I liked the epic feel of RoN. It was (in my eyes) far better then any of the AoE games as it had a much longer coverage in the timeline, without getting out of hand either... and it didn't get into the futuristic stuff like Empire Earth.
I liked the historical feel, I liked the historical civs. This version to me seems to be catering to the adolescents wanting anime-style stuff/comic book style stuff... which is ok for them and it has its place... but RoN was popular due to its Civilization style.
Sure I like steam punk, but in RoN 2 I'd want a RoN with new mechanics, graphics, civs, units, etc. Not a complete change of theme! If they called it Rise of Legends or something like that (in the tradition of Age of Mythology), then I think that'd be neat.
I don't want uber graphics if the gameplay is weaker. Gameplay first, then graphics. Can't say so much of the gameplay, but it worries me when they focus so much on graphics. For some reason cities/buildings recieving damage in the style of AoE III worries me. Almost like it is more a movie then a game.
---
The alternative: What if they took RoN (updated as a version II should be with new mechanics, etc) and one of the mechanics was this... you could choose (at a certain point) to pursue more religious, scientific, or balanced attitudes. Depending on which (when?) you chose it, could have a significant effect on your civ and its tactics, perhaps even letting you switch every so often. It still wouldn't be RoN, but if you could toggle this option on/off before the game (IE if it was off it'd be more conventional) then that'd be really cool.
To me this game is like a steampunk warhammer style world. Historical influences, but not historical. No real historical civs, but inspired ones.