OK I restarted everything, pitboss, game (from Majic Autosave - last turn), Hamachi. I logged in and paused with an hour and 30 mins left on the clock.
I was able to ping Elkad and Donovan from the Pitboss CPU, but not Majic, so I would suggest that if Majic or anyone else still can't connect that you restart LogMeIn from your Services application. I posted a troubleshooting guide early in this thread.