I don't think you're hitting home with most of these accusations. Of the people you suspect, I am less than thrilled with the suspicions on:
1) Kennigit (His and Newyn's posts)
2) Newyn (His and Kennigit's posts)
3) Askthepizzaguy (Swing and a miss!)
I still don't see how Kennigit's and Newyn's mutual assurance clears them as town members. I have already explained problems I have with Newyn's claim to his abilities.
If you feel like it you could make clear why this marks them as townmembers
As for "
3) Askthepizzaguy (Swing and a miss!)" I don't know what that's supposed to mean, except what you said that for the sake of argument we should assume both of us are town members.
I'm still a bit suspicious of you, but:
Stuff we might agree on:
A) Kingmorgan (I voted him day one, he's done nothing so far this game except the D1 vote.)
B) Remake20 (Because he's lurking and not posting, that indicates a lack of town solving)
Snerk maybe but my gut says no. He reads the appropriate level of paranoia.
So, I would recommend we lynch Remake20 instead, since he will dodge the WOG today.
Or, a compromise, if you like:
How about Xym or Cuthilius? Xym is trying to lynch you, third on the wagon. But if someone scummy like remake20 was voting to spare Cuthilius day one, that would explain much.
The OMGUS is a powerful scum-hunting weapon.
But I do not believe that remake20's vote on choxorn was true OMGUS. It was third on the wagon and deliberately lynches choxorn and saves me and Cuthilius, who had two votes apiece.
I know that choxorn AND Askthepizzaguy were both townies. Therefore, if Cuthilius is a scumbag, that means something. It would also mean that Xym is probably a townie in those circumstances.
If I have understood you correctly (not 100 % sure I have, but still), I think you make a fair enough point.
The claim that Remark20 is lurking, I'm not 100 % sure on. You mean you have seen him listed as active on the forum without posting? I don't know how much I can rely on the idea that he is lurking, nor do I know how much I should care for the third on the bandwagon trend, but it does make some sense.
That sounded a bit overly critical, but:
You are essentially that he was trying to save another mafia member from being lynched, sort of braking his cautious lurking play style, right?
Alright, I'm going to give it a go. If he is a town member though, I probably will get more critical of y'all yet
Unvote; Vote: Remake20
as for Xym: As I mentioned, he did the exact same thing to me in NSP3 (as far as I remember). It seems to me this is how he usually go by things, so it's not something that really raises my suspition of him.
Hmm, I'm a little more torn on Lohrenswald now. They (@Lohren, what pronoun should I use to address you?)
he-him pronouns. I'm cis-male for whatever it's worth
Saying "they" about me is something else Xym has done in the past. Not quite sure what to make of it
are behaving quite differently from Visor's last game, in which they were town. Something about their behavior seems more controlled, too controlled. I dunno.
I suppose you mean something like "self-control". Like Askthepizzaguy said, I'm trying to play a bit better, but it's also a bit circumstance, really.
Consistency isn't really a trait I have, so I can't really guarantee I'll play quite as seriously throughout this game.
In this game he's far more open and downright reckless. I personally enjoy reckless, it indicates an open mind. As stated before, despite his really bad voting record so far, it's the towniest aspect of him.
nah, Lohrenswald seems to be the typical clueless townie Lohrenswald we know and love.
Well thanks a bloody lot, guys
Stop trying to make me not want to cooperate
@Xym, @Lohrenswald.
Whatcha doin to find the scums right now?
I'm just trying to analyse the posts.
These last two posts by Al Sipsclar and KingMorgan haven't really contained anything to raise my suspicion of them.
Newyn and Kennigit still seem kinda shady
Xym as stated I think is just playing his usual town game.
But my plan for now is to follow your idea on Remake20 and Cuithullus. If Remake20 is indeed a mafia, I'm going to cooperate more closely with you, and probably vote for Cuithullus next, as things currently stand. If he turns out to be a town member, I'll try to figure out something to learn more about you and Newyn.
(also Jarrema please notice the vote in this long post)
