Trial Poll: People vs Chieftess, Part II

[FortyJ]

President Chieftess has been charged with violating this law. How do you find?

Please vote Guilty,Innocent, or Abstain. This poll will remain open for 72 hours.

Charge: Violation of CoL.D.1.E

[b]Code of Laws[/b]
[b]D.[/b] The Legislative Branch
    [b]1.[/b] The Senate (Governors)
        [b]E.[/b] A governor organizes tile development his [SIC] province.

This charges Chieftess with violating COL D.1.E. This law states that "a Governor organizes tile development in his Province". Chieftess, in abandoning procedure, denied me my rights as a governor and chose to develop the tiles in The North Province (NP) of her own accord.She started doing this on day one of this term and is still doing it, even though I have posted worker action requests all over the DG forums. Chieftess has ignored these requests/instructions altogether and conducted her own worker actions in the North Province. So either way you look at it, Chieftess organized tile development in my Province or Chieftess denied me my rights to organize tile development in my Province, she violated the law.

The entire quote and relevant discussion can be found here.

 

[Goonie]

Guilty as charged. CYC has presented me with the evidence and it is clear that Chieftess commited this felony.

 

[eyrei]

If you are simply going to state which way you voted, don't post here.

 

[donsig]

Originally posted by eyrei
If you are simply going to state which way you voted, don't post here.

Why not we do it all the time in our polls!

I voted guilty.

 

[eyrei]

Originally posted by donsig


Why not we do it all the time in our polls!

I voted guilty.

Moderator Action: That will be 3 days for ignoring a moderator warning and attempting to mock a moderator.
Please read the forum rules: http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=422889

 

[Eklektikos]

Maybe now would be a good time to ask what (if anything) we are allowed to post here?

 

[eyrei]

Originally posted by Eklektikos
Maybe now would be a good time to ask what (if anything) we are allowed to post here?

If you have new information or a new argument, please post them. If you are simply going to say who you voted for, and/or attack those who voted differently from you, please don't.

 

[Strider]

CT clearly did her job as part of the presidents job is to:

# Organizes worker activities.

She did what she was suppose to. So I voted innocent.

Edit: Would this be considered as new information or which way I voted?

 

[GenMarshall]

Originally posted by Strider
CT clearly did her job as part of the presidents job is to:

# Organizes worker activities.

Removed trace of Voting preferance

Hmm, after looking through the Consitution. In fact Chieftess does have the right to Organize worker activities. This, IMO Conflicts with the Govenor's rights on Violation of CoL.D.1.E. I view CoL.C.1.G. as an overriding action that give the President the right to use the worker as he/she sees best

 

[Goonie]

I would also like to ask what we are allowed to post here. I see people posting all the time which way they voted in polls. I am confused. . Is there something in the three books that forbids us from posting our vote in polls?

 

[Strider]

Originally posted by Goonie
I would also like to ask what we are allowed to post here. I see people posting all the time which way they voted in polls. I am confused. . Is there something in the three books that forbids us from posting our vote in polls?

Eyrei also told us what we are allowed to post here.

Also nothing in the three books forbids us.... The mods do.

 

[Cyc]

New information. Please, let's be real here. That's what the PI threads were for. Just because some people refused to speak about the issue in the propoer manner (through the PI thread) doesn't mean they should get to spam this poll. If we can't say how we voted, then we shouldn't allow all this spamming either. This just shows how useless little boy boycotts really are.

 

[Goonie]

Originally posted by Strider


Eyrei also told us what we are allowed to post here.

Also nothing in the three books forbids us.... The mods do.

I dont understand. If the three books doesn't forbid, why shouldn't we post. There is no forum rule against it.

 

[Strider]

Originally posted by Goonie


I dont understand. If the three books doesn't forbid, why shouldn't we post. There is no forum rule against it.

Actually.... The mods can do anything they want to really... If TF doesn't like it then he'll do something about it. I believe it says somewhere in the rules that you are to respect mods and there decisions, but a quick skim just brought me this:

Respect the authority of moderators and admins.
If you don't like something that an admin or a moderator did, you can post why you think the admin or moderator is wrong in the Site Feedback forum. We encourage rational discussions of moderator actions, but posters who feel the need to insult moderators and admins will be punished.

So take it up with TF if you have a problem.....

Also I relize this is a spammy post.... but I'm trying to explain to goonie about this

 

[Chieftess]

Originally posted by Goonie


I dont understand. If the three books doesn't forbid, why shouldn't we post. There is no forum rule against it.

Moderator Action: I normally wouldn't do this, especially since I'm involved in this 'debate', but, I'm speaking as a moderator. Goonie, when a mod tells you to do something, listen. Don't argue, or you'll end up being banned. Same goes for everyone else. No further discussions. If you have any questions, take it up in a pm.
Please read the forum rules: http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=422889

 

[disorganizer]

*sigh* so we go thru that situation again *sigh*

btw: you forgot to say that you can still complain at sitefeedback forum or notify TF, our supreme god, about when you feel you were wrongly treated.

finally, you sound like this forum is a true dictatorship, which is not so (hopefully)

 

[Shaitan]

Moderator Action: Folks, we are at a tense time right now. Tempers are high and we (your loyal moderators) are simply trying to keep the flames from getting out of control. Normally we would not dream of stifling free speech (we actually get ragged quite frequently for our "relaxed" moderating style in these forums) but we must maintain control while we steer through this difficult passage.

Respect eyrei's directive, take heed of Chieftess' advice and rest secure in the knowledge that we will get through this challenging time soon.

If anybody still has questions or comments on any of this, PM me instead of continuing to spam this thread.
Please read the forum rules: http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=422889

 

[Octavian X]

As I did in the other poll, I will close this trial poll. Chieftess is officially guilty of violating CoL.D.1.E. This trial will now move to the sentencing phase.