Don’t focus so much on Ukraine that you miss the severe threats to European security brewing in Libya.
That’s the message Italy and Greece are trying to deliver to their EU and NATO allies, but without much success.
Migrant flows from Libya are spiking again, at a time Rome is increasingly concerned about Russia’s growing influence in the unstable North African nation, wielded through arms supplies and
a potential new naval base in the northeastern port of Tobruk.
Athens has also sent two warships to conduct patrols off Libya in response to the migration surge and its strategic concerns that its archrival, Turkey, is working with the Libyans to carve up the Mediterranean into maritime zones for energy exploration. The zones claim waters just south of the Greek island of Crete, while Athens
deems them illegal under international maritime law.
Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani has described Libya as “an emergency that Europe must address together,” but a European attempt to make some diplomatic headway last week degenerated into farce.
EU Migration Commissioner Magnus Brunner, accompanied by ministers from Italy, Greece and Malta, was declared “persona non grata” in Benghazi, the territory of the eastern Libyan strongman Khalifa Haftar. Accused of
unspecified “violations,” the delegation was ordered to leave.
“Russia’s role in Libya continues to expand, using it as the central node in its African strategy,” warned one EU diplomat who follows the dossier closely. The diplomat added that a politically connected smuggling network in Libya was supporting Russia’s strategic efforts, helping Moscow to circumvent sanctions and to weaponize migration.
Italy and Greece know, however, that tackling a problem as complex as Libya — a country more than three times the size of Spain — will require support from big allies such as the U.S. and France.
So far, however, the response from those allies has been underwhelming.
Migration again tops the agenda
The Greek government announced tough new migration rules on Wednesday as it struggles to cope with a surge in arrivals from Libya on Crete at the height of the tourist season.
“An emergency situation requires emergency measures and therefore the Greek government has taken the decision to inform the European Commission that … it is proceeding to suspend the processing of asylum applications, initially for three months, for those arriving in Greece from North Africa by sea,” Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis told lawmakers.
Some 9,000 people have arrived in Crete from Libya since the start of the year, most of them in recent weeks, already almost double the number for the whole of 2024.
Overall, there has been a 7 percent rise in irregular crossings in the central Mediterranean in the first part of the year. | Nicolas Koutsokostas/NurPhoto via Getty Images
In late June Greece deployed two warships in a bid to curb the recent surge of migrant arrivals. Senior government officials doubted their effectiveness, however, warning that naval patrols may encourage migrants to pitch themselves into the water to seek rescue. Sure enough, in the last week alone over 2,000 migrants came ashore in Crete.
The Greek government is also taking criticism from both the
opposition and
its own officials for having abandoned the Libya file in recent years.
Overall there has been
a 7 percent rise in irregular crossings in the central Mediterranean in the first part of the year, almost entirely from Libya, compared to an
overall 20 percent drop on all the other main routes.
The Greek crackdown has also triggered
fears in Italy that more migrants will be pushed into Italian waters.
“We are concerned about the situation in Libya and the recent increase in irregular departures,” a European Commission spokesperson said before last week’s EU visit to the country.
Being concerned is one thing, finding a solution quite another.
Diplomats described last week’s diplomatic mission as an attempt to determine what solutions could be feasible. EU cash, after all, would likely play some role. The EU struck a highly controversial deal with Tunisia in 2023 in which it paid the authorities to stem migrations, but diplomats doubt such a model could be replicated in a country as destabilized by rival militias as Libya.
Russians at the gate
A recent
display of Russian weapons in Benghazi during a military parade showed the Kremlin's growing proximity to Haftar.
Russia wants a stronghold in the Mediterranean, especially after the new authorities in Syria
terminated Moscow’s lease at the Port of Tartus after the fall of Bashar al-Assad. Italy’s Tajani issues
regular warnings that Libya is the most likely destination for a replacement naval base.
According to
a report by the Agenzia Nova news agency, Moscow also wants to install missile systems at a military base in Sebha in southern Libya, which is controlled by Haftar, and to point the rockets at Europe.
Many analysts and diplomats are skeptical that Moscow is already at the stage of pointing rockets at Europe from Libya. But even without the missiles, Russia can already use a handful of military bases in Libya for logistics, "which theoretically could hit Europe,” said Arturo Varvelli, a senior policy fellow for the European Council on Foreign Relations.
So far, Russia has mainly used Libyan bases to run its operations in the rest of Africa,
operating mainly through
the Africa Corps, backed by Russia’s defense ministry.
The Greek government announced tough new migration rules on Wednesday as it struggles to cope with a surge in arrivals from Libya on Crete at the height of the tourist season. | Yannis Kolesidis/EPA
There are also growing fears among southern European officials that Russia could soon be able to harness migration from Libya in a rerun of the hybrid war it launched
on the EU’s eastern front, when it forced Middle Eastern refugees over the Belarusian border into Poland.
Still, not everything is going Russia’s way. One of the diplomats said the costs of the war in Ukraine were depriving the Africa Corps of the funding it needed to pay Libyan militias, creating tensions with its proxies and Haftar.
“I don’t see the Russians taking over” the migrant smuggling business, said Karim Mezran, a resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, but “I see the Russians telling the people: Now I’m the new ruler and you just follow my orders
.”
A quest for allies
Despite the gravity of these threats from Libya, Italy and Greece are struggling to convince their allies to step up.
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni discussed Libya with French President Emmanuel Macron at a
three-hour meeting in Rome on June 4.
Libya “is of course a topic of key relevance for both Italy and France,” said an Italian official with direct knowledge of the talks between Paris and Rome, stressing “common concerns, especially on security — as regards also Russia’s increasing presence there — and migration.”
The Italian official, however, acknowledged that there are “nuances” between the two countries’ positions “on the possible political solutions.”
Libya is increasingly being added to the agenda of more diplomatic talking shops, but in practical terms little is happening. While Italy desperately wants buy-in from military heavyweight France, the subject simply isn’t as vital to Paris as it is to Rome, and even exposes France’s
recent failures in Mali and Niger.
“For Italy, the question of Libya is more central in the short term than for France,” said Virginie Collombier, a professor at Luiss University in Rome and an expert on Libya.
“Politically, the French government has little interest in crying wolf on Russia because it highlights the failures of the French government,” she said, noting that France
has gradually withdrawn from African countries in the Sahel region while Russia has upped its presence.
And with the U.S. increasingly looking to the Pacific, there is scant hope that Washington will invest much political capital in stabilizing the country.
Most tellingly, the most recent
NATO declaration, signed June 25 in The Hague, doesn’t even mention Africa.
“No one wanted divisive issues [included] as NATO now has a very minimalist agenda,” said Alessandro Marrone, head of the defense, security and space program at the Rome-based Istituto Affari Internazionali think tank.
That’s a bitter pill for the Italians.
Rome has “now to face this reality,” Marrone added.
