eventually, the team tore apart, since I had nothing to continue the project myself. I was unable to get employed because of my local reputation as a psychotic, though I eventually found work as a medical administrator for a month, which I found that soul-killing and wasting of people's potential that I do not wish this for anyone to happen.

This particular episode made me wonder to which extent capitalism is the cause for most mental problems. To which degree would one estimate that capitalism causes psychiatric problems and other questions are for this thread.
 
Hm, psychosis (afaik) is the analogue to neurosis but for cases where (more dangerously) the personality isn't stable/very constructed. So if that was your diagnosis (and a correct one) you should continue improving your life. I have a person in my immediate family who is diagnosed with psychosis, and it can be very difficult (no doubt far more so for the person himself/herself).
Re capitalism: it causes crap to happen, including more mental issues, cause there is no safeguard against all sorts of injustice and (legal) violence. When societal care collapses, those with mental issues suffer more than the rest.
 
So if that was your diagnosis (and a correct one) you should continue improving your life.

Psychosis isn't necessarily correlated to the presence of a chronic mental disorder. However, psychosis is very often caused by external factors an individual lacks the means to deal with rather than a change in brain structure, which is simply an adjustment to it.

Hence, improving my life is accomplished by improving society first.
 
^Even in such a case, improving society is out of reach of any person. One should try to protect oneself - cause that is a bit more viable, imo :)
Btw, i am not an expert on psychiatry, so just cause i said something doesn't mean it is true.
 
I am sad to hear that.
There are seldom adequate words to make things sound better. All I can say is that the ride never ends, and new dawns will come.
Our society has indeed become unfair, where good people with fine dreams go under, while rotten scoundrels win...Makes me sad.

Keep fighting, and I hope you find your heart's peace and material prosperity.
 
In 2016, I experienced psychosis consciously for the first time. Back then, I was working on a video game. I recently moved back to my parental home, though the financial situation was rather precarious: I had to waste all my savings on living expenses because family finances dumped and I had no income. Worse still, my rig used for game development broke down and I had nothing to replace it. So I became depressed, and eventually psychotic. Eventually, the team tore apart, since I had nothing to continue the project myself. I was unable to get employed because of my local reputation as a psychotic, though I eventually found work as a medical administrator for a month, which I found that soul-killing and wasting of people's potential that I do not wish this for anyone to happen.
To be honest, this all sounds like really bad planning and careless behavior to me. You had no money, and instead of trying to at least find a side job to help with that, you wasted your time on something as unreliable as game development? And focused so much on it that, despite living with your family, which should give you some base stability, the fact that your PC broke made you spiral down into depression? Maybe I don't quite understand the nuances of the situation, but this whole thing sounds like there were some really bad decisions involved in this.

The way you're telling the story makes me think that neither society, nor capitalism have had much to do with this.

This particular episode made me wonder to which extent capitalism is the cause for most mental problems.
In general, I don't think it's fair to say that capitalism directly "causes" mental problems, but it's very true that environments created by capitalism have a lot of trap doors that people fall into - and there are more and more of them, as our societies become more and more complex, and the time planned in for "resting" seems to become shorter and shorter. That's especially true for American-style capitalism as the fallback options for people who don't work well in the system, or come from a background of poverty are very... basic. Being poor in America can be a drain on one's personal mental and physical health, and if you make bad decisions like having kids without a stable income, well, you'll probably not live a good life at all.

(Central and Northern-) European capitalism works differently, in that it weaves in social policies that attempt to push the minimum life that you can expect to have - even as a person who's in the middle of having to deal with a severe mental illness - to something that is livable, while not interfering with the good things about capitalism. In Germany, you can live a small, but decent life even if you've never worked and are likely going to be unable to ever participate in the work force. But of course that's a matter of expectations - will you be able to afford a high-end rig to develop games? Probably not.

Both systems share the pitfalls at the upper end of the scale, where there are very high stress jobs that can severely damage the mental well-being of people who can't deal well with the stress caused by such jobs. Other people will work just fine in such positions.
 
Capitalism causes mental health problems in one of two ways.

1) social construction of mental illness (I'm not saying that mental illness isn't real, just that it's socially constructed and I do think that some diagnoses basically boil down to "you're not an obedient drone"
2) increased stress on people causing and aggravating various problems

It's interesting that I see this thread now, a friend of mine just posted a thing on Facebook positing that the opioid epidemic is actually the result of a social crisis caused by hypercapitalism.
 
Liberty is completely illusory if one is denied stability and then judged by others on account of having pursued a passion for designing games. It's only a "waste of time" if you're under the capitalist delusion that expenditure of one's time is only "worthwhile" if one is getting paid for it.

While this probably isn't itself a cause of mental illness, it undoubtedly is an extremely aggravating factor. It's very hard to reconcile the fact that people are supposedly "free" with the social constructs that severely curtail actual "freedom" for all but the extremely wealthy.
 
^Another grave issue is that in a capitalist system those who are ruthless can go about far more easily than people who actually have some sense of pride, duty or seriousness.
So all sorts of clowns rise to the top, or at least have it easier.

I think that - at the very least - there should be mandatory public works done by money of the ultra-rich. As was done (already) in ancient Athens.
 
Moderator Action: Personal mental health issues have never been acceptable topics of discussion at CFC. Whilst the last sentence of the OP in itself might be an acceptable topic, it would need a good deal more explanation to stand by itself.
Please read the forum rules: http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=422889
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom