A Tale of One City [Game Thread]
- Thread starter Skwink
- Start date
Skwink
FRIIIIIIIIIITZ
- Joined
- May 14, 2010
- Messages
- 5,688
Would of been fixed earlier, but the server's being a jerk.
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
Skwink
FRIIIIIIIIIITZ
- Joined
- May 14, 2010
- Messages
- 5,688
End of night 8
When the people arose they found General Olaf slain in his bed. Olaf was buried, and the people went about their debating. Now they were desperate, they knew the end may be growing near.
Spoiler :
Living
5) Verarde
10) choxorn
15) Jarrema
20) JoanK
22) Darth Caesar
23) Yoshiegg737
Dead
1) Red_Spy --Lynched day 1 --Innocent
2) Classical_Hero --Killed night 1 --Innocent
3) Ninjacow64 --Lynched day 2--Mafia
4) MoreEpicThanYou --killed night 1--Innocent
5) BigTin --Lynched day 3-- Mafia
6) Diana Abnoba --Killed night 3-- Innocent
7) Zack --lynched day 4-- Innocent
8) Johnhughthom --killed night 4-- innocent
9) MjM --Wog'd day 5-- innocent
10) CELTICEMPIRE --wog'd day 5-- innocent
11) Askthepizzaguy --lynched day 5 -- innocent
12) LordNwahs-- wog'd day 5-- innocent
13) Kennigit --killed night 5--innocent
14) Landlubber --lynched day 6-- innocent
15) Daveshack --killed night 6-- innocent
16) Mergle --lynched day 7-- innocent
17) BSmith --killed night 7--innocent
18) Joecoolyo --lynched day 8--innocent
19) General Olaf --killed night 8-- innocent
Day 9 ends in 48 hours.
I think we've moved into "Lynch or Lose" now. I'm not sure, but the theory that one of the just-barely-there lurkers is a mafia looks increasingly likely. Between Yoshi and DarthCaesar, I slightly lean towards Yoshiegg. He seems to have been timing his periodic inactivity to avoid WoG'ing, while DarthCaesar has only gone completely inactive in the past couple of days. I think Caesar will be WoG'ed if he doesn't vote today, so I don't think there's any point in voting for him, especially if it's not Lynch or Lose now like I think it is.
Skwink, if there are 2 mafia and 2 innocents tomorrow, what happens? Also, if DarthCaesar gets WoG'ed and turns out to be mafia or something like that, what happens?
Skwink, if there are 2 mafia and 2 innocents tomorrow, what happens? Also, if DarthCaesar gets WoG'ed and turns out to be mafia or something like that, what happens?
Skwink
FRIIIIIIIIIITZ
- Joined
- May 14, 2010
- Messages
- 5,688
I roll a die to determine lynch on a tie, so in a scenario where the 2 remaining mafia vote for one person and and the two remaining townies both vote for a person who is mafia, there is a chance that the mafia player will be lynched.
Yoshiegg737
Jungo Jungo
Using WoGing as a main argument is rather flimsy, good sir Choxorn. Perhaps sifting through previous activity might be better to determine the mafia as whatever we've been doing since BigTin's lynch is clearly not working
That's somewhat of a relief, it means we get one more day if we guess wrong today.
Now, my other question: Will DarthCaesar get WoG'ed or not if he doesn't post today?
Yoshi, that you haven't been WoG'ed isn't my main argument. My main argument is that you've been doing literally as little as possible to stay in the game. That post you just made is the only post with more than a few words you've said all game long. Now, normally mafia aren't lurkers to that extent, but JoanK and Jarrema both seem very townie right now, especially JoanK, and I know I'm townie. If I'm right about that, then two of you, DarthCaesar, and Verarde are mafia. You and Caesar are both lurking like hell, so either we have at least one extreme lurker-mafia or I'm wrong about JoanK and Jarrema. I find you to be the scummiest of those 3 by far, and the fact that you suddenly came out of hiding, late in the game, when faced with an accusation, does not help your cause at all.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
God, maybe we shouldnt have lynched Zach and ATPG, their rants gave life to this. I support getting rid of lurkers now, so Yoshiegg
Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
If Yoshiegg737 does not turn up mafia, then my suspicions turn to JoanK.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
To me? Well, you are free, but given that pretty much everybody agrees that I am townie I will turn mine upon you. Even you said I was, if I remember well.
Yoshiegg737
Jungo Jungo
Oh, the lurking. Bad habit of mine to do that often in Mafia games where I read the thread, but don't end up posting or voting, afraid to look like I'm bandwagoning or throw out a relatively poor case against somebody who was actually a townie. Mafia don't normally kill lurkers anyway, and surviving long towards the end is a regular goal of mine 
Anyway, chance of everyone changing off me, the prime suspect, is slim to none, so might as well throw out my two cents before I get lynched
Darth Caesar: Following my philosophy on lurkers, most likely a townie
Choxorn: Seems like one of the last players to be posting long and logical arguments. Of course, if you are mafia, the game is won. I know you are a particularly good player, so I wouldn't put away the possibility
JoanK: Well, 99% townie here, nothing much else
Verarde: I focused mostly on BSmith's analysis (well, not too much since he states that all 4 of you are probably townie, but anyway) and liked the point on Verarde voting pretty fast on BigTin. Also helped the case against NinjaCow, so likely townie.
Jarrema: Again, during BSmith's analysis, one of Jarrema's main points was switching to the NC bandwagon. Although, I do find that at the time he switched, the vote had already gone 8-6 for Ninjacow. It was possibly likely he saw BigTin's blunder, thought NC was done for, and switched for the decisive vote. Again, only possibly.
I'm going to guess Choxorn and Jarrema, based on my own guesses. My ghost shall win 100 virtual monies if I'm right
Now then, I'd not prefer to get lynched by hanging. It is rather painful and slow, after all. Can't you spare a knife or something?
Anyway, chance of everyone changing off me, the prime suspect, is slim to none, so might as well throw out my two cents before I get lynched
Darth Caesar: Following my philosophy on lurkers, most likely a townie
Choxorn: Seems like one of the last players to be posting long and logical arguments. Of course, if you are mafia, the game is won. I know you are a particularly good player, so I wouldn't put away the possibility
JoanK: Well, 99% townie here, nothing much else
Verarde: I focused mostly on BSmith's analysis (well, not too much since he states that all 4 of you are probably townie, but anyway) and liked the point on Verarde voting pretty fast on BigTin. Also helped the case against NinjaCow, so likely townie.
Jarrema: Again, during BSmith's analysis, one of Jarrema's main points was switching to the NC bandwagon. Although, I do find that at the time he switched, the vote had already gone 8-6 for Ninjacow. It was possibly likely he saw BigTin's blunder, thought NC was done for, and switched for the decisive vote. Again, only possibly.
I'm going to guess Choxorn and Jarrema, based on my own guesses. My ghost shall win 100 virtual monies if I'm right
Now then, I'd not prefer to get lynched by hanging. It is rather painful and slow, after all. Can't you spare a knife or something?
Skwink
FRIIIIIIIIIITZ
- Joined
- May 14, 2010
- Messages
- 5,688
Day 9 is over
Yoshiegg was voted to be lynched today. As per request, he had his throat slashed with a knife, instead of being lynched. In other news, DarthCaesar was discovered to have fled for the desert three days ago.
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Living
5) Verarde
10) choxorn
15) Jarrema
20) JoanK
Dead
1) Red_Spy --Lynched day 1 --Innocent
2) Classical_Hero --Killed night 1 --Innocent
3) Ninjacow64 --Lynched day 2--Mafia
4) MoreEpicThanYou --killed night 1--Innocent
5) BigTin --Lynched day 3-- Mafia
6) Diana Abnoba --Killed night 3-- Innocent
7) Zack --lynched day 4-- Innocent
8) Johnhughthom --killed night 4-- innocent
9) MjM --Wog'd day 5-- innocent
10) CELTICEMPIRE --wog'd day 5-- innocent
11) Askthepizzaguy --lynched day 5 -- innocent
12) LordNwahs-- wog'd day 5-- innocent
13) Kennigit --killed night 5--innocent
14) Landlubber --lynched day 6-- innocent
15) Daveshack --killed night 6-- innocent
16) Mergle --lynched day 7-- innocent
17) BSmith --killed night 7--innocent
18) Joecoolyo --lynched day 8--innocent
19) General Olaf --killed night 8-- innocent
20) Yoshiegg --knifed day 9--innocent
21) DarthCaesar --Wogg'd day 9-- innocent
End of day 9, Update straight ahead
Skwink
FRIIIIIIIIIITZ
- Joined
- May 14, 2010
- Messages
- 5,688
The Finale
Michael looked around at his last living citizens, Joank, Verarde, Choxorn, and Jarrema. Michael knew that he had failed in his attempt to protect his town. "Well now, which of you are the Adams?" asked Michael. Choxorn and Jarrema stood up. JoanK and Verarde immediately moved to attack Choxorn and Jarrema, but the two Mafiosos had become quiet skilled in combat over the last few days, and easily incapacitated Joan and Verarde. Jarrema grabbed Michael and restrained him, as Choxorn slashed Michael repeatedly across the body and face. Jarrema dropped Michael's body onto the ground, and asked, "Well, Joan and Verarde, you have two choices". Choxorn spoke up, "You can stay and be our subjects, or you can wander into the desert". The two townies knew they would not survive in the desert, so they submitted to the Mafiosos, and bowed at Choxorn and Jarrema's feet.
In the temple, Choxorn and Jarrema sat in their former thrones, and looked out their magnificent window at their city. Their brothers Ninjacow and Bigtin had been killed in this struggle, but their deaths were not in vain.
Once again, it was all theirs.
Mafia Victory
Zack
99% hot gas
This game is a perfect example of why the lynch anyone who even remotely tries to scum-hunt strategy is an abysmal one.
Also a great example of when a player, in this case Jarrema, is so incredibly eager to lynch the two most active townies in consecutive days, he is scum.
Also a great example of when a player, in this case Jarrema, is so incredibly eager to lynch the two most active townies in consecutive days, he is scum.
Yeah, pretty much. It's also an example of why one or two people scum-hunting at once won't get the townies anywhere, and why keeping the dead from talking makes the mafia kill active townies (See: Kennigit, BSmith), and keeps the dead innocents from calling out obvious scumbags like me and Jarrema.
Although, honestly, even with all the active people dying, you guys lynched two out of the four mafia by day 3 because they self-destructed. It shouldn't have been that hard to find the other two.
Although, honestly, even with all the active people dying, you guys lynched two out of the four mafia by day 3 because they self-destructed. It shouldn't have been that hard to find the other two.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
D'Oh! Well, my first game and I did horribly. But it was my first game. Some day I'll join another one.
Similar threads
