Why were jews superior?

Keep in mind that nobel prize awards are often very political, and there are tons of extremely important scientists who never got one.
Yes and no.
What you're really after is that science, never mind the other things, does have political implications.

As for people not winning Nobel Prizes, that's the normality. Most scientists, even the influentual ones, will never win one anyway. They tend to die too soon, some new discovery overtakes what was otherwise a solid accomplishment, and then there's the whole tricky subject of what constitutes a "discovery" as per the will of Alfred Nobel. A background noise of some high-pitched whining from non-Nobel Prize Laureates and their supporters is to be expected (winning one gives you special parking privileges at certain US universities after all).;)
 
There´s no doubt that jews in history produced number of great persons. I wonder why? I somewhat should understand how they should get wealthy easier than christian in medieval times (interests on loans were forbidden by Church), but the number of great advisors and scientists (check nobel prizes) is unbelievable. I cant mock from fear abused by populists during various times. So were they realy superior race, or it was something with religion/culture?

I'm getting into this discussion late, but I think the answer is obvious.

Jews were prohibited from engaging in certain professions due to being surrounded by (usually) hostile Christian kingdoms. So they turned to professions which were then considered beneath most Christians. Moneylending, for example, was considered both demeaning and even sacrilegious to Christians. So as a result, a disproportionate amount of Jews became involved in banking. Same was true with academia. It was difficult for a Jew to work in a trade, as the guilds monopolized most of them, so Jews tended to gravitate to academia once there was a shift away from monastic academies to universities. Meanwhile, in the middle ages, most people made a living as farmers and tradesmen.
 
There´s no doubt that jews in history produced number of great persons. I wonder why? I somewhat should understand how they should get wealthy easier than christian in medieval times (interests on loans were forbidden by Church), but the number of great advisors and scientists (check nobel prizes) is unbelievable. I cant mock from fear abused by populists during various times. So were they realy superior race, or it was something with religion/culture?

One word: Latkes
 
There´s no doubt that jews in history produced number of great persons. I wonder why? I somewhat should understand how they should get wealthy easier than christian in medieval times (interests on loans were forbidden by Church), but the number of great advisors and scientists (check nobel prizes) is unbelievable. I cant mock from fear abused by populists during various times. So were they realy superior race, or it was something with religion/culture?

Short answer, the Jews were wealthy because their religion allowed them to collect interest and thus become rich bankers and loaners. Early Christians and Muslims on the other hand, could not. This created a cycle of Jewish wealth. Enabling them to send their children to good universities etc.
 
Can Isay something here?
The Jews of today are an ethnoreligious group, meaning ahybrid of their original ethnicity and followers of judaism regardless of their ethnicity.
According to the Tanakh, the Hebrews were founded by Ibrahim, whom God later renamed him Abraham,who roamed through the middle east from the Sumerian city of Ur under Gods orders. Later the descendants of Jacob(later renamed by God as Israel) became the twelve tribes of the Hebrew race.But back then,the Hebrews wer not a unified people, just tribes that enjoyed peaceful relations due to kinship(much like the Angles, Saxons, Jutes, Vikings, and Danes of Germany and Scandinavia). Later the tribes were unified by King Saul, later to be replaced by David of the Tribe of Benjamin. Out of this bloodline it is suggested in the Nevi'im that Y'shua(Jesus Christ) (the Nevi'imdoes NOT mention the name of the Messiah)or the Messiah would come to cleanse mankind of its sins.
By the time Jesus was born though, the Kingdom of Israel was merely a shadow of its former glory; after being set free by the King Xerxes, Nehemiah and his Hebrew followers rebuilt Jerusalem., and by the time Jesus was cruicified, the independent Hasmonean Dynasty had been destoryed by Antipater the Idumaean and the Romans and the dynasty of Herod had almost come to an end.
The infamous Jewish diaspora began after the Jews rioted against Romans, who eventually destroyed the Jewish rebels and destroyed Jerusalem again. Duringthis revolt the famous general,later historian under Vespaspian's house, Josephus.
The Jews by now a mixed enthinicy compared to their the ancestors, were compelled to hide in various corners of thw world, where they further dilluted their ethnicity by intermarring and accepting new converts(the modern country of Israel accepts Jews, regardless of ethiniciy, as one of their own if he/she is willing to immigrate, for reference look into 'Return Law' on Wikipedia ). The Jews after suffering proseucutionrefound their country through the help of the Zionists and Winston Churchill(he was Zionist all his life while being atheistnor Jewish by confession, an actual persuer of Social Darwinism).
The Haganah and Jewish people fought to keep their precious land as the Arab(persumed by some as the descendants of Ishmael, the first born of Abraham and the father of the Midians) nations tried to strangle theinfant country. The War ended with the Jewish nation wining the war,thus perserving independence.
The subjeact of whether Israel is supposed to exist is heatedly debated by Jews, for it is a sacred land that is in Jewish propehcies(look for eretzYisrael on Wikipedia)and some jewish theologians argue that the Jewish nation can only be found under divine guidance, which they believe the present country is not.
 
While very interesting, what exactly does it have to with this thread?
 
well i just got kind of carried away just by reading all those weird replies about Israel.....
Also sorry for the crappy English. You cant blame me because I was up at 5:00 am in themorning while writing this.
 
well i just got kind of carried away just by reading all those weird replies about Israel.....
Also sorry for the crappy English. You cant blame me because I was up at 5:00 am in themorning while writing this.
Don't worry about the English, there are guys on the boards that spent their whole lives in the US with worse Englsh than that. Quite a few actually. I don't remember many weird replies about Israel, but then again I haven't looked at this thread in about three weeks or so either.
 
Back
Top Bottom