So which armed uprisings should have been surpressed and which shouldn't have?

[Bugfatty300]

* The Southern secession (free trade!! also, the USA doesn't deserve to exist, see American revolution)

Then the CSA wouldn't deserve to exist by default either?

 

[kochman]

Whoa, I think you've invented the hardest question in history.

Wouldn't even know where to start on this one without the forums demolishing me. College history students have nightmares about this showing up on the final exam in a much smaller form.

In all fairness, it's like 20 questions in one...

Obviously, the Whiskey Rebellion has the best name.

 

[Deaths Advocate]

18. American Revolution 'Merica
20: French Revolution
20. 1848 Revolutions
21. Paris Commune There could be a thread dedicated to this.
20. Pugachev's Rebellion
20. The Decemberists
20. October Revolution
18. Whiskey Rebellion
20. Shays Rebellion
22. Bacon's Rebellion Glorious fried pig flesh!
20. Glorious Revolution
21. The Levellers
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
20. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979 Religion.
20. Cuban Revolution. The Levellers
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
18. Velvet Revolution
20. Iranian Revolution of 1979
20. Cuban Revolution

 

[hobbsyoyo]

19. American Revolution 'murica
20: French Revolution
20. 1848 Revolutions
21. Paris Commune
20. Pugachev's Rebellion
20. The Decemberists
20. October Revolution
18. Whiskey Rebellion
20. Shays Rebellion
22. Bacon's Rebellion
20. Glorious Revolution
21. The Levellers
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
20. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979 Religion.
20. Cuban Revolution. The Levellers
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
18. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979 Ayatollah's
20. Cuban Revolution

 

[cardgame]

20. American Revolution USA #1
20: French Revolution
20. 1848 Revolutions
21. Paris Commune
20. Pugachev's Rebellion
20. The Decemberists
20. October Revolution
18. Whiskey Rebellion
20. Shays Rebellion
20. Bacon's Rebellion Bacon does not a reason make
20. Glorious Revolution
21. The Levellers
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
20. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979
20. Cuban Revolution. The Levellers
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
18. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979
20. Cuban Revolution

 

[Arakhor]

This thread is going places.

 

[Borachio]

18. American Revolution USA -1
20: French Revolution
20. 1848 Revolutions
21. Paris Commune
20. Pugachev's Rebellion
20. The Decemberists
20. October Revolution
18. Whiskey Rebellion
20. Shays Rebellion
20. Bacon's Rebellion
20. Glorious Revolution
22. The Levellers Yay! Diggers!
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
20. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979
20. Cuban Revolution. The Levellers
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
18. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979
20. Cuban Revolution

 

[King Kalmah]

How the hell does the "Velvet Revolution" warrant mention over the Hungarian revolution of 56?

(I understand the importance of the Velvet Revolution,but you said ARMED and that revolution was an unarmed uprising....)

and I love how you just simplified all the 48 revolutions like they were clones of each other....

ehh don't expect much from me in this thread since Civfanatics is mostly pro Soviet....

EDIT sorry if I come off as rude,but today sucked...

 

[Joecoolyo]

19. American Revolution murica bamp
18: French Revolution copy cats
20. 1848 Revolutions
21. Paris Commune
20. Pugachev's Rebellion
20. The Decemberists
20. October Revolution
18. Whiskey Rebellion
20. Shays Rebellion
20. Bacon's Rebellion
20. Glorious Revolution
22. The Levellers Yay! Diggers!
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
20. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979
20. Cuban Revolution. The Levellers
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
18. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979
20. Cuban Revolution

 

[Dragonxander PR]

Neither the 1868 Grito de Lares nor the 1950 (was supposed to be 1952) Nationalist Revolt, in Puerto Rico, should have been suppressed. Otherwise we wouldn't have the shameful condition of world's oldest colony--504 years (390 under Spain, 114 and counting under the USA).

 

[cardgame]

The people of Puerto Rico apparently don't want to be anything other than "the world's oldest colony", though. Excluding of course the 2012 results indicating a desire for statehood.

 

[hobbsyoyo]

Would someone mind checking the current tally for accuracy? I thought we were supposed to downvote by -2 and upvote by +1 but I think I saw some -1 downvotes. If you repost a corrected list, highlight the corrections in blue.

20. American Revolution USA +1!
18: French Revolution
20. 1848 Revolutions
21. Paris Commune
20. Pugachev's Rebellion
20. The Decemberists
20. October Revolution
18. Whiskey Rebellion
20. Shays Rebellion
20. Bacon's Rebellion
20. Glorious Revolution
22. The Levellers
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
20. Velvet Revolution
18. Iranian Revolution of 1979
20. Cuban Revolution.
20. Sepoy Rebellion
20. Naxalite Rebellion
20. First and Second Intifada
20. Third Intifada
20. Kurdish Uprising
20. PKK Insurgency
20. MEK Insurgency in Iran
20. Kashmir Insurgency
18. Tuareg Rebellion
20. Anti-Assad uprising
20. Libyan Revolution
20. LTTE Uprising
20. 1905 Revolution
20. Nat Turners Rebellion
20. The Zapatistas
20. John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry
20. The Peasants War'
20. The Spartacists
20. Spartacus
20. The Social War
20. German Revolution of 1918-1919
20. Constitutional Revolutions (Ottomans)
20. August General Uprising
18. Velvet Revolution
16. Iranian Revolution of 1979 I don't like fatwas. -2
20. Cuban Revolution