Smilie Mafia 2: Backstabbed - Game Thread [Small Mafia] [Concluded]

My uncertainty mostly comes from the fact that I'm still not sure how this power you are implying Murska has works.

If one of you could explain to me how its meant to work I would appreciate that.
 
I like Yano's list. Lock him town, fellow :smug:.

Vote: pzelda

I remain uncertain but I feel this is perhaps the best course of action
Chox isnt very active, but neither am I and he did not seem especially scummy from what little he said. I feel like I am usually wrong when I try to read, but I do what I can.

These are both posts full of uncertainity (Zack's points it out well in his response to Robert's vote). I guess you should question them both. In case Johanna, this approach seems to be consistent in all of her posts.

My uncertainty mostly comes from the fact that I'm still not sure how this power you are implying Murska has works.

If one of you could explain to me how its meant to work I would appreciate that.

I guess this explains Robert a little. Murska's power, :c5puppet:, redirected all my actions to Tak.
 
Pzelda, can you talk about your read on Zack right now? Mostly Zack, but also the people pushing/voting on you? Are they just wrong town or are some of them mafia?
 
Tally

---

Lynch

Voting: 13
pzelda - 10 (Xym, Murska, Choxorn, Zack, Visorslash, Rakkoon, Yakostovian, JohannaK, SouthernKing, Robert Can't)
Choxorn - 1 (pzelda)
Zack - 1 (Manasi)
Murska - 1 (Beroli)

Not Voting: 0

---

Empowerment

Voting: 10
Murska - 4 (Zack, Visorslash, Manasi, Murska)
Choxorn - 3 (JohannaK, Robert Can't, SouthernKing)
Xym - 3 (pzelda, Rakkoon, Beroli)
Zack - 1 (Yakostovian)

Not Voting: 2 - (Xym, Choxorn)

---

Day ends in roughly 7 and one-half hours from timestamp. (8 PM EST, 05/26/18)

Spoiler Countdown :
bla_1527379200.png
 
Pzelda, can you talk about your read on Zack right now? Mostly Zack, but also the people pushing/voting on you? Are they just wrong town or are some of them mafia?

Wrong town? I'm not sure about that. I was right about Tak being villager. Am I bad at mafia and being villagery? Defo.
My Zack read (which changed to tr) is based mostly on his activity today and on reads of other people. He questions people. I'm little worried about his townreads being unexplained, but I'm sure he will do that eventually. It's a bad read, but I don't think it's a wrong one.
From people pushing me, I'm sure Choxorn is mafia. Just read his posts. And I suspect Visor, who's deliberately trolling with some of his posts. I'm not sure about Murska. If he's Mafia, the plot is little shrtsighted and he used the same reason to suspect me as choxorn (who added a vote).
SouthernKing, Robert and Johanna have some questionable posts and activity, but I don't really suspect them. I guess there's possibly one wolf among them.
Beroli voting Murska makes sense from my pov, but it's possible he;s trying to stay off mislynch.

Btw, Why do you suspect Zack?
 
I'm a little worried we might be lynching a manic town caught in an unfortunate circumstance.

Choxorn and Xym each have three people randomly voting them the empowerment and they don't even want it. Hmm.

Johanna had a post about Choxorn(?) that was hedgy. I don't feel great about either of those two.

Not sure I buy Robert's confusion and uncertainty here, and he ignored the part of my question about other possible courses of action.

Beroli and Manasi are being wildcards. I think Manasi is trolling me and Beroli's process is a bit alien. :borg:

Hopefully this lynch works! :grouphug:
 
Wrong town? I'm not sure about that. I was right about Tak being villager. Am I bad at mafia and being villagery? Defo.
My Zack read (which changed to tr) is based mostly on his activity today and on reads of other people. He questions people. I'm little worried about his townreads being unexplained, but I'm sure he will do that eventually. It's a bad read, but I don't think it's a wrong one.
From people pushing me, I'm sure Choxorn is mafia. Just read his posts. And I suspect Visor, who's deliberately trolling with some of his posts. I'm not sure about Murska. If he's Mafia, the plot is little shrtsighted and he used the same reason to suspect me as choxorn (who added a vote).
SouthernKing, Robert and Johanna have some questionable posts and activity, but I don't really suspect them. I guess there's possibly one wolf among them.
Beroli voting Murska makes sense from my pov, but it's possible he;s trying to stay off mislynch.

Btw, Why do you suspect Zack?
I'm not actually suspecting Zack, just giving him a hard time. I feel like this wagon on you formed really fast with only one person (Beroli) not voting on you. He doesn't have anything to gain by staying off your wagon because everyone is already on it. I duno. I'd rather lynch elsewhere but I think it's too late to organize that.
 
End of Day Two

Takhisis opened his eyes to see Topsecret standing nearby. "What's going on? I thought I died." He wasn't quite sure why he had not simply been laid to rest.

Topsecret shrugged. "You did. But I have enabled you to come back during the write-ups."

"You can do that?"

"Um, yeah. I needed someone else besides the ol' King Smilie. He's getting annoying."

In the distance, the aforementioned Smilie shouted, "I heard that!"

"Really annoying," Takhisis responded. What was this King's purpose anyway? He didn't seem to do much around here.

Topsecret and Takhisis headed back toward the Courthouse, where a rather interesting scene was taking place. Several Smilies had gathered around pzelda and were questioning him on his business last night. They also seemed quite anxious to lay the blame on him.

"We demand pzelda be lynched! Give us pzelda!" The angry Smilies were eager to avenge Takhisis' death. But when they noticed Takhisis standing beside Topsecret, the lynch mob temporarily strayed from their quest.

"Takhisis, how are you here?" Beroli asked. "I thought you had died!"

"Yeah!" Rakkoon exclaimed. "You were dead."

"I am dead," Takhisis replied, "but Forumville is a funny place where the dead talk if you stick around long enough."

Topsecret nodded, but he was also deep in thought. Soon enough, however, he returned to the present situation and demanded the verdict of the mob. "You want justice, and this is the Mafia Subforum of Forumville! Someone must die. Who shall it be?"

"PZELDA! PZELDA!" The chanting drowned out every other noise.

"I see. Do you, pzelda, have a defense? Or do you admit to treachery?"

"I am quite innocent. But this group will not be pacified unless I die, so just go ahead and lynch me," pzelda said.

"As you wish. I suppose that you all have selected someone to take this :strength: empowerment I have offered?"

This decision was not quite so unanimous, but the Smilies reached a decision quickly. "We think Murska can handle it again."

"Very well. Here you go, Murska." Topsecret handed Murska the :strength: empowerment. Murska simply nodded.

"Are you ready, pzelda?"

"Indeed."

Takhisis stepped forward. "I will take care of this, Topsecret. It only seems right."

"OK." Topsecret simply looked into the distance, not watching the lynch.

pzelda was lynched!
Spoiler :
He was :scan:!
Spoiler :
He was Good!
Spoiler :
He had a Spot on his face!

Topsecret looked at the Smilies. The Smilies looked at Topsecret.

"Hmm. Interesting."

---
Tally

Lynch

Voting: 13
pzelda - 10 (Xym, Murska, Choxorn, Zack, Visorslash, Rakkoon, Yakostovian, JohannaK, SouthernKing, Robert Can't)
Choxorn - 1 (pzelda)
Robert Can't - 1 (Manasi)
Murska - 1 (Beroli)

Not Voting: 0

Empowerment

Voting: 11
Murska - 4 (Zack, Visorslash, Manasi, Murska)
Choxorn - 3 (JohannaK, Robert Can't, SouthernKing)
Xym - 3 (pzelda, Rakkoon, Beroli)
Zack - 1 (Yakostovian)

Not Voting: 2 - (Xym, Choxorn)

---
Night 2 has begun!

:faint:

Night will end in around 24 hours after this post, on May 27th, around 8 PM EST.

bla_1527465600.png


Send in your night actions. :hide:

You are allowed to talk in the thread at night. (Rule III, E)
 
Last edited:
With so many on pzelda, this isn't a very good day for data. Zack's town stock is sinking a bit for questioning the vote on pzelda without removing his vote. At present, I think Beroli looks a little better as well for being off-wagon, but I may be giving him more credit than he is due. I want to give some town points to Manasi for the vote on Robert Can't. I'm planning on voting for Robert Can't tomorrow until given a reason to look elsewhere.
 
With so many on pzelda, this isn't a very good day for data. Zack's town stock is sinking a bit for questioning the vote on pzelda without removing his vote. At present, I think Beroli looks a little better as well for being off-wagon, but I may be giving him more credit than he is due. I want to give some town points to Manasi for the vote on Robert Can't. I'm planning on voting for Robert Can't tomorrow until given a reason to look elsewhere.
I don't think that's wolfy for him

And manasis vote isn't villagery, it's a throwaway it doesn't matter at that point in the day

If anyone should go down in villageryness it's murska and I don't think so.
 
Choxorn and Xym each have three people randomly voting them the empowerment and they don't even want it. Hmm.

I should've mentioned earlier, but I was concerned if I'd voted for myself I'd cause a tie wasting the empowerment so didn't.
I mean, it looks like a much stronger arm than mine are!

As for Murska, I liked his posts D1 with the questioning and provoking discussion but he was quite quiet today. I don't think the redirect claim looked off, but the quietness doesn't look as good.
 
I find it quite hilarious that I'm not even slightly suspect when I'm a villager and in my last game as a wolf I got d1 scried and d2 lynched. Only possible conclusion: I suck at this game :smoke:
 
Thanks for hosting, Top. Your flavour texts are :goodjob:.
I won't be so serious next time. I was just overeager to make a good first impression
 
Sigh. Sorry pzelda. I felt your defense was good, but I also thought that logically Takhisis happening to die after I redirected you was too much of a coincidence not to pursue, so I didn't really have much to say about the day.
 
Back
Top Bottom