Originally posted by TimTheEnchanter
I'm running out of ideas, but...
Bob Gibson had his 1.12 ERA in 1968.
Who led the American League with a 1.60 ERA in that same year? Small clue: Despite that great ERA, he did NOT get the AL Cy Young award.
That was the year McLain won 31 games, so he probably got the Cy Young. May have been Luis Tiant?